HARRISBURG — A Senate committee unanimously approved acting Secretary Cindy Dunn’s nomination to head the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources on Wednesday, despite some legislators’ concerns about positions on natural gas development and other issues advocated by an environmental organization that she used to lead.

Ms. Dunn, former CEO of PennFuture, defended the environmental advocacy group, but said she will use her independent judgment in her new role and be responsive to the interests of all citizens.

Her nomination still must be considered by the full Senate.

Sen. Gene Yaw, R-Lycoming, chairman of the Environmental Resources and Energy committee, flagged a PennFuture report released in January around the time Ms. Dunn left PennFuture to become acting secretary, that advises Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf and the DCNR to “exhaust all viable legal strategies” to prevent shale gas development on a particularly prized section of the Loyalsock State Forest in Lycoming County, which has complex ownership interests and is where two gas companies hope to drill.

Advertise with us

The report is advocating “public litigation against private rights,” Mr. Yaw said. “That really concerns me.”

“Maybe you don’t like the rights, but they have them and we have to honor them,” he said.

Ms. Dunn said the governor’s office, the general counsel’s office and the DCNR will review the “fairly complex” questions about gas development on the tracts known as the Clarence Moore lands, but the conservation agency has not yet begun to discuss it during the new administration.

Sen. Scott Hutchinson, R-Venango, said he has heard broader concerns about how many people who once worked for PennFuture now hold positions in the Wolf administration. Mr. Hutchinson did not name them, but Mr. Wolf’s director of planning and policy John Hanger was president of the environmental group from 1998 to 2008, and acting Department of Environmental Protection Secretary John Quigley previously worked for it.

“People get concerned about, is this a — and this is not my term — ‘shadow government,’ ” Mr. Hutchinson said. “Those words have been raised to me because people see this.”

Advertise with us

“No, no,” Ms. Dunn said. She said PennFuture is a large and diverse organization and people come and go from it frequently. Many of the issues the organization works on are also areas of government focus, she said, “so it’s not surprising that there’s some overlap.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com