A Pennsylvania judge this week will consider whether state environmental regulators were right to add together the air emissions from a well pad and those from a compressor station producing gas from a state forest in Lycoming County, and then evaluate them as a single pollution source.

Two companies — National Fuel Gas Midstream Corp. and Seneca Resources Corp. — that share a common corporate parent are challenging the Department of Environmental Protection’s decision to add up the emissions, even though the combined facilities are not large enough emitters to be considered a “major” air pollution source and therefore trigger more regulatory scrutiny and pollution controls.

The appeal is one of at least six that the companies — both wholly owned subsidiaries of Williamsville, N.Y.-based National Fuel Gas Co. — have filed in recent years to argue that emissions from separate facilities should be evaluated independently.

All of the aggregated emissions were below major source triggering thresholds, but the companies said in legal filings that the DEP’s “incorrect” conclusions about which facilities should be combined could carry forward to other DEP actions at other gas well and compressor sites, where the consequences might be greater.

Advertise with us

The DEP considers several factors when it decides whether distinct emissions sources should be grouped together: the facilities must be under the common control of the same company, share the same industrial designation and be located on contiguous or adjacent properties. The agency also looks at whether the separate sources, when combined, fit the “common sense notion of a plant.”

The idea is that a linked group of well pads, pipelines and compressor stations controlled by the same company and built near one another should, in some cases, be considered one pollution source governed by one, stricter permit that will curtail the sites’ overall emissions.

The department does not keep track of how many times it has concluded that two or more natural gas facilities meet all the parts of the test, a DEP spokeswoman said.

Regulators aggregate emissions far too infrequently to please environmental advocates, who see it as an underused tool for curbing air pollution from the industry. Most challenges related to aggregated air emissions in the state have come from outside environmental groups pushing companies or regulators to consider several separate natural gas facilities as a combined plant whose emissions would be high enough to require more pollution controls.

“The difference between a major source and something that is not treated as a major source has pretty significant public health implications,” said Joseph Otis Minott, executive director of the Clean Air Council, which persuaded DEP to make its aggregation analyses more transparent as part of a legal settlement.

Advertise with us

Even when combined emissions don’t meet the major source threshold, a company might fight a DEP aggregation decision that could affect future operations, like how added emissions from more well pads or expanded facilities in the same area might be treated, Mr. Minott suggested.

In the current case before the Environmental Hearing Board, National Fuel Gas Midstream and Seneca Resources argue that none of the criteria in the three-part test apply to their sites.

The companies are fighting the idea that a well pad operated by Seneca and a compressor station operated by National Fuel Gas Midstream fall under one company’s common control because they are linked by a pipeline and share a common corporate parent.

The companies also say the facilities are too far apart, separated by about a quarter of a mile of undeveloped Tiadaghton State Forest, to be considered adjacent.

The companies have pointed to other aggregation cases involving other businesses to claim the department is applying an inconsistent interpretation of what can be considered a “plant.”

Advertise with us

“Having articulated its ‘common sense notion of plant’ in two separate filings with the board, the department cannot, to obtain the litigation result it wants, suddenly find that it has lost its ‘common sense’ and has developed a new interpretation,” an attorney for Seneca Resources wrote.

Regulators changed their minds on other contested single source determinations involving Seneca and National Fuel Gas Midstream sites, finding after a new review that “the distance between them, the varying terrain between them, and the existence of separate right-of-way agreements supports a conclusion that these facilities do not meet the common sense notion of a plant.”

DEP revisited its determination in this case in March but stuck to the conclusion it first reached in 2013.

Regulators said the companies share a number of executive officers and the corporate parent’s operations “are integrated to such an extent that its different branches are more like different sections of one organization, as opposed to entirely separate organizations.”

In other challenged aggregation analyses for the two companies, DEP has quoted National Fuel Gas Co.’s annual report, in which the company boasts that a “clear advantage” of its integrated business model “is the system’s ability to build synergies across operating segments.”

Advertise with us

“This is amply demonstrated,” the company wrote, “by National Fuel’s Appalachian development projects, where the Company’s upstream and midstream businesses work as a unit.”

Michael Krancer, an attorney with Blank Rome, who was DEP secretary when the current policy for guiding air aggregation decisions was developed, said the fact that the two companies in this case share a common corporate parent makes it a little different than most other cases that have involved facilities owned by completely unrelated companies, but that does not necessarily mean that the natural gas facilities are under common control.

“The corporate structure of these things usually is pretty complex, and they make decisions independently,” he said.

The board’s decision in this case could affect other companies with a similar corporate structure, he said.

The hearing in the case is scheduled to begin today in front of Judge Steven Beckman in Erie.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com