Divisions were stark on Wednesday when hundreds of people filled a ballroom in Washington, Pa., to show support for or opposition to proposed revisions to the state's environmental standards at oil and gas well sites.

One by one, those who had signed up to speak -- at the start of the meeting, 68 people -- had five minutes before representatives of the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection.

It was a diverse group with a wide range of concerns, some specific and some broad, and who all had a similar message: Our way of life is under threat.

At issue are a spate of revisions to the state's rulebook for construction and operation of oil and gas wells. They address myriad aspects of above-ground waste handling, spill prevention well permitting and a host of off-site issues.

Advertise with us

Washington's was one of three public hearings added to the schedule because of the volume of comments, DEP officials said.

On Wednesday, some speakers demanded that the regulations go further and claimed drilling operations would contaminate their land, water and children. Others have ridden the boom as part of an ancillary business and opposed stricter rules, aligning themselves with the industry.

Eric Cowden, community outreach manager for the Marcellus Shale Coalition, a trade group representing the unconventional drillers, called the proposed regulations "vague and inconsistent" and said they exceed the department's authority.

He listed what he said were the oil and gas industry's far-reaching benefits: lower power costs, increased sales of seed and fertilizer on farms, $2.3 billion in taxes since 2008 and $830 million in impact fees over the last three years.

"These benefits, unfortunately, are at risk," Mr. Cowden said. "We are, therefore, very concerned about regulations which seek to hold the natural gas industry to different standards than any other industry."

Advertise with us

Some spoke on behalf of conventional oil producers, which typically drill shallower and vertical wells than those in the Marcellus and Utica shale plays, distanced themselves from the large energy corporations and questioned why they are subject to regulations at all.

Joseph Thompson said he is the third generation of his family's conventional oil drilling business that since 1947 has operated safely in "the rural, economically depressed counties of northwestern Pennsylvania."

"In many of these communities, ours is the only industry left," Mr. Thompson said. "We are the people you bump into at the grocery store. ... Don't confuse us with Chevrons, Shells and Senecas," referring to the large, out-of-state oil and gas companies.

"I am forced to ask the question: What has changed in the operations of the conventional oil and gas industry since the 1960s? And the answer is nothing," he went on. "We are the local hardware store; you're treating us like Wal-Mart."

Boyd Ramsey, chief engineer of GSE Environmental, defended the industry's use of an open-air storage pits for large volumes of brine waste and said the DEP was "missing the curve" by proposing to eliminate them. His firm, based in Houston, Texas, manufactures a lining that is holding waste and protecting groundwater supplies at sites ranging from local landfills to nuclear plants around the world, he said.

Advertise with us

"My message to you is: This has been done before, the technology is well-established, and there are people in the commonwealth who can tell you how to do this with global best practices," he said. "You guys are missing the curve by a fair amount."

One man from Greene County recited a lengthy list of chemicals that have been found in the local creeks.

"We in rural Pennsylvania are being treated like a Third World playground for the extraction industry!" he yelled.

Bernadette Puzzuole of the Pittsburgh Airport Area Chamber of Commerce disagreed strongly.

"Many view the drilling industry as the goose that has laid a golden egg in Western Pennsylvania," Ms. Puzzuole said. "We challenge anyone who tries to get in its way, including the DEP."

Advertise with us

Hearings on these rules have often been the most well-attended in Washington because of the industry's presence in the area, said DEP spokesman John Poister.

The DEP will hold another meeting today in Warren and the last one on May 4 in Williamsport.

[This story was updated on May 1 to clarify comments made by one of the speakers.]