A section of Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf’s proposed severance tax bill that would prohibit companies from sharing the cost of the tax with natural gas leaseholders is raising questions among Republicans in the General Assembly who doubt the proposal is legal.
Several senators flagged the issue during recent budget hearings and pointed to a common term in existing lease contracts that allows natural gas producers to deduct the landowner’s fraction of a severance tax from royalties.
“That’ll be in court pretty quick,” Sen. Lisa Baker, R-Luzerne, warned acting Department of Environmental Protection Secretary John Quigley during a budget hearing for his agency, after she asked him if he had gotten legal guidance that the administration’s proposal is valid.
The Wolf administration is confident its plan to protect leaseholders from having to pay the severance tax is on firm legal ground based on legal precedent and past acts by the General Assembly, regardless of what leases say.
The language of the relevant part of the proposed severance tax bill is borrowed nearly directly from the 2012 law that established the current impact fee on shale gas wells, which also prohibited companies from passing on the costs to landowners, Mr. Wolf’s director of planning and policy John Hanger said.
“We’re confident that the language that stops the impact fee from being deducted from royalties also would stop any severance tax from being deducted from royalties,” he said.
“This language has a strong legal basis, and it’s certainly got an even stronger equitable basis — it’s fair, in other words.”
The impact fee law and the proposed severance tax bill both contain clauses that prohibit companies from making the fee or tax an obligation of a landowner, and they both declare the parts of any existing or future leases that contradict that ban to be illegal.
Oil and gas lawyers caution that the impact fee is unique from a severance tax in ways that make the equivalence shaky.
The impact fee that companies currently pay to the state and to local governments is based on the number of wells they drill. A severance tax is based on the volume and value of gas flowing from wells.
Gas leases have traditionally required production companies to shoulder the costs of building a well up until the point of production, which, in Pennsylvania, would include the cost of the impact fee that is assessed at the start of drilling, said George Bibikos, an oil and gas attorney with the firm K&L Gates.
But leases have traditionally required landowners with a royalty stake in the well to share the costs for things like transportation, marketing and severance taxes that add up after the gas is produced.
Mr. Wolf’s proposal, he said, “is fundamentally at odds with every other state that I’m aware of that allows those costs to be shared.”
The bigger issue, though, is that the legislation could be seen to violate principles in the federal and state constitutions that protect against government interference in existing private contracts.
“It certainly opens itself up to a constitutional challenge on the day of enactment,” he said.
Doug Clark, an oil and gas attorney in northeastern Pennsylvania who represents landowners, also questioned the constitutionality of the leaseholder protections in the proposed bill.
“When I saw it, I thought, that’s wonderful. It takes on so many concerns from my clients and the landowners that I care about. But I just don’t know how that can ever happen,” he said.
He worries that even in the event that the severance tax passes as it’s currently proposed, a court could toss out the leaseholder protections and leave the many landowners whose leases call for sharing a severance tax with an unexpected burden.
His clients share his skepticism, he said.
“I talk to so many people and I’ve never talked to somebody who said, ‘This legislation’s great. It’s going to result in tax benefits for the state while not taking anything from the landowner.’ I haven’t heard that once.”
Mr. Wolf, a Democrat who took office in January, is proposing a 5 percent tax on the value of gas and natural gas liquids produced from shale wells, plus 4.7 cents per thousand cubic feet on the volume of the natural gas. His proposal sets a $2.97 per thousand cubic feet minimum value for shale gas, regardless of the actual sale price.
Mr. Wolf’s proposed budget directs the money from the tax to education and environmental protection programs, while maintaining funding for communities that host wells at roughly the same level they are expected to receive this year from the current impact fee.
Mr. Hanger emphasized that the governor “stands squarely with the landowners to make sure that royalty payments are full and fair.”
The government can modify contracts in some situations if clauses are against the public interest, he said.
“General assemblies have much broader latitude here than one perhaps might think,” he said.
Bruce Ledewitz, a Duquesne University law professor who specializes in constitutional law, said legal precedent supports the idea that the state could prohibit companies from sharing the costs of the severance tax with landowners, even if their lease contracts say otherwise.
The constitutional prohibition on interference with the requirements of contracts has been interpreted to allow for states to create generally applicable laws that are in the broader public interest since the 1930s, he said.
“I wouldn’t think that this would be a problem,” he said.
A spokeswoman for Attorney General Kathleen Kane did not directly answer a question about whether it would be legal to bar companies from deducting the cost of the severance tax from royalties in instances where existing lease contracts allow for the deductions.
She said the Attorney General’s office has not received a request for a legal opinion on the legality of the provision.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.