Pennsylvania environmental regulators are endorsing a stricter limit for smog pollution that has been proposed by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to improve air quality and protect public health, even though they said meeting that standard will be a significant challenge for the state.

The state Department of Environmental Protection said in a letter to the EPA last week that the safe concentration of smog-forming ozone should be set at or below 70 parts per billion — within the range of 65 parts per billion to 70 parts per billion that the EPA is proposing, and below the current standard of 75 parts per billion that was set in 2008.

One air quality monitor in Allegheny County is the only Pennsylvania sampling point not meeting the current ozone standard, DEP wrote in its comment letter on the proposed change, but roughly 90 percent of the monitored areas in the state would violate a 65 parts-per-billion standard if the lower proposed limit were put in place right away.

EPA expects the new standard, whichever limit is adopted, will be fully implemented by 2025.

Advertise with us

Industry groups, Republican congressional leaders and some states say the costs of compliance could be overwhelming. They are fighting the proposed new limits, which the Obama administration already withdrew once in response to opposition in 2011.

The EPA’s science advisory board has recommended since 2008 that the health-based ozone standard be set between 60 and 70 parts per billion.

“It will be a significant challenge for states, including Pennsylvania, to attain a more stringent ozone standard at or below 70 (parts per billion),” DEP policy director Patrick McDonnell wrote. Nevertheless, state environmental regulators recommend the EPA adopt that standard because they said scientific evidence suggests the current ozone limit is not adequately protecting public health.

Ground-level ozone, the main component of smog, is a corrosive gas formed when other pollutants emitted by vehicles, factories and power plants combine in the presence of sunlight. It can trigger or worsen breathing problems, cause premature death from lung or heart diseases and damage sensitive plants.

EPA officials project that most of the country could meet either a 70 or 65 parts per billion standard by 2025 with air quality rules that are already in place or under way. But three counties in southwestern Pennsylvania — Allegheny, Beaver and Indiana — are among those that likely would require additional emissions controls if the standard is set at 65 parts per billion.

Advertise with us

Business and industry groups who also responded to the EPA’s air quality proposal before the comment period closed last Tuesday urged federal regulators to keep the ozone standard where it is.

The American Petroleum Institute, citing a February study commissioned by the National Association of Manufacturers, said the proposed regulation could reduce U.S. gross domestic product by $140 billion per year and cause significant job losses, which is in itself a health risk.

The Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry said the state should be given the chance to meet the current standard and evaluate the lower levels promised over time by other recent air quality rules, before the EPA establishes a new one.

“A lower ozone standard would require Pennsylvania to drastically ramp up the time frame in which such reductions would occur, with great cost to industry and consumers,” Kevin Sunday, the chamber’s government affairs manager, wrote.

The Pennsylvania Independent Oil & Gas Association, a Wexford-based trade group, summed up its concerns with the proposed rule under the heading “Too Much, Too Soon,” while FirstEnergy Corp., the Akron, Ohio-based owner of power plants and utilities across Pennsylvania and several states, said the scientific evidence cited by the EPA does not establish that the existing standard is no longer protective enough.

Advertise with us

Health, medical and environmental groups including the American Lung Association and American Academy of Pediatrics are pushing for even greater reductions — to 60 parts per billion — and EPA also accepted comments on that proposed limit.

A group of seven health and environmental organizations that work in southwestern Pennsylvania wrote that the state could significantly reduce ozone-forming emissions at very little cost if Pennsylvania’s coal-fired power plants “properly and consistently” used the state-of-the-art pollution control devices they already have installed.

Even though Pennsylvania environmental regulators support strengthening the ozone standard, they said in their letter to EPA they will need help from their federal counterparts to meet it.

“Local controls may not be enough to attain the proposed ozone standard,” DEP wrote.

The state agency encouraged the EPA to create new federal policies and regulations to reduce emissions that contribute to background ozone concentrations, which include methane and international pollution that wafts into the U.S.

Advertise with us

The largest human-caused sources of methane include leaks in the natural gas production and distribution system, livestock and landfills.

As national air quality standards for ozone become more stringent, and state-level opportunities for emissions reductions become scarce, “It will be necessary to reduce all anthropogenic precursors that lead to the formation of ozone,” DEP wrote, “including methane.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com