HARRISBURG — Natural gas industry trade groups railed against the state Department of Environmental Protection’s proposed changes to rules governing the industry at an advisory board meeting on Friday, saying they are being held to stricter standards than those that apply to similar industries.

Representatives of the Robinson-based Marcellus Shale Coalition and the Wexford-based Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association questioned the agency’s legal authority to make some of its proposed changes, and criticized the DEP for offering little warning before proposing new standards for subjects like noise mitigation and waste reporting requirements.

Many of the proposed standards “are merely, in our view, designed to increase costs and threaten continued development of this industry,” Jim Welty, vice president of government affairs for the Marcellus Shale Coalition, said at the DEP’s Oil and Gas Technical Advisory Board meeting.

He said the trade group had submitted “extensive and detailed comments” on an earlier draft of the proposed rules, “the vast majority of which appear to have been ignored.”

Advertise with us

DEP released a revised draft of wide-ranging regulatory changes earlier this month that will direct how the oil and gas industry operates above ground. The changes reflect the agency’s consideration of thousands of suggestions submitted by citizens, industry representatives and environmental groups during a public comment period last year. The proposed revisions have been in the works since 2011.

Friday’s meeting was the first for the Technical Advisory Board since its past members were dismissed and all new members were appointed in recent weeks — including four non-voting members from environmental and community groups and research institutions outside the industry who represent the public interest.

The board did not take votes or conduct other official business on Friday because the appointments had not yet been finalized.

Kevin Moody, general counsel for the Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association, criticized Gov. Tom Wolf’s administration for changing the board’s membership in a way that was “shrouded in secrecy” and he said the additional members are not called for under the oil and gas law that established the board.

“The statute doesn’t provide for non-voting members. It doesn’t provide for public interest considerations. We would say they have no place on a technical advisory board,” he said.

Advertise with us

Scott Perry, DEP’s deputy secretary for oil and gas management, defended the transparency of the appointments and the rule making process, which will include an additional 30-day period for written public comment that is expected to begin on April 4.

“We have clearly committed to a heightened level of transparency and public scrutiny by adding non-voting members, who have interests that are really independent of just the oil and gas industry,” he said.

Aaron Jacobs-Smith, a staff attorney with the Philadelphia-based environmental group Clean Air Council also welcomed the addition of public interest representatives on the board.

“I noticed that the only comments about how to strengthen the rules that were talked about today came from the non-voting members,” he said. “I see that as an encouraging sign.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com