HARRISBURG — Environmental and citizens groups called for the Department of Environmental Protection on Tuesday to re-evaluate its longwall mining regulations and more fully enforce them to prevent the severest impacts to water resources and buildings that are caused by the coal extraction method.

The groups gave testimony to the agency’s Citizens Advisory Council in response to a recent report on the surface impacts caused by bituminous mining in Pennsylvania between 2008 and 2013, saying the “you break it, you fix it” principle at the heart of the state’s subsidence law is not working.

The law, known as Act 54, allows subsidence damage to occur as long as structures are repaired, water supplies are replaced and surface waters are restored. But, among other findings, the University of Pittsburgh researchers who produced the comprehensive report for the DEP wrote that regulators have deemed sections of seven streams disrupted by mining to be unrecoverable, and companies’ broader ability to repair damage to streams “remains largely unknown.”

Coal industry representatives testified that the law is working as it was intended, damages are being repaired, and the industry’s “tremendous” economic benefits should be taken into account.

Advertise with us

“From a program perspective, overwhelmingly the data supports the idea that [the law] is working as it relates to the property owner and the coal owner, and there is continuous improvement,” said John Pippy, Pennsylvania Coal Alliance CEO.

Mr. Pippy was the only person to speak for the industry. The six other speakers testified for environmental or citizens groups or spoke of their personal experiences with subsidence damage. Some of the environmental groups called for systematic reviews of the state’s mining regulation strategies and whether severe stream impacts can be fixed, while others called for a halt to longwall mining under streams altogether.

The report — the fourth in a series of five-year reviews required by Act 54 — found 8 percent more reported surface impacts during the most recent study period than the last one, even though the amount of undermined acreage decreased 18 percent.

“In today’s regulatory climate, we would not accept these impacts from newer extractive industries or practices like unconventional shale gas development,” said Davitt Woodwell, president of the Pennsylvania Environmental Council. “It begs the question: Why do we continue to effectively give the mining industry a pass?”

Stephen Kunz, an ecologist who spoke on behalf of the Citizens Coal Council, suggested the DEP return to the “old” mode of environmental protection: try first to avoid impacts, then minimize them, then allow them only if they can be mitigated and only as a last resort.

Advertise with us

“Act 54 would seem to have eliminated the first two steps and gone right to allowing the damage as long as you fix it,” he said. “But we’re seeing that things aren’t getting fixed too well.”

The Citizens Advisory Council is holding a second hearing to take public testimony on the report on March 27 from 1 to 3 p.m. at the DEP’s California District Mining Office in Coal Center. Written comments on the report can also be submitted to the council by April 14.