Pennsylvania is going to need better data if it wants to limit damage to lands and waters that are mined below the surface by the state’s underground coal operations.
That key finding of a recent report on the surface impacts caused by bituminous mining in Pennsylvania between 2008 and 2013 might seem academic.
But the University of Pittsburgh researchers who produced the study for the state Department of Environmental Protection found that the quality of information that state regulators collect about mining impacts — and how they store and sort it — can have a significant effect on the protection and repair of surface resources, especially streams and groundwater where even normal conditions are unique and constantly changing.
“When a wall is cracked, the crack is repaired. When a well is obstructed, a new well is drilled. However, when a stream runs dry, how do we ‘put it back?’” the researchers asked in the report, the fourth in a series of five-year reviews required by a 1994 revision to the state’s mine subsidence law, known as Act 54.
“Natural waters,” they wrote, require a “data-intensive approach to ‘putting things back.’”
Act 54 removed absolute protection requirements for homes built prior to 1966 and replaced them with new terms that allow subsidence damage to occur as long as structures are repaired, water supplies are replaced and surface waters are restored.
The University of Pittsburgh researchers tallied the damage and analyzed the efforts to fix it, but they also identified substantial obstacles in the data provided by the state that often made it difficult to arrive at conclusive numbers.
During the five-year period, 31,234 acres of Pennsylvania land were undermined — an 18 percent decline from the previous reporting period, which the researchers said reflects both a reduced demand for coal and the fact that the next stages of development at Consol Energy’s large Bailey Mine in Greene County headed across the border into West Virginia during the study period.
Despite fewer acres being undermined, 8 percent more surface impacts were reported. DEP recorded 389 reported effects on structures and 855 reported effects on wells, springs and ponds. It determined that mine operators were liable for 61 percent of the structure effects and 57 percent of the water supply effects that had been resolved in the five-year-period.
Mine operators used private agreements with landowners to settle 70 percent of the incidents when the company was liable, which the researchers said made it impossible to know how those damaged structures and water supplies were addressed.
Thirty-nine of the 96 miles of streams undermined during the reporting period had pooling or a loss of flow somewhere in their channel that was caused by mining, which contributed to harmful changes in water chemistry and aquatic life, the researchers found. A mitigation technique called gate-cutting was found to be successful in restoring stream ecology in the four miles where it was used to reduce mining-induced pooling.
Nearly all of the stream impacts were linked to longwall mining, an efficient deep-mining technique that removes all of the coal, including support pillars, from panels cut from the bituminous coal seams that run under southwestern Pennsylvania. It is the mining method used in Pennsylvania that is most strongly associated with subsidence.
The researchers also followed up on streams that were disrupted during the last assessment period and found that while 51 of the 55 stream investigations from that period have been resolved, seven streams above the Bailey Mine and Murray Energy’s High Quality Mine in Washington County were damaged beyond repair and deemed unrecoverable by DEP.
The master tool that the researchers used for their analysis was a geographic information system — fed by DEP, state, company and university data sources — that the researchers had to build themselves because the Commonwealth does not have, or did not make available, a suitable system linking its databases and paper files to spatial information necessary for dynamic maps.
Records in DEP’s primary mining information system for tracking impacts from subsidence “are sometimes missing altogether” the researchers wrote “and frequently lack sufficient information to accurately determine their locations and feature type or to link them to other sources of information regarding that particular feature and effect.”
In the end, the researchers concluded that DEP’s mining information system has so many errors and absences that it “cannot be relied upon as the authoritative source of information on undermined surface features, impacts or impact resolution,” even though that is its purpose.
The state Department of Environmental Protection asked for the scrutiny: In its contract with University of Pittsburgh, the agency directed the researchers to evaluate for the first time how effectively DEP is implementing Act 54 in addition to assessing the effects of underground coal mining.
At a recent DEP Citizens Advisory Council meeting when the report was presented, Tom Callaghan, DEP’s mining programs director, said the agency is still reviewing all of the information in the more than 400-page report.
“We view the report as welcome scrutiny, as an audit, if you will, of the practices that are in place,” he said. “We think its healthy to take a look at the program.”
Stephen J. Tonsor, the University of Pittsburgh biological sciences professor who was the report’s lead author, said, “It would be so much easier for the DEP,” and help the agency in its monitoring and enforcement duties, if it required mine operators to submit information in a uniform way.
“It should be electronic,” he said. “It should be on standardized forms with standardized content and standardized metadata.”
The Citizens Advisory Council is holding two hearings to take public testimony on the report: on March 17 from 12 p.m. to 2 p.m. in the Rachel Carson State Office Building in Harrisburg and on March 27 from 1 p.m. to 3 p.m. at DEP’s California District Mining Office in Coal Center. Written comments can also be submitted to the council by April 14.
The Pennsylvania Coal Alliance, an industry lobbying group, is preparing its testimony for the upcoming hearings, when it will offer detailed comments on the report, CEO John Pippy said.
In the meantime, he said it is important to consider that Act 54 was developed to help balance the property rights of the coal estate owner and the surface landowner.
“Act 54 set up a process to deal with remediation of subsidence issues.” It didn’t prohibit subsidence but it also didn’t allow a company to undermine with impunity, he said. “The remedial standards established by Act 54 are stronger than corresponding federal standards and very similar to what you see across other coal-producing states.”
Several environmental groups have already used the report, which was first published on Dec. 30, to call for lawmakers to revise Act 54.
Speaking on behalf of the Citizens Coal Council, Stephen Kunz, an ecologist with the Delaware County consulting firm Schmid & Co., told the Citizens Advisory Council in January that “recording and tracking the damages carefully is really just a very small part of the problem.”
“The real problem is the damage itself — and the fact that it keeps happening in increasing numbers and severity,” he said. “To address that requires a much more fundamental change.”
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.