The sponsor of two bills that would give Pennsylvania leaseholders protections in oil and gas contracts figures that one way to turn a bill into a law is to start first and fast.

Last week, the strategy seemed to work when the state Senate passed those bills unanimously 22 days into the new legislative session, a week after they came up for a committee vote.

The bills would provide mineral owners with access to more information about how their oil and gas royalties are calculated and protect them from retaliation by companies if they question the royalty calculations.

Similar versions of the bills reached this same point during the last legislative session, but then languished in the House. The sponsor, Sen. Gene Yaw, R-Lycoming, said he thinks they have a good chance of passing this year. Timing might make the difference.

Advertise with us

“There was no real objection in the House the last time,” he said. “They just got caught up in the trading that was going on [at the end of the session], and they never were brought to the forefront.”

The new chairman of the House Environmental Resources and Energy committee, Rep. John Maher, R-Upper St. Clair, said the bills may fare better in the House this time.

“On a notional level, to ensure that the royalty owners have a fair accounting seems as American as apple pie,” he said.

He was more reserved about the one that protects against retaliation. “I think the devil will be in the details to make sure that it can’t be misconstrued.”

Senate Bill 147 contains several provisions that royalty owners have championed: It would give royalty owners the right to inspect gas company records to verify proper payment, require that royalties be paid within 90 days of production, and make sure joint venture companies that pay a share of a well’s royalties disclose information about their stake.

Advertise with us

Jackie Root, president of the Pennsylvania chapter of the National Association of Royalty Owners, said some landowners now wait much longer than 90 days for a first payment on a producing well. In one case she helped with, a royalty owner waited 18 months for the first check.

The right to audit payment records and get information about the companies partnering in a well will also address persistent problems, she said. With joint ventures, royalty owners receive separate payments from each company, but not necessarily any information about what percentage of the gas production those companies control.

“That is a huge problem for royalty owners to reconcile their volumes and what they’re paid,” she said.

Senate Bill 148 would prohibit a gas company from retaliating against a landowner who questions the accuracy of royalty payments by shutting off production or otherwise punishing them.

Mr. Yaw said he can’t name specific cases of that kind of retaliation, but constituents have told him they are afraid to ask questions because they believe gas companies could cut the flow of gas and, in turn, the flow of money.

Advertise with us

“Maybe perception is reality,” he said. “Hopefully we can encourage them to stand up for their rights and ask questions.”

Natural gas industry groups have not taken a strong stance. A spokesman for the Robinson-based Marcellus Shale Coalition said it has not taken a position on either bill, but the coalition “supports reasonable disclosure to leaseholders and will continue to work with the General Assembly to address any real or perceived issues.”

The industry pushed much harder to squelch a bill introduced in the last legislative session that would prohibit companies from subtracting post-production costs that shrink a landowner’s share below the state’s guaranteed minimum one-eighth royalty.

The bill, known in the last session as House Bill 1684, is still the first priority for the state’s royalty owners group. The proposal faced opposition from lawmakers who raised constitutional concerns about changing the terms of current lease contracts.

“To be clear: our eye is on 1684,” said Ms. Root, with the royalty owners association. Transportation and processing fees that some companies subtract from royalties are leaving landowners with far less than the state mandated minimum.

Advertise with us

“That is huge, and it is sucking millions and millions of dollars out of the pockets of royalty owners in this state,” she said. “That needs to be corrected.”

Mr. Maher indicated that debate over Mr. Yaw’s bills will be part of a broader conversation about the rights of royalty owners getting a smaller fraction than the minimum royalty required by law. He said the decades-old minimum royalty law “was made to protect the small guy, the David versus Goliath.”

“That question is going to be receiving considerable attention,” he said.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com