President Barack Obama and India’s prime minister, Narendra Modi, emerged from their weekend talks hailing a historic breakthrough on an issue that has hampered nuclear power development in India for years.
The two world leaders said they’ve reached an agreement that would shield nuclear suppliers, such as Cranberry-based Westinghouse Electric Co., from liability in the event of a plant accident.
Westinghouse CEO Danny Roderick, who traveled to India for the occasion, has been quoted calling the deal a breakthrough, but he was vague in a the statement issued Monday, saying only that he was “pleased to have been a part of this effort,” and thanking the two governments “for their acknowledgment that nuclear energy is essential to ongoing economic development and quality of life enhancement.”
In 2013, Westinghouse signed a preliminary agreement with the Nuclear Power Corporation of India to build between two and eight plants in the Gujarat, in the western part of the country. Each reactor would cost between $5 billion and $6 billion.
But that work has not moved forward because of a 2010 nuclear liability law passed by the Indian parliament that includes two sections troubling nuclear suppliers.
One allows plant operators to sue their vendors for damages in the event of a nuclear accident and another can be interpreted to allow any member of the public to seek unlimited damages from suppliers under the country’s tort law.
Part of the announcement Sunday was a promise by the Indian government to create an insurance pool totaling $250 million that would pay out damages on behalf of nuclear suppliers in the event that an operator chooses to sue them.
The details are sketchy but should emerge more fully in the days or weeks to come, said Ashley Tellis, a senior associate at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Until then, it’s difficult to assess if the brokered deal actually addresses the concerns that nuclear suppliers have had for the past four years.
“We don’t know whether the companies that are involved are as ecstatic about the agreement as the leaders are,” Mr. Tellis said.
The only solution that would put companies such as Westinghouse completely at ease, he said, would be changing the 2010 law. Everything else, including the insurance pool and liability caps spelled out in legal memos from the government, may not stand up in court.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.