FRAILEY TOWNSHIP, Pa. — First there was the pile: a 100-foot-high hill of discarded anthracite coal built up during decades of sorting purer carbon, left behind on this marred pocket of eastern Pennsylvania to spoil the land and streams.
Then came the plant to burn it down.
The Westwood Generating Station began operating in Schuylkill County in 1987 as part of the first wave of power plants designed to clean up the state’s so-called “culm banks and gob piles” by using the mounds of coal waste to generate electricity.
Pennsylvania has 14 of these plants, more than any other state, and the Commonwealth embraces them as a way to solve an otherwise intractable problem — how to get rid of hundreds of millions of tons of polluting waste left by companies that no longer exist without burdening taxpayers with the cleanup costs.
Now, as the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency prepares to tell states to curb their emissions of greenhouse gases from existing power plants, electric generators who burn waste coal are asking regulators to weigh their environmental benefits against their environmental harms and count their carbon emissions as zero.
The industry isn’t alone in asking that it be given special consideration. The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection and Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., are among those urging the EPA to protect waste coal-fired plants as it calculates how much carbon Pennsylvania should cut.
Read More
Vince Brisini, DEP’s deputy secretary for waste, air, radiation and remediation, said the department believes “there is a special place” for waste coal plants because the coal refuse piles that they burn in controlled systems would smolder anyway and release more pollution if they were set alight by lightning or a spark.
“One could make a strong case that they are net neutral from a carbon standpoint because the material is going to burn and be released anyway,” he said. Because electricity produced by the waste coal plants displaces energy that would have been produced by other, probably carbon-emitting, sources, the plants might even be seen to provide a carbon reduction, he said.
“What we believe is that because they are net neutral they don’t need to be part of the strategy as part of the targets.”
The plants provide environmental benefits not involved in a strict carbon calculation: The alkaline ash from waste coal-fired plants forms a concrete-like material that is used to remediate mine-damaged land. More than 7,200 acres have been reclaimed by using the coal refuse as a fuel, according to DEP, and the industry estimates that there are still 170,000 acres in the state to be reclaimed.
Even some of the state’s broad-interest environmental groups have said they recognize the environmental value of the plants’ cleaning up waste coal, but weighing the coal piles’ land and water pollution against the power plants’ air pollution is a difficult task.
“Whether a waste coal plant is advantageous or not, you really have to look at the community that’s impacted,” said Rob Altenburg, senior energy analyst for the environmental group PennFuture.
He suggested that the EPA does not need to make a broad exemption for the plants because the draft Clean Power Plan leaves room for states to tailor their greenhouse gas reduction strategies to accommodate unique interests, especially small ones.
Waste coal plants only make up about 5 percent of Pennsylvania’s installed electric generating capacity.
“The Clean Power Plan, as EPA wrote it, doesn't require specific controls on specific plants,” Mr. Altenburg said. “The target is a statewide goal and within that statewide goal the state has the flexibility to do whatever they choose, pretty much.
“If the state determines that exempting waste coal from any requirement is the correct choice, they can do it,” he said.
Waste coal plant operators worry that being small and special can be a disadvantage if policymakers do not recognize their differences from the traditional coal-fired power plants at the center of the carbon-reduction plan.
For example, there are limits to how much more efficient a power plant can be when its principal fuel is what Westwood Generating’s plant manager John Oelbracht described as “rock with some coal stuck to it.”
“Too often we’re collateral damage because we’re small,” said Gary Merritt, regulatory affairs manager for Northern Star Generation, which has two coal refuse-fired plants in Pennsylvania.
Inside Westwood’s rumbling heart, Mr. Oelbracht pointed to its boiler — a box 9-stories tall — in which crushed coal and limestone is suspended by jets of air and burned. In systems like this one, called a circulating fluidized bed, any unburnt material is circulated through a cyclone that funnels it back to the furnace to be combusted again.
“We burn every last bit that we can,” he said, “but we still have the rocks. No market for hot rocks.”
The technology results in relatively low emissions of some conventional air pollutants like mercury without additional pollution control equipment. But carbon dioxide is the system’s “Achilles’ heel,” he said, because the best bits of coal were sorted out and burned long ago and the leftovers are a low-quality fuel. Plants have to inject more limestone into the mix to control sulfur dioxide emissions, but that same process causes carbon emissions to rise.
Unlike some plants that have the flexibility to switch to a cleaner fuel, like natural gas, to meet the Clean Power Plan’s goals, waste coal plants were designed to get rid of the otherwise valueless garbage in their backyards.
“This plant was built to burn a specific type of fuel in a specific geographic area,” Mr. Oelbracht said. “This is a child of the pile that was here.”
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.