It would take 71 Environmental Protection Agency employees spending all their workdays from now until June to read all the comments submitted to the agency’s Clean Power Plan thus far, assuming a modest 5-minute limit per comment.

For some, five seconds will do: “Don’t [expletive deleted] this up, [expletive deleted],” was the concise directive of one commenter.

Other comments may require a kick-back of the old recliner. The 89-page “risk analysis” from the Electric Power Research Institute, which explains why EPA’s calculations of the benefits of its rule are incorrect and exaggerated, isn’t exactly a quick read.

The tally of comments stood at about 1.6 million, which doesn’t include “the hundreds of thousands of comments that came in last week and those that are coming in today,” wrote Janet McCabe, the acting assistant administrator for the Office of Air and Radiation, in a blog post on Monday. The comment period for the Clean Power Plan was scheduled to close Monday at 11:59 p.m.

Advertise with us

The proposed EPA rule aims to cut carbon emissions from existing power plants by 30 percent from 2005 levels by 2030. The agency said it still expects to finalize the rule in June, even though it extended its comment period by 45 days, citing high volume.

It’s easy enough to peruse the range of technical advice, cheerleading and scolding involved in these comments. They’re sorted by docket number at regulations.gov.

Many are carbon copies of letters initiated under mass mail campaigns. What they lack in originality, they make up in volume.

But how can a boilerplate letter signed by Jeffrey Hassinger of Pleasantville carry the same weight as the charted, graphed, and footnoted analysis from NRG Energy, one of the nation’s largest power generators, which was personally e-mailed to the senior counsel in the EPA’s Office of Air and Radiation by NRG’s senior vice president for policy and strategy?

“Hi Joe, I hope you’re well,” the e-mail began. “I would like to come discuss with you and your colleagues when you have time. Please let me know when that might be convenient.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Hassinger knows his letter can’t compete with that.

“I think it’ll just be stacked up with other letters, and no one will pay attention to it,” Mr. Hassinger said. “You just hope that the stack gets so high that somebody feels the necessity to do something about that.”

There’s something to be said for sheer volume, said Rob Altenburg, senior energy analyst for the environmental advocacy group PennFuture, who was still polishing up the group’s comments on the Clean Power Plan before Thanksgiving.

As the rule gets closer to being implemented, there will likely be tremendous pressure on the president to delay or mitigate its impacts, Mr. Altenburg said. “If he knows that there are a million people that took the time to send the letter in, that's a clear indication that it's something worth his time to fight for,” he said.

Before joining PennFuture in January 2014, Mr. Altenburg spent two decades with the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection where he reviewed thousands of comments on proposed state rules, many of which were form letters delivered in shoeboxes before electronic submissions were available.

Advertise with us

The technical tomes submitted by large environmental or industry organizations took the most time and consideration, he said, but there was impact in those handwritten personal notes as well.

“If someone says, this is necessary because my child has asthma — having a weight of comments that say that — I think is great,” he said. “It focuses why this is important. It humanizes the problem. I think it’s easy for anybody in the regulatory field to get so focused on the technical aspects that they detach a little bit from the human impacts.”

Some commenters were clearly banking on the personal touch when they coated their pleas in poetry.

Robert Kraft, who said he grew up in a coal mining region of Eastern Pennsylvania wrote “[I] recall vividly how the filth spewed from coal-burning homes would turn freshly fallen snow into a gray landscape in hours and how in a day’s time it would be black.”

Others wrote in about their children’s illnesses, or their own.

Advertise with us

Dorothy Frayer, a Wexford resident who said she has asthma, bemoaned Pittsburgh’s poor air quality and said that while she wishes to stay in Pennsylvania, she understands that “this is exposing me to emissions that are compromising my health.”

A coal miner’s wife, Christina Martin, wrote to the EPA that her husband has been forced to take a job three hours away from home because of coal mine closures that she expects will accelerate if the new rules go into effect.

“We go for weeks without seeing each other,” she wrote. “And our two children can’t understand why their daddy has to work so far away.”

The Clean Air Act is one of the most commented rules the EPA has ever put out, though the current record stands at 2.7 million comments the agency received earlier this year in response to its carbon pollution standards for new power plants.

“EPA takes all comments into careful consideration as we work toward a final rule,” said Enesta Jones, a spokeswoman for the agency.

Advertise with us

The air docket office sorts comments by size, sender, and attachments, and they figure out which letters are part of mass mail campaigns.

Beyond that, though, Ms. Jones could not say how many readers the agency employs to review the comments, only that each will get its due.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.