The Pennsylvania Supreme Court will soon decide whether oil and gas companies are allowed to extend the life of a lease by the length of time taken up by a landowner’s failed attempt to void the contract.
The court’s answer could change the stakes of every lawsuit filed by landowners to challenge the validity of their oil and gas leases.
Pennsylvania is rare among oil- and gas-producing states in that it hasn't allowed drilling companies to tack the months they left leases idle during legal fights onto the end of their primary lease period if landowners lose their challenges.
Industry trade groups estimate that in the last decade production companies in Pennsylvania likely lost tens of thousands of months of lease time while they fought landowner challenges that were ultimately decided in the companies’ favor.
The question came up when Cabot Oil & Gas Corp. asked a U.S. district judge for the Middle District of Pennsylvania to give it back the 30 months of a five-year lease term it spent resolving a lawsuit brought by a Susquehanna County landowner, Wayne Harrison, who sued to invalidate his lease and lost.
The district judge ruled against Cabot, reasoning that Pennsylvania courts had already established that leases last as long as they say they do and lawsuits don’t stop the clock. Cabot appealed, which prompted the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit to ask the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to settle the issue.
The state Supreme Court agreed to take up the question in July.
The industry and aggrieved landowners have filed competing briefs in the case, with each arguing that its position is the fair one.
Cabot’s attorneys argue that companies only want to be put back in the position they would have been in if landowners had not interfered with their ability to fulfill the contract terms.
“That is not tipping the balance in favor of the production company,” Cabot’s attorneys wrote. “It is restoring the balance disturbed by the landowner’s losing lawsuit.”
Courts in Texas, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Kansas, Arkansas, Illinois, Michigan, Ohio, Montana and elsewhere have all adopted so-called equitable extension rules to give companies back the time they lost on lawsuits, an attorney representing the Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association, the Marcellus Shale Coalition, Chief Oil & Gas and Southwestern Energy Production Co. wrote in a friend of the court brief.
Bruce Kramer, a scholar of oil and gas law, wrote in support of Cabot that the equitable extension rule has been in effect in some U.S. jurisdictions for more than 100 years so that companies can’t be deprived of their lease rights by landowners’ wrongful attempts to block them.
While a lawsuit does not require a company to suspend its operations on a contested property, it forces the company to decide whether to take the “huge gamble” of committing “many millions of dollars in the drilling, completing and equipping of a well with the prospect that those millions of dollars will be wasted” if it loses, he wrote.
Attorneys for Mr. Harrison and Pennsylvania landowners who are siding with him argue that drilling companies already have the advantage of wealth, legal expertise and bargaining power in drafting and negotiating leases. If the law “punishes” landowners by adding months or years to leases that landowners already think are unfair it will further discourage landowners from filing legal challenges, they wrote.
“The court should not embrace a bad idea because other states have embraced the same bad idea,” attorney Charles Becker wrote for Mr. Harrison. “It should not upend Pennsylvania law for the sake of creating a special benefit for gas companies.”
The landowners have on their side a 2011 opinion by U.S. District Judge John E. Jones III, who rejected an equitable extension request in a separate Pennsylvania case, calling it “bad law and even worse public policy” to say that landowners filing lawsuits is equivalent to them refusing to comply with their lease obligations.
In a friend of the court brief on behalf of six Pennsylvania landowners who “have experienced the high-pressure tactics and sharp practices of the oil and gas industry,” the environmental legal organization Earthjustice wrote that the case “threatens to create a significant new barrier to the courts, which offer small landowners critical protection against rich, powerful, and sometimes over-reaching gas producers.”
If the industry’s “vastly superior” legal resources can both reduce the landowner’s chance of winning and increase the risk of an extended lease term, “the odds against small landowners will be insuperable,” Earthjustice wrote.
The court does not plan hold oral argument in the case and will issue its decision based on the briefs that the parties submitted this fall.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.