HARRISBURG — The Department of Environmental Protection is proposing a new policy to standardize the way it handles oil and gas well site inspections, enforcement actions and complaints that drilling has damaged water supplies.
Some of the provisions might give people “heartburn,” a DEP official said.
The proposal lowers expectations for how frequently well sites will be inspected and requires, rather than requests, drilling companies to temporarily replace potentially disrupted water supplies within the radius of their wells where the law presumes the company is to blame.
While much of the draft document, “Standards and Guidelines for Identifying, Tracking, and Resolving Oil and Gas Violations,” varies only a little from policies that have been in place for years, the few provocative changes will likely draw criticism during the public comment period, which the department just extended until Nov. 18.
Some concerns were raised at the DEP’s citizens advisory council meeting last week when Kurt Klapkowski, director of DEP’s bureau of oil and gas planning and program management, presented the proposal.
“It’s flawed,” Burt Waite, a council member and geologist with Moody and Associates, an environmental consulting firm with oil and gas clients, said after the meeting. “I think there are provisions in it that allow the department to be the policeman, the prosecutor and the judge without giving operators an adequate opportunity to respond.”
The draft policy addresses several issues raised in a withering audit of the department’s oil and gas program released in July by Auditor General Eugene DePasquale — but not necessarily in the way the auditors recommended.
Mr. DePasquale urged DEP to update its inspection policy to include mandated inspections at critical drilling stages and over a well’s lifetime.
The department’s current inspection policy, which was developed more than 25 years ago, says regulators intend to inspect well sites during as many as 16 separate stages of development, including roughly nine times between when the drill bit hits the ground and when the well begins producing oil or gas.
The department is not meeting those goals, which were always “aspirational” and are no longer “necessarily appropriate,” Mr. Klapkowski said.
“I think we’re probably lucky at this point if we’re getting to these well sites two to three times in that time frame, based on the number of inspectors we have and the number of well sites,” he said.
The new proposal lists 12 key occasions when regulators aspire to conduct inspections, but in somewhat opaque language it instructs district offices to “ensure that all wells are inspected at least once” in accordance with the schedule — not once at every stage.
It also drops the current guidance to inspect every well at least annually.
“What it says is that it has to be inspected at least once,” Mr. Klapkowski said. “I think some people are going to have a little bit of heartburn with that, and I expect we’re going to get a significant amount of public comment on that issue.”
DEP spokeswoman Morgan Wagner said in an email that it is the agency’s goal to inspect a well each time one of the 12 key stages occurs. The department “is confident it has the positions necessary to conduct approximately 27,500 inspections annually,” she said, including about 10,500 annual inspections for new wells. There were about 2,100 new wells drilled last year.
The new draft policy also lays out steps and schedules for regulators to respond to water supply complaints so inspectors in different regional offices follow the same procedures.
Mr. DePasquale’s audit criticized DEP for late, confusing and inconsistent communication with people who complained of water supply disruptions related to drilling. The audit also reprimanded the agency for failing to issue enforcement orders every time oil and gas operations damaged water supplies, saying that without such official actions “violations can be dealt with ‘off the books’ and away from the public’s scrutiny.”
DEP has improved the consistency of its communications — it is now department practice to issue a letter in every case rather than making phone calls, as some inspectors did in the recent past. DEP officials have said they are working to create a standard template for the letters so they are uniformly clear and informative.
In the draft policy, DEP also commits to issuing a formal violation notice every time it ties a water supply disruption to drilling. Violation notices are recorded in the agency’s online compliance databases, which means the public can learn about them more easily than if they were only kept in paper files.
But DEP does not intend to issue an order — a higher, more resource-intensive level of enforcement — in cases when a water supply has already recovered on its own or been replaced, when a water supply owner withdraws the investigation request or when the drilling company and water supply owner reach a settlement.
“It will be documented that the determination occurred. A notice of violation will be issued. But we’re not going to issue that order,” Mr. Klapkowski said.
DEP’s proposal for automatically requiring companies to provide temporary replacement water for some disturbed supplies is already raising eyebrows in the industry.
“There’s got to be a way for an operator to take an action without admitting guilt,” Mr. Waite said after the meeting. “That’s not in there. In fact, the opposite is in there.”
State law presumes drillers are responsible for water supply pollution within 1,000 feet of traditional oil and gas wells and 2,500 feet of shale gas wells during six months or a year after drilling. Companies can rebut that presumption by showing that the pollution already existed or was caused by something else, among other defenses.
In an issue alert published on Oct. 6, K&L Gates attorneys R. Timothy Weston and Tad Macfarlan wrote that “the suggestion that PADEP can and should ‘advise’ an operator to provide a temporary water supply even if the operator can firmly rebut the presumption of liability” goes beyond the language of the state’s revised oil and gas law, known as Act 13.
Mr. Klapkowski said that although he expects DEP will receive “a vigorous and thoughtful set of comments” on the proposal, the final version will likely be in place by the end of the year.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.