Entrepreneurs, along with other voters, must soon decide whether they believe incumbent Gov. Tom Corbett or candidate Tom Wolf will better serve their interests as the commonwealth of Pennsylvania’s chief executive.

Typically, startup business owners favor conservative candidates because they advocate lower corporate taxes and fewer regulations. Most entrepreneurs view high taxes and regulation as business impediments. They usually embrace free market philosophies like those espoused by Nobel Prize-winning economist Milton Friedman in his seminal book, “Free To Choose.”

Progressives usually fall into the camp of economist Paul Krugman, also a Nobel Prize winner and author of “The Conscience of a Liberal.” Mr. Krugman believes that government should wrap its loving arms around society and stimulate the economy through grand public works projects and worker protections, such as strong unions and higher minimum wages.

Experienced voters might expect the progressive candidate to be spawned from civil service and the conservative from entrepreneurism. Yet in this gubernatorial election, the opposite is true.

Advertise with us

Republican Gov. Tom Corbett has pursued a career almost entirely in the public sector, beginning with his post as assistant district attorney for Allegheny County in 1976. He joined the U.S. Attorney’s Office in 1980, then served two separate stints as attorney general for the commonwealth, the first beginning in 1995 and the second in 2004. Between those terms, he re-entered private practice as general counsel for Waste Management Inc.

Democratic candidate Tom Wolf started in the family cabinet-making business driving a forklift. In time he rose to the C-suite, sold the business to a private equity firm, then bought it back to save the manufacturing company from bankruptcy. He probably made a couple of bucks in the process. Away from business, Mr. Wolf served as Gov. Ed Rendell’s secretary of revenue collecting taxes, so he’s not wholly unfamiliar with Harrisburg’s political meat grinder.

Despite the candidates' backgrounds, their platforms pretty much follow traditional party lines when it comes to how best to help business.

Both candidates advocate tapping into our huge natural gas formations as a means of creating jobs.

Gov. Corbett wants to create more training programs for the energy sector. Through the 2012 Marcellus Shale Drilling Law, he instituted an extraction fee that has generated $200 million in tax revenue. The governor has also made it easier for drillers to access land for extraction as well as transmission of natural gas.

Advertise with us

In contrast, Mr. Wolf favors a robust natural gas extraction tax to fund education, roads and renewable energy. He advocates tougher environmental oversight. He also strongly supports workers’ rights and does not believe employers should use tax dollars “to fund anti-union efforts.” He favors an increase in the minimum wage to $10.10 an hour and “indexing” it to inflation. Many business owners might balk at the added employee costs associated with the increases Mr. Wolf has proposed, especially with expected rises in the Consumer Price Index.

As in other states, the impact of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) is just beginning to be felt by business owners in Pennsylvania.

While Gov. Corbett has recently decided to accept federal money to expand Medicaid as part of the ACA, Mr. Wolf seems to advocate an even greater expansion. He also wants state government to actively participate in implementation.

Few entrepreneurs like being forced to provide broader health insurance coverage at the same time they are anticipating increases in the premiums they must pay. So robust support of the ACA may not be music to the ears of entrepreneurs.

More ideas for job growth would be.

Advertise with us

Mr. Wolf focuses on manufacturing jobs tied to the gas boom, citing Shell’s new ethane cracker plant as an example. He also wants to create a corporate tax incentive program tied to job creation.

Companies increasing their annual taxable payrolls by at least $1 million can receive “cash payments of up to 5 percent of new taxable payroll the following year.” Mr. Wolf also wants to grow connections between Pennsylvania’s colleges and emerging companies as a means of fostering innovation.

Gov. Corbett wants to increase state education funding but reform teacher pension programs.

While Mr. Wolf seems to hold a significant lead in recent polls, the race may tighten as entrepreneurs peel back the onion and discover that this election in fact entails two traditional choices. The decision may come down to simple economics. That is, Milton Friedman’s or Paul Krugman’s.

But as I read both candidates’ jobs programs, both of which seem remarkably thin and tied predominantly to harvesting the Marcellus and Utica shale formations, I get a funny feeling. Maybe it’s just gas.

Advertise with us

Chris Allison, a former CEO of a local Nasdaq-listed tech company, is the author of “You'll Manage” and teaches entrepreneurship at Allegheny College in Meadville.

To contribute to PowerSource Voice, a regular feature offering insight and opinion on energy subjects, contact Associate Business Editor Teresa F. Lindeman at tlindeman@post-gazette.com