Pennsylvania’s Commonwealth Court will hear arguments Wednesday in a legal battle over whether the state violated its duty to conserve public natural resources by leasing state forests for shale gas development and using the bonanza to balance budgets.

The case will determine if Gov. Tom Corbett and the General Assembly can go ahead with a plan to raise $95 million for the general fund this fiscal year by signing new natural gas leases under state parks and forests.

It will also provide a first answer for how courts will handle claims under the state’s long-neglected environmental rights amendment, which was rejuvenated in December by a state Supreme Court decision in a separate case.

The Pennsylvania Environmental Defense Foundation first challenged the natural gas leasing and fund transfers in 2012. The environmental advocacy group is asking the court to declare that both Mr. Corbett and former Gov. Ed Rendell violated the state constitution by leasing state lands for shale gas extraction without adequately considering or protecting against harms to public resources, and by diverting the windfall away from a special fund set aside for conservation projects.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania’s environmental rights amendment — article 1, section 27 of the constitution — requires the state to conserve and maintain its public natural resources for the benefit of all its citizens, current and future. It also declares Pennsylvanians’ right to clean air, pure water, and the preservation of the environment’s natural, scenic, historic and aesthetic values.

The commonwealth argues that the environmental rights amendment does not place limits on the governor’s power to decide to lease gas interests under state lands. Instead the amendment requires the governor to “consider the potential impacts on the environment of proposed actions as part of a balancing of environmental and economic considerations,” attorneys for the state wrote in a brief filed in August.

In the environmental group’s view, gas extraction on state lands causes immediate and long-term negative impacts to both natural resources and people’s rights.

But the state’s lawyers say the government’s leasing decisions meet the amendment’s standards: the impacts to state forest land from gas development have been “quite limited,” they wrote, and the state’s conservation agency, the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, is properly balancing all of the uses of the state forests, including recreation, timber harvesting and gas development.

Under the governor’s new policy, leases can only be signed in cases where companies can extract gas by drilling horizontally from current wells pads or private property without creating additional, long-term disturbances to the forest surface.

Advertise with us

Attorneys representing the Corbett administration and the Republican caucuses in the General Assembly also argue that the environmental group is urging the courts to interfere with powers delegated to the governor and legislature to make budget and policy decisions.

The environmental group would elevate DCNR to a position as “the constitutional guardian of Section 27 values” and force elected officials to take the agency’s advice about public natural resources, attorneys for the Republican caucuses wrote in a friend of the court brief.

The case has already been a trying one for the state. Testimony during hearings this spring from both past and present DCNR officials revealed that key people in the agency responsible for protecting state forests warned against or, at best, tepidly complied with demands to lease additional public lands for drilling during both the Rendell and Corbett administrations.

The Pennsylvania Environmental Defense Foundation and the state reached a temporary settlement in July.

Until the court rules on the merits of the case, the state agreed not to sign new natural gas leases under state parks and forests, and the foundation agreed to drop its push for a temporary injunction to block any further transfers of oil and gas revenue to fund DCNR’s operating budget.

Advertise with us

However the court rules on the case, it is likely to alter the legal landscape as well as the forested one.

Pennsylvania’s environmental rights amendment was revived by a state Supreme Court opinion in Robinson Township v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania that relied on the amendment to justify striking down limits to local zoning control of natural gas operations in December.

For decades, until the Robinson Township case, Pennsylvania courts did not treat the environmental rights described in the state constitution as they did every other protection in the state’s bill of rights, said John C. Dernbach, a Widener University law professor who co-directs the school’s Environmental Law Center. Instead, they substituted a test for balancing environmental and economic interests.

The Supreme Court’s plurality decision in Robinson Township rejected that test and interpreted the environmental rights amendment based on the language of the amendment. The decision established a “persuasive legal precedent,” if not a binding one, for future courts to treat environmental rights the same as other public rights, Mr. Dernbach wrote in a friend of the court brief in the present case.

“In this new constitutional moment, when we are forced to look at the text of Article 1, Section 27 ‘as if for the first time,’ it is especially important to get the law right,” he wrote.

Advertise with us

The state’s claim that the environmental rights amendment does not place limits on the executive power of the governor is “simply wrong,” he wrote.

Other parties argue that the courts must allow some balancing test — whether or not it is the one that has been used in the past — otherwise the environmental rights amendment might become an unreasonable obstacle to development.

The Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association, whose members are among at least 18 companies that have expressed interest in leasing state lands if the new bids can go forward, also filed a friend of the court brief in the case.

PIOGA attorney Kevin Moody summoned Gifford Pinchot, considered the father of the conservation movement in America and a two-term Pennsylvania governor in the 1920s and 30s, to define conservation and give weight to the association’s positions in his brief.

“The first great fact about conservation,” Mr. Pinchot wrote in 1910, “is that it stands for development.”

Advertise with us

“We just think that maybe people have forgotten what conservation really means,” Mr. Moody said. “It does not mean anti-development.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com