SCRANTON — The nuns who founded Marywood University in 1915 paid the mining company that sold them the land to leave pillars of coal untouched beneath their campus to ensure that the ground wouldn't give way.
A century later, the school drilled two wells into the abandoned, flooded mine to draw water. The water circulates through a system that cools the studios in its environmentally sustainable School of Architecture building.
A college built on a coal mine learns to accommodate the void beneath it.
The same might be said of cities and states.
Pennsylvania’s abandoned mines could be a massive source of renewable energy, extracted not from coal but from the water flooding the unused caverns. The state’s subterranean pools are large, reliably warm and generally close to population centers, which makes them ideal geothermal resources for heating and cooling buildings.
Michael Korb, a program manager in the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection’s Bureau of Abandoned Mine Reclamation, wrote a paper about the potential in 2012: “With more than 3 million people living in and around cities like Pittsburgh, Scranton, Wilkes-Barre, Johnstown and Hazleton located over known mine pools,” he wrote, “the possibilities for use of geothermal heat from mine pools seem to be unlimited.”
Rich with possibilities
Heating and cooling buildings with mine water makes elegant use of a dirty problem.
A flooded mine is “just a reserve of heat,” Mr. Korb said. “It is 55 degrees, and it is not going to change temperature because there is so much of it.”
Mine water is typically warmer than the air in winter and cooler than the air in summer. Geothermal systems that tap into the pools generally use heat exchangers to draw warmth from the water to heat buildings or sink the heat of the indoor air into the water to cool buildings.
The temperature of the mine water is not far from the temperature you want inside a room, which makes a geothermal system more efficient than a heat pump that relies on air.
“I have a heat pump at home,” Mr. Korb said. “When it gets down to freezing or below, it works pretty hard to exchange that air to make it 70 degrees. But it is much easier to make 55-degree air into 70-degree air.”
The possibilities are particularly plentiful in Southwestern Pennsylvania.
In 2006, researchers with the National Energy Technology Laboratory evaluated the geothermal potential of the more than 1 trillion gallons of water stored in the Pittsburgh coal seam, which stretches through parts of Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Ohio. About 4 percent of the water — 50 billion gallons — is discharged each year at the surface, either at treatment plants or at legacy outfalls where the untreated mine drainage pollutes waterways.
The discharged volume alone could be used to heat and cool about 40 million square feet of building space, the researchers found, or the equivalent of about 20,000 homes. Tapping into the reservoir, they wrote, would allow 10 times as many homes to be heated and cooled.
The energy and pollution savings would also be substantial. If 20,000 homes above the seam used mine water geothermal instead of standard electrical heating and cooling, the researchers found, it would save 437,000 megawatt hours each year and cut annual sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides emissions by 2,100 and 920 metric tons.
At the time, they calculated that geothermal heat pump systems using mine water would reduce annual heating costs by nearly 70 percent and cooling costs by up to 50 percent compared to conventional methods using natural gas, heating oil or standard air conditioning.
Obstacles
But with the advent of shale gas drilling in the region, the drop in natural gas prices, and the transition from coal to gas to create electricity, those calculations have likely changed.
George Watzlaf, one of the paper’s authors who now works at an environmental consulting firm, said cheaper conventional fuels are probably a main reason more projects have not adopted the technology.
“It’s not so economically advantageous that people are willing to take the risk to try a system that might not work and is going to have some higher initial capital costs,” he said. “The payback time is probably not as quick as it was in 2006.”
In 2012, Mr. Korb counted only two functioning mine water geothermal systems in the state: the one at Marywood University and a 30-year-old system at a Luzerne County recreation center. A model system installed at a Hill District church in 2008 operated for about a year before the church stopped being used, he said. A half-dozen projects under consideration never came to fruition.
“I think it is thought of as something that hasn't quite been proven — even though it has been done for 40 years,” he said. “It still is something new, it’s something different.”
There are other obstacles.
Dissolved metals in the mine water can build up scale on a heat exchanger, and materials to reduce the risk, like stainless steel, are expensive, Mr. Watzlaf said.
And there can be questions about who owns the water and what laws apply if you use it. “That makes finance people very nervous,” Mr. Korb said. “And lawyers. And rightfully so.”
“I think a lot of people think about the potential problems that may have to be ironed out, and they don’t want to be the ones who are ironing out these problems,” Mr. Watzlaf said.
Model project
Marywood University took the risk, and it has paid off.
Wendy Yankelitis, the school’s assistant vice president of buildings and grounds, said the mine water geothermal system, which was installed in 2010, paid for itself in fewer than three years.
The $530,000 project was funded by a $205,000 Pennsylvania Energy Development Authority grant, with the rest paid for by Marywood and its partners.
The system is used only for cooling. Mine water is pulled up from an unobtrusive well sunk into a campus green, piped underground and through the building’s basement in plastic pipes that resist corrosion, then circulated through a stainless steel heat exchanger before it is pumped back down a second well into the mine pool. A separate loop circulates clean water cooled by the heat exchanger into chilled beams that hang above open studio spaces on the ground and loft levels of the architecture school upstairs.
The expansive space — a renovated former gym — is kept at 74 degrees as cold air drops from the beams and warm air rises, hits the cold coils and drops again.
“There is no compressor. There’s no motor on an air conditioning unit. There’s no motor on our chilled beams,” Ms. Yankelitis said. “The only thing you’re paying for are those two pumps” in the production and recharge wells “and they’re not that big.”
The mine water Marywood extracts from beneath the university has a relatively neutral pH and low levels of iron and manganese, so the staff maintaining the system doesn't have to do much to prevent scaling or corrosion. The heat exchanger still looks new.
“I wish we’d done it earlier, because it is that simple,” she said.
“It’s remarkable to me that more people aren't doing something like this.”
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.