Last month, when California regulators decreed that every new house built in that state shall be topped with solar panels, David Fisfis took notice.
“In theory, Duquesne Light would like to be in support of [something like] that,” said the utility’s vice president of rates and regulatory affairs. “But there’s a business case.”
A business case means that what is good for consumers and the planet isn’t necessarily what is good for the utility whose revenue still largely depends on how much electricity flows through its wires.
It’s been about two decades since Pennsylvania overhauled its electric power industry, compelling utilities such as Duquesne Light to shed their power plants and transition into a strictly poles-and-wires service. And it’s been 10 years since the state formally decided that everyone should use less electricity, requiring utilities to reduce demand and setting penalties for those that fail.
In the meantime, mammoth shifts in technology (smart meters, solar panels); the exploitation of shale gas (most power plants built today will run on natural gas); and an aging grid that needs to be rebuilt — all have outpaced the wonky business of figuring out how electric rates are structured.
Mr. Fisfis argues the changes have called into question the very function of a company like Duquesne Light, a century-old enterprise that serves nearly 600,000 customers in Allegheny and Beaver counties.
Read More
“We need to have a broader discussion about what is the role of a utility,” he said.
Duquesne Light is wedging that broad discussion into a handful of rather specific cases before the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission.
The first is a rate case: a request by the Downtown-based utility to raise customer rates by 9 percent for residential clients, 3 percent for commercial clients, and 2 percent for the industrial class.
For a very small group of clients — right now, just Duquesne University — the utility also is proposing a 220 percent increase in the so-called backup rate. That’s a service offered to facilities that generate their own power but can still draw from the grid in an emergency.
Currently, the university — which has a 5 megawatt power plant that burns natural gas to make electricity and captures the waste heat from that process for heating and cooling — pays about $150,000 per year for backup service.
The rate, established in 2013, is $2.50 per kilowatt per month. The utility is proposing to increase that to $8 per kilowatt, which would take the university’s annual fee to nearly $500,000.
And there is a potentially much bigger fish on the horizon: Shell Chemical Co. is building a 250-megawatt natural gas plant to power its petrochemical complex in Beaver County. It’s not known if Shell would use the backup service or negotiate with Duquesne Light for a customized rate. That’s a $24 million-per-year question for Duquesne Light.
Duquesne Light argues that it doesn’t cost the utility any less money to maintain the poles and wires that serve a customer like Duquesne University just because electricity isn’t flowing every day.
The university has filed an objection to the rate increase, but it’s not the proposal’s most vehement opponent.
That role is being filled by another utility — Peoples Natural Gas, another Pittsburgh institution with 700,000 customers in Western Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Kentucky.
Electric vs. gas
Peoples supplies the gas for Duquesne University’s combined heat and power, or CHP, system. And as natural gas — already established as a heating source — increases its influence in electricity generation, Peoples is courting other CHP developers to build projects in its territory.
In fact, it has asked the PUC to approve a voluntary energy efficiency and conservation plan for the gas utility that would give incentives to such developers.
The entity most vehemently opposing that plan? Duquesne Light.
Peoples proposes to spend up to $17.5 million — to be recouped from customers — to attract around 20 combined heat and power projects. It’s a plan, Duquesne Light charged, that “while cloaked in the garb of energy efficiency, is a gas market-development program that increases rather than conserves gas usage.”
The gas utility isn’t disputing that. “Peoples seeks to protect its own interests,” it said in filings.
Combined heat and power projects would increase the sale of natural gas, Peoples said. Therefore, “Duquesne's proposal to increase (backup) rates will directly, immediately and substantially affect Peoples' economic interests by making these projects less economically viable.”
Jeff Nehr, Peoples’ vice president of production and business development, said the utility’s energy efficiency plan also has incentives for consumers to reduce natural gas consumption, such as rebates for more efficient furnaces.
Behind this feud are the diverging paths of the two utilities.
Technology and mandates have lowered demand for electricity in Duquesne Light’s territory and the trend is expected to continue.
Demand for natural gas in Peoples’ territory is increasing — gas is cheap and plentiful and the powers that be really like it.
Double standard
It has long been considered noncontroversial that electricity should be conserved.
In 2015, then-PUC commissioner Robert Powelson urged electric utilities to “evolve” past their grumbling about the 2008 state law that requires them to decrease demand and instead think of a way to unshackle their financial health from how much product they move.
But when Mr. Powelson, who now serves on the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, was asked if similar mandates with hefty financial penalties should be imposed on gas utilities, he said he had “a personal issue with that.”
“I just struggle with the fact that I’d want people to use less of a cheap commodity,” he said, especially since Pennsylvania wants to encourage Marcellus Shale development.
Duquesne Light has drawn on that double standard in its objections to Peoples, saying that while its revenue suffers from decreased electricity use and it faces fines if those decreases aren’t sufficient, Peoples has no such requirement and might actually eat Duquesne’s lunch with its proposed combined heat and power plans.
Here’s how.
A combined heat and power project developed where the two utilities intersect could qualify for incentives from both companies.
The responsible party is the one that gets to charge its customers for the cost of those incentives. Duquesne Light is worried that if it can’t claim the electricity savings against its mandatory reduction targets, it might be forced to pay fines.
If a combined heat and power project is deemed economic, that means more demand and more money for Peoples. If it’s considered to be out of the money, Duquesne Light retains the electricity demand and the associated revenue.
In April, the state PUC commissioners adopted a policy statement that promotes the development of combined heat and power projects and instructs utilities to welcome them. Peoples says Duquesne Light’s proposed backup rates run counter to the PUC’s wishes.
Rethinking rates
Figuring out how to incentivize and fairly price combined heat and power projects is only part of a bigger discussion that bubbles up from time to time at the PUC.
Policies that take volume out of the equation are in place in 23 states, according to the Center for Climate and Energy Solutions. It’s what made California’s decision to mandate rooftop solar easier for electric utilities to swallow.
Andrew Place, the PUC’s vice chair, is thinking about how new rate structures can reflect what we will want from our utilities now and in the future.
For example, we want them to strive for efficiency and conservation; to have the lowest cost possible spread in the most equitable way; to accommodate the two-way flow of electricity from distributed generation resources like solar panels; to use smart meters to send real-time price signals to customers incentivizing them to reduce energy use during peak times; to make the grid more reliable; and to improve the environment.
Rates based on volume can’t deliver those promises, Mr. Place said.
The PUC has been evaluating ways to let rates speak for its priorities.
The options include:
- Tying how much utilities make to performance targets, which might include safety goals, reliability or environmental performance
- Basing rates on how much it costs the utility to maintain its system regardless of throughput
- Allowing utilities to adjust their charges up or down to account for abnormal weather swings
Mr. Place believes the PUC has broad authority to remake how customers are charged. But it’s a nice cushion that a bill moving through the Pennsylvania Legislature spells out that once and for all, he said.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.