In an effort to nudge more customers to shop for electricity instead of relying on their utilities to buy it for them, FirstEnergy Corp. has proposed shifting hundreds of large commercial clients onto an hourly rate.

The company also plans to penalize residents who don’t shop for electricity providers.

West Penn Power, part of Akron-based FirstEnergy Corp., is proposing a plan that would move some 800 businesses from a fixed quarterly electricity rate to a real-time price that varies hour by hour.

The Greensburg-based utility made the proposal while explaining how it will procure electricity for customers who don’t shop around. If approved, the plan would go into effect in June 2019.

Advertise with us

The same plan from Penn Power — another FirstEnergy-owned utility that services communities in Allegheny, Beaver, Butler and nearby counties — would shift about 330 businesses to the variable, real-time rate.

The change would impact commercial customers that use more than 100 kilowatts of electricity at any time during the prior year. Currently, the threshold for hourly pricing is 400 kw. All electric customers have the option to choose an alternative electricity supplier — a list is available at PaPowerSwitch.com — and shop for a fixed rate.

If the past year is any indication, switching to an hourly rate could cut businesses’ electricity prices by half or even more. But events like the 2014 polar vortex, which saw prices skyrocket amidst very high demand, could undermine the potential savings.

All this is a result of deregulation: electric utilities in Pennsylvania don’t make a profit on the sale of electricity. That has created a market for companies that specialize in supplying electricity. For customers who don’t seek out those suppliers, their electric utility becomes their default supplier.

West Penn Power, for example, serves about 780,000 utility customers. Of those, most of the industrial customers shop for electricity. Most residential customers don’t.

Advertise with us

In the commercial class, about 30 percent rely on the utility to determine the price of electricity. It is this group that will be impacted by the utility’s proposal, but not for another year and a half.

By then, all FirstEnergy customers will have smart meters, the company said. The gadgets will give ratepayers the ability to see their energy use and prices in real time, and adjust their demand accordingly.

“It’s just another nudge to increase shopping, increase choice in Pennsylvania,” said Scott Surgeoner, a spokesperson for FirstEnergy. “It does also provide them with more options to use energy more efficiently, wisely.”

The proposed nudging mechanism for residential consumers is a per kilowatt hour fee that will be charged to the 70 percent of residents who aren’t signed up with an alternative supplier.

Based on the average home electricity consumption in Pennsylvania, as reported by the Energy Information Administration, the penalty would add only about $15 a year to the electric bill.

Advertise with us

Nearly all of the revenue from the fee would be redistributed back to FirstEnergy utilities’ residential customers, those shopping and those not.

But utility prices are so low right now that even those that check out alternative suppliers may choose to stick with the default.

Such was the case with Natalie Abel, whose home is in Penn Power’s territory. She looked on papowerswitch.com but found no rates lower than her default. So she stayed with the utility.

Ms. Abel doesn’t need a nudge to shop for electricity. It’s what she does at Energy Savers Inc., a Ross-based electricity broker for industrial and large commercial clients.

When Ms. Abel heard about FirstEnergy’s filing, she thought, “It’s going to pull in a lot of clients.”

Advertise with us

“It’s actually kind of good for me because people who are going to be forced to [switch] aren’t going to want to do it,” she said. “Once they go hourly, they’re not going to know how much they’re going to pay.”

For businesses that rely on a steady price for budgeting, “They would be pulling their hair out,” Ms. Abel said.

Estimating what kind of business uses 100kw a year is tricky. Ms. Abel and Mr. Surgeoner said the small mom-and-pop store wouldn’t fit into this category. Only about a percent of commercial customers in West Penn’s territory would fit the bill, Mr. Surgeoner said.

FirstEnergy utilities’ default supply plans, filed with the Public Utility Commission earlier this month, will go through a commission review process and be subject to public feedback before they are approved.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.