COLUMBUS — State regulators today agreed to lock in customers for power generated by legacy nuclear and coal-fired plants that have struggled to compete in today’s electricity market.
After months of hearings, plan revisions, and dueling TV and radio ads, the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio voted unanimously on a modified plan that guarantees income for Akron-based FirstEnergy and Columbus-based American Electric Power.
Both cases have been watched nationally for the precedent they might set. Court challenges are likely.
The utilities argued that Ohio can’t afford to let plants such as FirstEnergy’s nuclear Davis-Besse near Oak Harbor close if it wants to guarantee reliable and affordable power generation within its borders.
They have also pointed to the thousands of jobs tied to these plants and argue they will become more economically competitive with other sources of electricity as, among other things, the dust around new federal pollution standards settles.
Critics, however, have called the two plans a combined $5.9 billion bailout for the utilities that will force customers to buy power from their subsidiaries’ plants over the next eight years when those customers could purchase cheaper and cleaner sources like natural gas through the multistate regional grid.
“My belief in free market competition is not compromised with this order...,” said Commissioner Lynn Slaby. “There are times when outside factors may dictate some intervention in an imperfect world.”
The dispute pitted traditional utility companies against competing electricity marketers. It has created splits between major industrial users eager to lock down long-term reliable sources of power against other manufacturers who believe they can do better in a competitive market fed by natural gas and green energy sources.
The deals have also divided environmentalists as some, in AEP’s case, were wooed by utility promises to reduce carbon emissions and move more toward cleaner energy.
The deal for FirstEnergy, the Akron-based parent of Toledo Edison, faced more of a backlash than Columbus-based AEP’s smaller plan. The FirstEnergy deal locks in a market for Davis Besse, the coal-fired W.H. Sammis coal plant near Steubenville, Ohio, and the utility’s share of the Ohio Valley Electric Corp. units in Gallipolis, Ohio, and Madison, Ind.
The federal government recently extended the operating license for Davis-Besse through 2037.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.