Call it a reason to read the fine print. Some residential electric customers, in altering their homes to be more energy efficient, could be paying too much for service.

Electric utilities require new home builders to submit an application for service that determines the so-called tariff schedule — the classification that utilities use to group customers for billing rates.

But any change after that must come at the request of the homeowner — or an electric company would have to notice on its own that a customer’s consumption patterns had changed, said Robin Tilley, spokeswoman for the Public Utility Commission.

The issue has come to light with Duquesne Light’s tariff schedule for customers who have added heat pumps, which are billed at rate that currently is as low as one-third that of regular electric heating service.

Advertise with us

A homeowner in Economy recently filed a complaint with the state Public Utility Commission claiming that his house has been overcharged for electricity for more than two decades, and demanding that Duquesne Light be required to return some of those funds.

Heat pump billing

Heat pumps can make sense in regions of the country with relatively low electricity rates, like Western Pennsylvania. Instead of heating air with a flame, like fuel-based heaters, they draw in heat from outside air and pump it through a home. In the summer, they cool spaces by reversing the process.

Annual U.S. shipments of heat pumps grew 41 percent from 2012 to 2014, according to figures compiled by the Air Conditioning, Heating and Refrigeration Institute.

Utilities added separate rate classes decades ago to help smooth out demand following the construction of several new nuclear plants in Pennsylvania, said Tanya McCloskey, a representative for consumers on state utility issues for the Office of Consumer Advocate.

Advertise with us

At that time, utilities still owned power plants. Add-on heat pumps would increase electricity usage during the winter months, typically a time of lower electric usage during the 1980s.

But since electric generation now falls to the competitive market and utilities now primarily control distribution, the PUC has pushed utilities to consolidate those schedules. The commission believes having one electric heating class of customers is fair, Ms. Tilley said, because the cost of distribution is the same for all customers.

Duquesne Light is the only Pennsylvania electric utility still offering a distribution rate class tied specifically to heat pumps. West Penn Power, which delivers power to 24 counties surrounding Pittsburgh, has never had a separate class for heat pump owners, spokesman Todd Meyers said.

Duquesne Light is gradually phasing out the separate rate classes. Last year, the utility brought its summertime heat pump distribution rates in line with its regular rates, while keeping wintertime rates at a discount.

Years of lost savings

Advertise with us

The change in rates could come too late for some customers.

Economy resident Bob Kramer bought his single-family detached house in 2000. It wasn’t until he went shopping for another electric supplier last year that he discovered the home appeared to have been systematically overcharged for electricity for the past 26 years.

A previous owner in 1988 had installed a heat pump. The owner did not notify Duquesne Light that he qualified for a lower rate.

According to tariff filings effective July 1, Duquesne Light’s charges customers with heat pumps 1.1586 cents per kilowatt-hour for distribution service during the winter months. This compares to 3.5845 cents per kilowatt-hour during that same time for regular electric heating service.

At that current rate — using the PUC’s estimate that Pennsylvania home use on average 2,000 kilowatt-hours for heating every month — the typical customer who did not inform the company that he or she installed a heat pump would have overpaid at least $7,500 for distribution services in 26 years.

Advertise with us

In August, Mr. Kramer filed a complaint with the PUC asking state regulators to force Duquesne Light to recalculate his last 14 years of billing statements.

“Twenty-six years of over-payment cannot stay on their bottom line,” he said, noting he shelled out $8,348 in 2008 to replace both the furnace and heat pump. “This is a form of theft.”

Duquesne Light has not yet formally answered the complaint and declined to comment on the specifics of the case.

“It’s important for customers to understand their rate class, which is shown on the front page of their bill, and to notify Duquesne Light if any changes have been made at home that might warrant a rate change,” said company spokeswoman Ashlee Yingling in an email.

“We will then work with the customer to schedule a visit to their home to determine if a rate class change is necessary before making any adjustments.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.