A multiyear study by the state Department of Environmental Protection has found there is a low risk of radiation exposure related to Pennsylvania shale gas development.
The peer-reviewed report analyzed naturally occurring radioactive material, or NORM, present in the deep shale and other rock formations where oil and gas drilling occurs. The material is transported to the surface with drill cuttings and flowback water associated with gas and oil drilling.
Vince Brisini, DEP deputy secretary for waste, air, radiation and remediation, said in a news release announcing the study findings Thursday that it was comprehensive and provides “data to inform the management of natural gas resources and resultant wastes for environmental and health protection.”
Matt Pitzarella, a Range Resources spokesman, said the “rigorous and exhaustive” report should give the public confidence in the work of the shale gas industry.
“We recognize that even though each well is a temporary process, it must be conducted in the most harmonious manner possible in communities, and a big part of that is dependent on people being comfortable with our work,” he said. “This report demonstrates that this is an issue that is well managed and well understood by both the industry and regulators.”
While the study, which began in January 2013 at the direction of Gov. Tom Corbett, found little or limited potential for radiation exposure to the public or gas industry workers from the development, completion, production, transmission, processing and storage of shale formation natural gas, it said there are “potential radiological environmental impacts” from spilled fluids.
Spills of flowback or produced water, leachate from landfills that accept oil and gas waste, and drilling muds are a potential danger, and the study recommends a number of follow-ups, including further testing at well sites and at wastewater treatment plants, where sediment with elevated radioactivity levels was identified.
“If elevated radiological impacts are found, the development of radiological discharge limitations and spill policies should be considered,” the report states, paving the way for possible future rule-making.
This makes sense to Tom Brautigam, a Pittsburgh-based radiological specialist with Georgia-based Enercon, because not every situation can be anticipated. Routine handling of such wastes may also need to be standardized.
“This is something relatively new in the state, especially in the volumes we are now seeing, so there should be review of the regulations and/or guidance associated with it,” Mr. Brautigam said. “There should be clear guidance on proper protocols so that everybody is on the same page when generating, transporting, receiving, and disposing the waste.”
The report identified a potential hazard for workers that wasn’t fully tested during this study: the buildup of certain elements such as lead in pipes and equipment used in the oil and gas field and during processing and wastewater operations. This could present an inhalation and ingestion hazard, the DEP said, and recommended further study of the potential danger.
The study recommended that “there are site-specific circumstances and situations where the use of personal protective equipment by workers or other controls should be evaluated.” And it recommended that radiological discharge limits be considered for waste treatment facilities handling drilling wastes, as well as the review of long-term waste disposal rules.
It said further study is needed to determine the environmental and health impacts of spreading salty drilling wastewater from conventional, non-shale wells on roadways to suppress dust. The practice has been approved by the state on a limited basis.
Dave Spigelmyer, Marcellus Shale Coalition president, said the DEP study shows that natural radiation encountered in shale gas development has been effectively managed by the industry and the department.
“Sound research like this, as well as the industry’s own forthcoming NORM study, play an important role in guiding and informing the policy-making process which is best served by actual facts and science,” Mr. Spigelmyer said.
Eric Shirk, a state spokesman, said the state study was peer-reviewed by a “cross-section of academics, regulators and subject matter experts.” The reviewers were not identified.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.