TOWANDA, Pa. — Two major players in Pennsylvania’s Marcellus Shale gas boom sought to convince a Bradford County judge on Thursday to narrow or throw out a lawsuit by the state attorney general, who accuses the companies of misleading landowners about lease terms and cheating them out of royalties.

Oklahoma-based Chesapeake Energy Corp. and Texas-based Anadarko Petroleum Corp. argue the state’s case is fundamentally flawed because it misapplies Pennsylvania’s consumer protection law to a situation where the apparently harmed party — the landowners — were not consumers, but sellers, of mineral rights.

“The consumer protection statute does not regulate the conduct of purchasers,” Daniel Brier, an attorney for Chesapeake, told Senior Judge Kenneth Brown. He said four-fifths of the state’s complaint should be dismissed for that reason alone.

In a case originally filed in 2015, the attorney general’s office alleges that Chesapeake and three of its subsidiaries violated the state’s Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law by inflating prices for shipping gas from wells to major pipelines, engaging in deceptive leasing practices and participating in a price-fixing scheme with Anadarko.

Advertise with us

Anadarko, which was not included in the initial complaint, was added to the case in 2016.

Senior Deputy Attorney General Joseph Betsko said the law gives the attorney general’s office broad authority to act in the public interest to stop unfair or deceptive business practices.

Protecting buyers is “one very sound reason” for the law, he said. “It is not the only one.”

The unfair practices alleged by the attorney general include misleading Pennsylvania landowners with lease language that made them believe they were insulated against royalty deductions when they weren’t and then persisting in defending deductions that were inflated or not allowed. The attorney general also alleges the companies colluded to keep bonuses and royalty rates low by agreeing not to compete for leases in certain northeastern Pennsylvania counties.

The case has been closely watched by landowners who have seen Chesapeake subtract a significant percentage — and sometimes all — of their monthly royalties to pay for the costs of moving gas from wellheads to consumers. Many landowners view the case as their best chance to recover back royalties as lawmakers have been slow to address the issue of extraordinary royalty deductions in Harrisburg.

Advertise with us

Attorneys for the companies also argued on Thursday that the attorney general is improperly trying to expand the state’s unfair trade practices law to cover allegations of anti-competitive behavior and incorrectly relies on common law antitrust principles to make claims for damages.

Judge Brown said he will consider the overarching issue of whether the state consumer protection law applies to the case before addressing more specific objections. He did not indicate when he will rule.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.