Noticing a pattern of violations, and complaints from Pennsylvania residents, the state Department of Environmental Protection opened an investigation into Rice Energy Inc., which ended with a settlement and $3.5 million in fines earlier this week.
At one point, the agency refused to issue new permits to the Canonsburg-based company for a period of 50 days until it addressed some of the concerns that inspectors noted repeatedly during visits to Rice wells and pipelines.
In some places, Rice and its affiliated companies allowed sediment to run into streams. In others, they proceeded without permits in hand. In Jackson Township, Greene County, Rice operated an unpermitted centralized wastewater impoundment for three years, hauling water from half a dozen wells in the area into the pit, which was then found to be leaking, as evidenced by contaminated soil downhill.
Some violations, going as far back as 2011, went uncorrected for months and some persist today with a plan to address them.
The majority of the violations have to do with sediment and soil not being properly contained.
“Ultimately, it comes down to clean water,” said Neil Shader, a spokesperson for the DEP. “When you have poor erosion and sedimentation control, you end up getting dirt and sediment into waterways. That can affect wildlife, fish and potentially drinking water.”
Mr. Shader said that while DEP inspectors continued to return to Rice sites and find violations, the agency couldn’t stop operations and wait for the misdeeds to be resolved.
“It’s incumbent on the operators to fix these violations when they are noted,” he said.
Instead, the DEP stopped issuing new permits.
Julie Danvers, Rice’s director of investor relations, said the company was “pleased to have reached an amicable agreement” over the matter, but declined to talk about the substance of the violations.
The site that received the biggest chunk of the fine — $1.6 million — is a well site in Jackson Township.
The DEP knew that Rice was improperly storing flowback water there in August 2012. An inspector issued a violation to that effect then. But Rice continued to do so until April 2015.
In the interim, DEP inspectors visited the site a number of times and found other problems.
“Continuing and new (erosion and sedimentation) violations found,” inspector John Carson noted in March 2013, according to DEP records. Returning to the site two months later, he recorded that a pit being used to store drill cuttings wasn’t built properly.
Erosion and sedimentation violations are not uncommon in the oil and gas industry, Mr. Shader said. Because they’re a broad category, they encompass a lot of activities that take place during shale gas development.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.