WELLSBORO — Erick Coolidge, county commissioner, dairy farmer, genial ambassador of Tioga County, drove his SUV on a warm fall day past the crests and valleys of farms south of the county seat that obscured about half a dozen shale gas well sites, all of them what he called “locked up.”

The wells had been drilled to secure terms of leases but they are not yet connected to pipelines and there are no hints of plans to lay pipes anytime soon.

When Mr. Coolidge approached a picturesque stretch of wooded country road, he indicated the time was right to press a CD into the car stereo to play a pastoral ballad called “The Greenest Green,” written by a retired local music teacher and sung by Mr. Coolidge in his mellow tenor.

The ode to the local landscape served as the soundtrack for the roundabout trip to a Marcellus Shale well named Coolidge 464.

Advertise with us

“This will have six wells on it some day,” he said, once he’d reached the hilltop gravel pad where the well’s metal stack of bolts and valves was shut tight. “Probably long after I’m gone, but regardless.”

Like Mr. Coolidge, people in Tioga County have generally adjusted to the natural gas industry’s downward swing with equanimity.

The Northern Tier county’s drilling boom started and subsided earlier — and more abruptly — than other nearby counties and across the state.

In 2008, there were 15 shale wells drilled in the county; the next year, there were 123; and the year after that, there were 276.

But 2010 was the peak here, and the number of new wells dropped quickly to just 33 in 2013 and 17 so far in 2016.

Advertise with us
If you've driven into the countryside surrounding Pittsburgh recently, you may have seen a few skyscraping rigs like this. They're popping up across Pennsylvania as drillers tap the Marcellus Shale rock formation to access lucrative natural gas. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Traffic eased, work crews shifted elsewhere.

Compared to counties that saw development plummet just in the last year or two, Tioga has had time to collect its thoughts.

After years of rapid growth, Pennsylvania’s Marcellus Shale industry is in a period of retrenchment, although there are some tepid signs of recovery.

The national benchmark price of natural gas that once reached $13.42 per million BTUs in October 2005, fell to $1.73 this March, and even lower at Pennsylvania trading points. After drilling 1,956 unconventional wells in 2011 at the peak of the boom, the industry has drilled less than a quarter of that number in the state so far this year.

Mr. Coolidge’s family’s leased land — 700 acres — is tied up by that single hilltop well, drilled in 2009, devoid of connecting pipes and left dormant until market conditions improve. The pad and the road leading up to it have for the last seven years taken up about 20 acres of what otherwise could be productive farmland for corn, alfalfa and soybeans.

Advertise with us

Mr. Coolidge admires the perspective of his son — his partner in the family dairy farm — who, like his father and generations before, rises before 4 a.m. to tend the cows.

“Our son said, ‘Dad, we don’t wake up in the morning and see how much gas is produced. We wake up and see how much milk we can produce. And that’s how we make our living.’”

Seeking production without disruption 

Tioga County’s economic diversity shifted but it was not completely disrupted by the boom, a fact that helped the county withstand the drilling industry’s retreat.

In his office at the courthouse retrofitted using some of the county’s $20 million in shale gas impact fee money, Mr. Coolidge said major industries continue to be agriculture, education, health care and tourism.

Advertise with us
Sand silos and water storage tanks along a railroad in Delmar Township, Tioga County, service the Marcellus Shale industry. (Laura Legere / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The Tioga County Development Corp. released an analysis of the lingering impact of Marcellus Shale development on the county’s economy in the summer of 2015 and found that total employment in the county was almost identical in 2014 to what it was in 2007 — although in the intervening years it had experienced gains (a 12 percent increase between 2009 and 2012) and dips (a 5 percent drop between 2007 and 2009, and another 6 percent drop between 2012 and 2014).

Shale development brought the county better-paying jobs. That put pressure on sectors that had similar skill demands to increase pay. Wage growth over the period far outpaced that across the state — average weekly wages in Tioga were up 31 percent over the 7-year period, while they were up 12.6 percent statewide.

Tioga’s average wage still lags the state average wage, but shale development helped narrow the gap.

The county report also noted that higher-wage sectors connected to drilling benefited most from the boom: construction, professional services, transportation and warehousing, wholesale trade, and finance — “the very sectors the county has been encouraging to grow for the past decade.” Each of those sectors has also maintained above-average employment levels during the recent drilling downturn.

That’s not to say the transitions have been seamless.

Advertise with us

At one point, the county lost what Mr. Coolidge estimates was $500,000 worth of training that it had invested in county prison and emergency services workers who left for jobs in the gas industry. Some of those employees eventually returned.

The boom was “so overwhelming,” Mr. Coolidge said, but county officials eventually caught up to the gas companies’ pace of change. They tried to use the impact fee money to make “generational investments” in training and capital projects at county buildings, the airport, the prison and emergency services facilities.

And when drilling picks up again, as county officials are confident it will, everyone will be better prepared to deal with it.

“The only difference is that we have the ability now to appreciate what is necessary for it to be productive without being disruptive. We’re going to manage that. At least that’s the goal,” Mr. Coolidge said.

Dealing with a ‘boom-and-bust cycle’

Advertise with us

In some cases, the industry’s surge and retreat inspired local institutions to reaffirm core principals.

Mansfield University, a public liberal arts school about 13 miles east of Wellsboro, changed the name and expanded the purpose of its 2-year-old Marcellus Institute in 2014 to the Institute of Science and the Environment so it encompasses more land use and natural resource topics for research and outreach that could lead to employment in a variety of geoscience-based jobs.

The move corresponded with the decreased drilling activity but had more to do with a change in university administration, organizers said.

“We had an administration that saw the gas companies as a cash cow at the time,” director Lilace Mellin Guignard said.

“The Institute of Science and the Environment is using our resources to be much broader. We look at preparing our students. They should really be better equipped to deal with a boom-and-bust cycle with a four-year degree. That is our goal.”

Advertise with us

On the cusp of peak leaf-peeping season, the roads around Wellsboro were traveled by far more cars with bike racks than water tankers headed to fill up for the next fracking job, although there were still a few of those.

The Pine Creek Gorge, also known as the Grand Canyon of Pennsylvania, in Tioga County. (Laura Legere / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Locals talked about re-adapting to a quieter life, with differences.

A photo on the wall in the reception room of Appalachian Basin Land Resources LLC features a shale drilling rig tower lit up at night, but these days the bulk of the agency’s business is related to more traditional real estate transactions, secretary Carol French said. There are few requests for oil and gas minerals services.

Amy Witter, a title agent, said the influx of gas companies raised the value of property, but now properties are not worth what people paid for them five years ago. Those who have to sell are losing money.

Relatives and acquaintances who found work on well sites here during the boom now follow that work to other Pennsylvania counties or Ohio, even if it takes them out of town for long stretches of time. Ms. Witter’s brother is one of them, she said. “He’s gone a couple months and comes home.”

Advertise with us

The pay is good, but the schedule changes the rhythms of households and, by extension, communities.

A ‘shot in the arm’

Drilling-related work allowed the local excavation company that Dave Hilfiger works for to triple its employees and buy more equipment. Now, the larger crew keeps busy with forestry and conservation work, road building and paving, while the company’s well pad work has shifted away from Tioga County to bordering counties.

“They are still building well pads, but not like they were,” he said. “They had two or three going at a time back then. Now, if we do one or two a year, we’re doing good.”

At lunchtime at Terry’s Hoagies, where the sandwiches are made with homemade rolls, the discussion among the diners turned to the prospect of a natural gas-fired power plant that might be built in the county.

Advertise with us

It wouldn’t require a huge permanent workforce, but an employee of the soon-to-be-shuttered Osram Sylvania glass factory next door said, “Twenty jobs is better than no jobs, so we’ll take it.”

The lighting manufacturing plant’s closure affected 114 employees, but the historic factory once employed 300 people, Mr. Coolidge said later.

With the loss of those jobs and others expected to disappear when an auto parts manufacturer closes in 2017, the county would welcome some renewed growth in drilling to put people with industrial and manufacturing skills back to work.

A new natural gas gathering pipeline will connect Marcellus Shale wells in Tioga County to interstate pipelines. (Laura Legere / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Terry Davis, the hoagie shop’s owner for the last 32 years, never saw a boom like the one drilling brought, and he doesn’t expect to see one like it again.

“I knew the country was in a recession, but it wasn’t here,” he said. “Then all of a sudden, when reality finally came back to us, we started to feel what other parts of the country feel.”

Advertise with us

At 73, Mr. Davis is preparing to retire. In the thick of the boom, he extended hours, added staff and was getting regular sandwich orders worth several hundred dollars. He is glad for the “shot in the arm,” however long it lasted.

He is also grateful Wellsboro did not transform too much to accommodate it.

The community has miles of improved roads to show for the boom and a new traffic light downtown. But it is still the charming village on the way to Pennsylvania’s majestic Pine Creek Gorge that draws tourists back.

“We were a tourist town before they came,” he said. “We’re still a tourist town. It didn’t screw up what kept us alive before.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.