STATE COLLEGE — “I love your logo,” attorney Rayford “Trip” Adams said as he projected the design on a screen in a hotel ballroom during his presentation on oil and gas company bankruptcies at the National Association of Royalty Owners Pennsylvania chapter convention last week.
The defining image for the landowners group’s annual meeting was a rollercoaster train on a bumpy stretch of track. The ride’s supports were oil derricks and the passengers were green dollar signs, some of which had been tossed into the air as the cars crested a hill and hurtled down a pitch.
“The ups and the downs across the rigs, the money flying everywhere,” Mr. Adams said. “The issue is where is the money coming from — whose pockets — and who’s down at the bottom of the rollercoaster scooping it up.”
The audience in the ballroom had a few ideas about who was preparing to scoop up their cash.
One theme of the group’s sixth state convention was a warning from the wise: natural gas royalties might seem like a windfall, but you have to work hard to hold onto it. Through guile or accounting, gas companies, the government, environmental activists, maybe the heirs of the people who once owned your property, are going to try to keep it from you.
“This is not a simple thing — check’s in the mail, cash it, life is good. It ain’t that way. You have a job you need to do,” said John Beard, senior vice president at Warren-based Northwest Bank, during a separate session about managing mineral rights on Friday.
Natural gas operators’ practice of deducting post-production costs from monthly checks was the most universally hated impediment stopping royalty owners from getting what they say is their fair share. Many gas leases require royalty owners to share in the costs of compressing, transporting and marketing gas after it leaves a well head, while other leases are silent on the matter or forbid it.
After the final session, Sherre Boyanowski, a Wyoming County farmer, ran her fingers down a royalty statement for last October, noting deductions that whittled her share of the gas sales from nine wells, which should have been worth about $50,000, down to a check for $104. The deductions are not new, she said, but they got progressively steeper throughout 2015.
“It got worse and worse and worse until they took everything,” she said.
But the crowd of about 80 registered participants was generally upbeat, even if attendance was down by about 60 people from previous years and commodity prices are in the basement. Nearly everyone pitched in for a raffle to raise money to lobby for a bill in Harrisburg, known as House Bill 1391, that would forbid deductions that shrink a royalty share below the state’s statutory minimum 12.5 percent.
The group got a positive report about the bill’s prospects and that raised the mood, chapter president Jackie Root said.
“You’ll never get anything if you’re not optimistic about what your end results are,” she said.
Still, speakers described hazards on the horizon.
Jerry Simmons, executive director of the Tulsa-based National Association of Royalty Owners, detailed national level threats to royalty owners ranging from tax reform to Leonardo DiCaprio.
“If you go to his movies, if you give him money, shame on you,” Mr. Simmons said, as he described the movie star’s recent climate activism. “He doesn’t want you to develop your oil and gas properties. He wants it to stay in the ground.”
Robert Burnett, an oil and gas attorney at Downtown-based Houston Harbaugh, said he expects to see significant legal disputes in the next year over what Pennsylvania considers publicly owned stream beds, below which the commonwealth owns the oil and gas rights.
The state is presumed to own the river beds between the ordinary low water marks of navigable waters. The Department of Conservation and Natural Resources has executed 24 gas leases for 3,800 acres beneath streams and rivers since early 2010.
Mr. Burnett said the state’s ownership claims have surprised adjacent landowners who thought they owned the gas rights below the waterways on their property.
“Valuable oil and gas rights are at issue and these are very real disputes,” he said.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.