Penn Township now requires that oil and gas producers who seek to drill unconventional wells submit environmental impact studies for review before a decision is made on their application for a zoning permit.
The requirement is part of a lawsuit settlement reached last week between the township and a citizens group that sued a township zoning board this spring after it granted conditional approval to a drilling operation in the northeastern part of the township. The approval came with the condition that the company now carrying out the operation there, on a nearly 90-acre tract near Route 22, submit air and water quality studies within a month and a half afterward.
It is "crucial to the community," Gillian Graber, president of the group, Protect PT, said in a statement. She suggested that the prerequisite will ensure sufficient scrutiny of any future applications, opening them up for more public review.
Under the settlement agreement, township commissioners unanimously voted at a regular meeting Aug. 17 to clarify in a provision under its pending zoning laws that drilling companies must provide the required studies when applying for special exception permits for unconventional wells. The quasi-judicial zoning board is responsible for issuing those permits.
Even though the township has yet to adopt its zoning laws, they have remained in effect since it started revising them late last year, township manager Alex Graziani has said.
“The applicants shall demonstrate that the drill site operations will not violate the citizens of Penn Township’s right to clean air and pure water,” the township says in a resolution, citing the environmental rights amendment to the Pennsylvania Constitution.
As part of the settlement, Protect PT withdrew its legal challenge.
“We got what we wanted to achieve,” Ms. Graber said. In her statement, she noted that the group was “fighting for the principle of full early disclosure and for the public’s right to know … ”
The drilling operation that has taken place near the intersection of Mellon and Walton roads over the past couple of months had proved troublesome for the township.
The company carrying it out, Apex Energy LLC, filed a lawsuit against the board of commissioners and the zoning officer in June after the board required that it wait to begin drilling pending resolution of the lawsuit brought by Protect PT. Shortly thereafter, commissioners reversed their decision.
As for how surrounding municipalities are seeking to regulate any future drilling operations, Trafford officials are drafting rules for unconventional wells that include requirements similar to Penn Township’s, though with greater setbacks from drilling operations, Ms. Graber said. She noted that officials in the neighboring borough were receptive to feedback from Protect PT, which she said “commented heavily” on the pending rules.
Despite Penn Township’s stipulating the environmental studies, it remains to be seen whether it will find itself in another legal quandary over any future drilling operations. As of early this week, plans for two more unconventional wells in the township have received approval from the state Department of Environmental Protection, both of them by Apex. Unconventional wells involve an advanced drilling technique known as fracking.
While the township includes little land zoned for industrial use — it is largely made up of rural land and mixed residential property — it has created an overlay zoning district under its pending zoning ordinance that permits drilling outside industrial areas. The district superimposes additional zoning regulations onto existing ones.
That, Ms. Graber asserted, violates the state’s environmental rights amendment.
Should the township adopt its pending zoning ordinance without removing the overlay district, she suggested, the group could take legal action.
Jake Flannick, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.