Supporters of solar energy have plenty to cheer about following a recent report on employment in the U.S. solar industry.
In 2014, the industry added 31,000 solar jobs to bring employment to an all-time high of 173,807 nationwide, according to an annual census conducted by The Solar Foundation, a Washington, D.C.-based solar research nonprofit. That’s an increase of nearly 22 percent from 2013 and 86 percent from four years ago.
In Pennsylvania, the tune is starkly different.
The solar sector in Pennsylvania has shed 30 percent of its workforce since 2012, when the state ranked fifth in the country with 4,000 jobs, according to the foundation. Pennsylvania’s 2,800 jobs in 2014 placed it at 15th in the country and, when looked at as a percentage of the state’s working population, the state dropped to 37th.
“It’s been challenging,” said Ron Celentano, president of the Pennsylvania Solar Energy Industries Association, referring to the industry as well as his solar contracting and consulting business.
Solar projects that create both direct and ancillary jobs have cropped up in the vast deserts of Arizona and California. But, more frustratingly for solar advocates in Pennsylvania, projects are also going to neighboring states like New Jersey and New York.
Read More
Factors in the shift include a Pennsylvania rebate program that vanished, a federal tax credit that is scheduled to wane and the fact that the state’s market for renewable energy credits — designed to incentivize projects and prove compliance with the state’s renewable goals — has suffered from oversupply with credits purchased from other states.
Different ways of counting
The Solar Foundation drew its jobs figures from a database compiled by the Solar Energy Industries Association, the official trade group for the U.S. solar industry, which called Pennsylvania “one of the largest solar employers in the nation.”
In 2014, the census found the number of solar companies in Pennsylvania jumped from 428 to 461.
But the figures represent survey responses from companies on the periphery of the solar industry, such as law and accounting firms, advocacy groups and upstream companies as long as they spend more than half their efforts promoting solar-related causes or producing materials for solar manufacturing.
“Pennsylvania is a tough state to calculate,” said Alex Winn, a Solar Foundation program director.
Pennsylvania’s interstate commerce with neighboring solar-friendly states in the Mid-Atlantic and Northeast, he said, makes its employment benefits more difficult to quantify than for a state like California. In particular, the massive solar build-up in New Jersey is often cited as part of the reason solar has gained a strong foothold in the eastern parts of Pennsylvania.
“There’s a lot of that in Philly,” Mr. Winn said, referring to law and accounting firms.
In Pittsburgh, the national database highlighted local and active solar developers such as SolarCast and Energy Independent Solutions. But it also included Alcoa, Bayer Industrial, PPG Industries — companies that might not be outwardly solar but that are involved in the manufacturing of solar technology. Advocacy groups like PennFuture and smart grid firms like BPL Global, which helps electric utilities upgrade their distribution lines, were also part of the mix.
That skews the reality with which Mr. Celentano is familiar.
During a presentation to a gathering of regional solar industry leaders last month, he took a screen shot of the census’ fact sheet for Pennsylvania and overlaid it with a string of question marks. By his count, there are about 50 — not 461 — solar companies in the state.
He also took issue with the census finding that the number of Pennsylvania homes powered by solar jumped from about 25,000 homes to about 33,000 homes.
That figure is actually total installed capacity — comprising residential, commercial and industrial uses — divided by the typical electricity a residential home consumes. Mr. Celentano, citing the state’s registration data as part of its Alternative Energy Portfolio Standards, said only about 7,700 homes are powered by solar, and almost all of them are in the Philadelphia area.
“Way overblown,” he wrote on the PowerPoint slide.
The census has reported that, despite allowing part-time workers to qualify, about 90 percent of its respondents report working on solar full-time.
There’s nothing necessarily wrong about including all the indirect work created by a functioning solar industry, said Eric Casteel, president and CEO of SolarCast, a Pittsburgh-based manufacturer and installer, because it puts solar on a level playing field with other energy industries that also count job growth in supporting sectors.
“I think you have to look at the auxiliary business as well,” Mr. Casteel said. Referring to the natural gas industry job counts: “If they do it, we should do it, too.”
Open borders mean outsourced projects
In December, Mr. Celentano was surprised to see that the generation registered into Pennsylvania’s renewable energy compliance program had suddenly expanded 7 percent. As it turned out, the credits represented 27 megawatts of solar generation hundreds of miles to the south.
“It was a huge amount of projects and capacity that went to North Carolina,” Mr. Celentano said.
That was not a recent phenomenon. With the new credits, out-of-state solar generation represented nearly half of the total capacity registered in Pennsylvania and available to be sold in the state’s marketplace.
The ostensible driver of in-state investment has been the state’s goals to, by 2021, buy 8 percent of the state’s electricity from renewable power, including 0.5 percent from solar.
But utilities have increasingly met compliance by purchasing solar credits from out-of-state projects — “effectively outsourcing some of the economic benefits the standards were designed to generate in-state,” according to a December report from Pew Charitable Trusts.
Pennsylvania allows the purchase of credits from any state within the territory of PJM Interconnection, the Valley Forge-based grid operator that manages the flow of electricity through 13 states and the District of Columbia. As of Dec. 31, more than a third of the market was supplied by Maryland, North Carolina, Illinois and Delaware.
Part of the problem lies with solar’s half-percent carve-out in the renewable energy goals, which solar advocates see as way too low to provide the urgency needed to invest, said Jessica Lubetsky, officer of clean energy initiative at Pew, a Philadelphia-based nonprofit that analyzes policy issues.
Another part is the Pennsylvania Sunshine Solar Rebate Program, a $180 million state commitment in 2009 that had largely dried up by 2012 and pushed investors to other states with better-funded programs.
But solar proponents have also advocated “closing the borders,” so only in-state solar projects could earn solar credits. It would be an easy fix that would add the stability that big-time employers need in a market that right now is too unpredictable and that fluctuates with other states’ policies, said Joe Morinville, president of Energy Independent Solutions in Robinson.
He said his installation company has grown in recent years by picking up market share as other companies have exited the industry. But after doing work in Ohio, West Virginia and Indiana, he said, he finds it unfair that the solar credits coming from those projects must be registered in Pennsylvania and further weaken the market.
It’s a sort of chicken-or-egg issue: The market is reflecting the lack of in-state investment, but the weakened market is also scaring the investment away, Mr. Morinville said.
“On the surface, it’s not a big dollar change, but it’s a huge psychological change for investors,” he said. “It’s just kind of frustrating that those things could’ve been corrected a long time ago to keep those jobs in Pennsylvania.”
Mr. Celentano is now worried that more New Jersey solar credits could be sold into the Pennsylvania market as that state’s solar goals could soon be met. He is also concerned Virginia solar credits could emerge from Dominion Virginia Power’s proposed installation of 400 megawatts of solar power across Virginia by 2020.
It’s not unheard of. The solar credit prices, hovering around $45, dropped last summer just as they were starting to rebound after Ohio froze its renewable energy standards and Ohio credits were sold in Pennsylvania, Ms. Lubetsky noted.
“Ohio became Pennsylvania’s next problem,” she said.
Rep. Greg Vitali, D-Delaware, last month introduced a bill that would reestablish the PA Sunshine Solar Program, proposing a tax hike on utilities that would provide $25 million a year for the program. He also proposed tripling the solar goal to 1.5 percent of electricity by 2022. Mr. Vitali said his proposal does not include closing the borders, suggesting the idea would be too politically divisive.
But while the bills are certainly generating valuable attention, Mr. Morinville said similar bills have failed before, and he’s not optimistic that this time around will be any different.
“I don’t have a lot of high hopes for it,” Mr. Morinville said. “Closing the borders in itself would be a smart move from a jobs standpoint. And rate payers would see the benefit.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.