After a two-year legal battle filled with Bible quotes and meditations on the Antichrist, Consol Energy Inc. was found to have wronged a 30-year employee by not accommodating his objections over a hand scanner.
Beverly Butcher Jr. of West Virginia was working at Consol’s Robinson Run Mine in 2012 when the Cecil-based company installed the scanners to track employees’ comings and goings for payroll purposes.
Mr. Butcher, who started at the mine in 1977 and with Consol two years earlier, said he feared the scanner would imprint him with the “mark of the Beast,” a reference to a passage from the book of Revelation in the Bible.
When he approached human resources officials at the company to discuss alternative options, they showed him a letter from the scanner manufacturer, Recognition Systems Inc., which, using all capital letters, attempted to make clear that its hand scanners “do not in any way have the ability to detect … or place the ‘mark of the Beast’ or any other mark on a person’s hand.”
This isn’t the first time the subject has come up, since the manufacturer’s letter dates back to 1998. The letter suggests that those still not relieved by the company’s assurance can opt to place their left hand with the palm up in the scanner, explaining that, “The Scriptures, regardless of version, consistently refer to the ‘mark of the Beast’ being found or placed only on the RIGHT hand or forehead.”
Mr. Butcher did not consider that an option.
In later court testimony, he explained that anything having to do with the hands — either hand — would put him in danger and, as an Evangelical Christian who believes that everything in the Bible is literally true, he could not use the machine.
When Consol declined to count his attendance in any other way, Mr. Butcher retired under protest at the age of 58. He planned to work another five years, he later said in court documents.
After his retirement, Mr. Butcher learned that two other employees, who were missing fingers and could not use the scanner properly, were given the option of punching in their employee numbers on a keypad on the scanning fixture. That’s when a failed union grievance process led to the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission getting involved and filing a lawsuit against Consol on Mr. Butcher’s behalf.
On Thursday, a jury awarded Mr. Butcher $150,000 in punitive damages. A judge will now consider whether the retiree is entitled to back pay and other compensation from the company.
Despite the EEOC’s protestations that the only thing important in this case is that Mr. Butcher’s beliefs were genuine, not necessarily mainstream or justifiable, the case often delved into the realm of theology.
In a letter to the company dated June 18, 2012, about a month before his retirement, Mr. Butcher offered several Bible passages and a paragraph from Pat Robertson’s guide “Spiritual Answers to Hard Questions.” He wrote that “even though this hand scanner is not giving a number or mark, it is a device leading up to that time when it will come to fruition, and in good faith and a strong belief in my religion, I would not want to participate in this program.”
During the trial, Consol’s attorneys tried to pin down Mr. Butcher on when he thought he would get the mark. They questioned him about a helmet he’d worn without objection, which has a sensor that tracks his movements through the mine. They also questioned his wife, Barbara Butcher, about her successful lobbying to exempt their three grandchildren from fingerprint scanners at school and her feelings about supermarket scanners.
“I’ve complained about them. I mean, because they make mistakes,” Mrs. Butcher said.
In the end, none of that appeared to matter.
As the EEOC wrote in a court document responding to some of Consol’s statements, “The relevant issue is whether Butcher had a religious objection to hand scanning, not why he objects.”
Consol and an attorney representing the company could not be reached for comment Monday.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.