Not long after New York City Comptroller Scott Stringer said in November that he would file identically worded shareholder resolutions with 75 companies seeking the right of shareholders to nominate corporate directors, many of those companies replied that they were just about to do the same thing.

The targeted companies, with energy firms representing nearly half of the bunch, were chosen as part of the New York City’s official’s effort to take on businesses he considers to have poor records on climate change, diversity, and shareholder’s ability to vote on executive compensation.

One way to give shareholders greater control over these factors, Mr. Stringer reasoned, is to allow them to nominate directors that would push those issues internally, also known as proxy access. That right exists only at a few companies in the U.S.

The Securities and Exchange Commission tried to standardize the practice when it wrote a rule in 2010 that would allow any shareholder or group of shareholders holding 3 percent of a company’s stock for three consecutive years to be able to nominate directors. The agency said it would create more board accountability.

Advertise with us

But the rule was struck down in court the following year.

That left it up to individual companies to decide if they want to allow that kind of proxy access. From the responses that Mr. Stringer’s targets have filed with the SEC, many don’t — at least not on his terms, which mirror the stock ownership thresholds proposed by the regulatory agency in 2010.

“What we’re seeing now is shareholders taking it into their own hands,” said Yafit Cohn, an associate with New York law firm Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP.

Instead of putting outside proposals on their proxy ballots and urging shareholders to reject them, as companies often do, the management teams of at least dozen targeted companies are looking to exclude the proposals from being voted on all together.   

Their strategy was pioneered by Whole Foods Market Inc.

Advertise with us

The Texas-based grocer just last month claimed that it planned to introduce its own proxy access proposal, one that would allow such access to individual shareholders owning 9 percent of the company’s stock for at least five consecutive years. Whole Foods’ current top individual shareholder only owns about 5.2 percent.

Under a regulatory provision that allows companies to omit shareholder proposals that directly conflict with their own, Whole Foods got SEC approval to scrap Mr. Stringer’s effort from its 2015 proxy.

After that, a number of energy companies followed suit.

Arch Coal, FirstEnergy Corp., Noble Energy Corp., Cabot Oil & Gas, Marathon Oil and Peabody Energy have responded to Mr. Stringer’s proposal by filing such letters, insisting that their companies are readying to prepare something similar and thus conflicting for shareholders to vote on during this proxy season.

Noble Energy, a Texas-based oil and gas producer that has operations in the Marcellus Shale, said it plans to pitch a proposal that would allow shareholders, or a group under common management (but not a group of individual shareholders), to nominate directors if they own 5 percent of the company’s stock for five years. The most they'd be able to nominate is either one director or 10 percent of the board.

Advertise with us

Texas-based Cabot, a prolific Marcellus Shale operator working in Susquehanna County, wrote to the SEC that it wants to allow shareholders who own 5 percent of the company’s outstanding shares, either individually or as a group, for more than three years, to nominate directors. Such shareholders would be permitted to nominate up to 20 percent of the company’s board, Cabot said.

Akron-based FirstEnergy, which owns the electric utility West Penn Power, also wrote to the SEC that it would propose shareholders owning 5 percent for three years can nominate one director or, at most, 15 percent of the board.

Several other energy companies with large regional operations haven’t yet decided on a course of action. Texas-based Range Resources Corp. is still mulling its options, spokesman Matt Pitzarella said, as is Cecil-based Consol Energy Inc., a coal and natural gas producer.

EQT Corp., a Downtown-based oil and gas firm, did not respond.

Mr. Stringer was not content to let the companies take over the process by filing conflicting proposals. In a statement, the comptroller urged the SEC to “not enable this cynical tactic, which serves to disenfranchise shareowners and fabricate the illusion of accountability.”

Advertise with us

The SEC may be reconsidering its approach to the issue.

On Friday, the SEC “pulled the rug out from under those companies,” said Avrohom Kess, head of Simpson Thacher’s public company advisory practice.

The regulatory agency issued a brief statement saying it will revisit the rule that allows companies to exclude conflicting proposals and won’t issue any decisions based on that rule during the current proxy season.

“It's huge that it happened literally in the middle of the game,” Mr. Kess said.

Now, “whiplashed” companies will have to decide if they want to continue their plans to exclude shareholder resolutions and introduce their own, put both resolutions on the proxy ballot, or go to court seeking a declaratory judgement to inoculate themselves against a potential future punishment from the SEC if they don’t include shareholders’ proposals this season.

Advertise with us

The change by the SEC last week had Cabot rethinking its options, according to spokesman George Stark, who said the company is still analyzing what the agency’s decision means for the oil and gas driller.

Almost half of the companies in Mr. Stringer’s list of 75 are energy producers or utilities, at least in part because of their exposure to climate change issues.

“Why I find that fascinating is ... you would have thought that if this is about shareholder value, one of the things they’d be targeting is underperforming companies,” Mr. Kess said. “I wonder if it’s a window into their heart. What really is this about?”

“A lot of this is not driven by returns,” agreed Ms. Cohn. “It’s driven by people or institutions with agendas.”

She noted that while getting proxy access is just the first step, Mr. Stringer wouldn’t go through the trouble unless he planned to exercise the option to nominate directors in the future.

Advertise with us

The New York City comptroller manages four different pension funds for city retirees. Even combined, they don’t come close to the 3-percent threshold proposed at any of the energy companies on the list. However, Mr. Stringer’s statement in November had supporting quotes from administrators of much larger pension funds, such as the New York Common Retirement Fund, CalPERS, and the California State Teachers’ Retirement System.

Mr. Stringer’s proposal says like-minded shareholders should be able to pool their holdings to reach the required threshold, and he’s already lined up a handful of heavy hitters that might get to that goal.

If such measures pass and unions and pension funds are looking to make a statement about fossil fuel investments, they could pool their holdings and start nominating directors to advance such agendas, Mr. Kess said.

Proxy advisory firms such as ISS and Glass Lewis have generally been supportive of proxy access measures, but both said in their 2015 policy guides that they would evaluate each proposal individually.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.