The Homer City Generating Station was built on top of a coal mine. For more than two decades, the 2,000-megawatt facility in Indiana County burned coal that was trucked in from the mine portals that surrounded it.

When those local coal supplies began to dwindle in the early 2000s, the behemoth power plant had a glaring problem.

Genesee & Wyoming Inc., a short-line railroad holding company based in Connecticut, had an ambitious answer: the resurrection of an overgrown, 16-mile section of the Buffalo & Pittsburgh Railroad.

Coal could then be hauled by train from western Pennsylvania mines, such as the one owned by Rosebud Mining Co. near Freeport. And because that railroad linked to a larger network, the plant could also, in theory, receive supply from any mine that sent coal along other railroads, including CSX Transportation and Norfolk Southern.

Advertise with us

“It was unbelievable how many trucks were carrying coal every hour, every week, every year into that power plant,” said Jerry Vest, senior vice president for governmental and industry affairs for Genesee & Wyoming. After three years of rebuilding the track essentially from scratch, Mr. Vest said, the railroad carried its first carloads of coal to the plant in July 2005.

The restoration of that stretch of track, together with another 23-mile-long track, formed a two-phase project that cost $21 million and took 80,000 truck trips — 40,000 trucks delivering coal one way and coming back empty — off the road, according to company figures.

Now, energy companies, particularly natural gas producers, also are putting increasing focus on smaller “short line” railroads to move materials more cheaply and to more places not served by pipelines.

But short lines, which operate on bits of track abandoned decades ago by the larger, national railroads, need billions of dollars of maintenance put off by previous owners and these rail lines don’t quite generate enough revenue to make the repairs needed to bring a track up to speed.

Further, the fate of a little-known federal tax credit — “without a doubt” critical to completing projects like the one in Homer City, Mr. Vest said — has been subject to the whims of Congress.

Advertise with us

Incentive to invest on hold

Rail advocates liken short lines to the ramps that branch on and off the interstate highway system. Most short lines fall under the government’s Class III designation, which includes all companies with annual revenue of about $37 million or less. The rest fall under Class II, which includes rail companies that earn a little more: from $37 million to about $467 million.

The highway analogy falls a bit flat with Mr. Vest, who pointed out that, compared with roads and bridges, the burden of building and expanding infrastructure in the rail industry falls more to the companies — and even more on the short lines. Responsible for nearly a third of the rail industry’s route mileage in the United States, short lines account for just 9 percent of its freight revenue.

To inspire investment, Congress approved a federal tax credit that since 2005 has helped propel roughly $300 million to $400 million annually in capital and maintenance expenditures along short line rail. The credit of 50 cents for every dollar spent improving and rehabbing track in effect allows private investors to double the bang for their buck.

“The thought process we go through to buy a new piece of machinery or to buy a mile of track is clearly whether or not we can get a tax credit for it,” said Carl Belke, president and chief operating officer of the Western New York & Pennsylvania Railroad. “We cannot afford the full cost of whatever it is we want to buy.”

Advertise with us

Yet despite unusually widespread support from members of Congress, it has survived on several last-minute renewals, many of them retroactively applying to previous years, for the 10 years it has been on the books.

Often attached to a larger tax bill, the short line credit lives and dies on the mood — and dysfunction — in Washington, said Linda Darr, president of the American Short Line and Regional Railroad Association, a trade association representing 450 short line and regional railroad members.

Last month, the credit quietly passed as part of a bill that retroactively extended $42 billion worth of expired federal tax breaks through the end of 2014 — or for two weeks before expiring again. The extension before that came as part of the “fiscal cliff” legislation passed in January 2013 that extended the credit two years: one year retroactively, and one year forward.

All that makes for too uncertain an environment for the multiyear, multimillion dollar upgrades that short lines need, Mr. Belke said.

“It’s very difficult to plan investments because you’re not certain about whether you’re going to get the tax credit,” he said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Darr said there is no current plan for another extension for 2015 and beyond, but she expects the conversations to begin anew with the recently sworn-in Congress.

“This is kind of the ‘little-engine-that-could’ tax credit; it is small but very mighty,” Ms. Darr said. “I think the need of this credit is more intense now than it ever has been.”

Traffic up from gas boom

Traffic on rail lines nationwide has been on the rise as the economy rebounds and a lack of pipelines in key shale plays has limited the flow of oil and natural gas to market. Trains carrying volatile crude oil to export have drawn criticism from environmentalists and local officials after several high-profile accidents in recent years, including an explosion that killed 47 people in Quebec following a derailment.

Short line and regional rail, which by nature focus on movement of freight domestically, have seen a particular boost primarily from the development of individual sites and transmission projects.

Advertise with us

Grant applications from energy companies and rail service providers to the state’s Rail Freight and Assistance Program, which offers $10.5 million in money annually to invest in upgrades of rail freight service, have increased, said Sarah Gulick, director of the state Department of Transportation’s Bureau of Rail Freight, Ports and Waterways.

“It does appear that the energy companies are relying more on the short lines,” Ms. Gulick said. “They’re taking on a lot of Marcellus Shale, so they needed to come in and upgrade their infrastructure.”

According to Genesee & Wyoming, which has presence in the Marcellus and Utica shale plays, one shale well requires 30 carloads of inbound materials — pipe, sand, aggregates and lubricants — and can produce more than 20 carloads of outbound materials — drill cuttings, brine water and natural gas liquids that could serve as feedstock for petrochemical plants.

“Got Shale? You need rail,” read a slide during a presentation by John Murray, assistant vice president for sales & marketing for the company’s Ohio Valley Region, to shale executives at the Marcellus and Utica Midstream Conference in Downtown last January.

Mr. Murray rattled off a list of reasons why rail transportation triumphs over pipelines: faster delivery to market; no possibility of mixing with other products; short-term and less onerous contracts.

Advertise with us

Western New York & Pennsylvania, a 330-mile line that snakes through the hills of northeastern Pennsylvania and New York’s southern tier, has built and expanded facilities to transload onto trucks the sand and water necessary for fracking, Mr. Belke said. At a facility in Emporium,Cameron County, last year, he said, 1,500 car loads of sand came through.

A yard built two years ago in Port Allegany, McKean County, has moved pipe used in the construction of a couple of hundred miles of pipeline for natural gas.

But a track often needs upgrades that involve clearing trees, fixing eroded washouts, replacing all the grade crossing safety features and installing cross ties. The cost of railroad construction materials has increased along with the demand for them. Mr. Belke noted the price of cross ties has increased to $67 from $52 in two years, in part due to an ironic new source of demand on timber suppliers: wooden drilling pads for natural gas producers.

Though tax credits should be subject to scrutiny, he said, the short line tax credit simply matches investment with demand. In Pennsylvania, where short lines make up 56 percent of the total rail mileage, the tax credit is worth $9.69 million annually on nearly $20 million of investment.

“This is a tax credit that clearly works, and you need only to look at some before-and-after photographs of the rail lines,” he said.

Advertise with us

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @danielmoore1213

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.