People love a benchmark, even one that may no longer make sense, says David Marks, owner of Duquesne-based natural gas and power marketing firm PA Energy Fuels LLC.

That’s why the Henry Hub — a physical place in Louisiana that was once the most popular trading spot for natural gas in the country — remains the price setter for all sorts of trades and financial instruments involving natural gas for the foreseeable future, he said.

That’s despite the fact that over the past two years the volume of gas flowing through the gates at the Henry Hub has been dwarfed by what’s trading at a hub just northeast of Pittsburgh — Dominion South Point.

For several years, speculation about Dominion South Point replacing Henry Hub as a benchmark has been swirling around the industry, but little has changed in the way energy futures are priced.

Advertise with us

First, a bit about benchmarks.

Whether the commodity is gas, oil or corn, benchmarks are proxies for the best average price. They tend to materialize in the confluence of several conditions, said James Preciado, an analyst with the U.S. Energy Information Administration.

First, there needs to be a physical trading point, typically at the intersection of several transportation options linking production to consumers.

Next is storage, or inventory, which gives market participants a cushion to transact easily and quickly. A lot of supply and many producers are essential — they provide the liquidity in selling the products.

It’s specifically the last point — volume — that has people talking about shifting the natural gas industry’s benchmark to an Appalachian trading point, with an obvious candidate in Dominion South Point.

Advertise with us

The Pennsylvania hub — really an intersection of pipelines about 40 miles northeast of Pittsburgh — saw nearly twice the volume of gas come through its gates as Henry Hub in 2013.

So far this year, Henry Hub averaged 37 transactions a month, with 254,000 million British thermal units trading hands daily, while Dominion South averaged 85 transactions, with 400,000 MMBtus.

“The more transactions that occur, the more trading that occurs, the closer you’re going to get to the real trading price,” said Jeff Nehr, vice president of business development at Peoples Natural Gas.

Financial instruments, such as hedges and swaps, use the Henry Hub price as the basis and then index regional price points to that benchmark.

So, what would be the impact on local gas prices if the benchmark shifted from Henry Hub to Dominion South Point?

Advertise with us

“Absolutely nothing,” said Mr. Marks. “It’s a function of pure math.”

The gas price would stay exactly the same, even if the formula to arrive at it would change, he said.

Peoples, a North Shore-based gas utility, buys about 95 percent of its gas at Dominion South Point, Mr. Nehr said.

It’s not just the sheer volume of gas being traded at Appalachian hubs that will drive a shift in the benchmark, said Teri Viswanath, director of commodity strategy, natural gas, with BNP Paribas in New York, who believes such a change will come, if not necessarily immediately.

It will be the infrastructure build out that will play a large role in the pace of the shift, she said.

Advertise with us

The growth in pipeline infrastructure, including reversals that now take Marcellus gas to the Gulf Coast, means it might be time to rethink how the industry prices gas, she said.

Henry Hub will remain relevant because of its physical links to Western states, which Appalachia doesn’t have, Ms. Viswanath said. So there might, in the future, be two benchmarks — one for the eastern part of the country, and the other for the Gulf Coast and the Western states.

Henry Hub may also continue to reign supreme in international contracts, such as those being inked to secure natural gas for exports, starting in 2018. Even though a large portion of the gas intended for oversees will be sourced from the Marcellus and Utica shales, it’s probably too early to expect international buyers to use an unknown, unestablished trading point in Appalachia as the benchmark, she said.

“[If] even in the U.S. market we can't agree upon what our new proxy of supply is, how can an international market that has long been used to Henry Hub as the benchmark?” she said.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.