A few months ago, Westinghouse Electric Co. lost a bid to put six new steam generators into a South African nuclear plant. It didn't take the news well.
Since the Aug. 15 announcement of a deal between its chief international rival, French company Areva, and the South African utility, Eskom, the Cranberry-based nuclear company has insisted on seeing hundreds of documents, urged that two utility officials be thrown in jail, and demanded that a South African judge award the deal to Westinghouse.
Westinghouse feels it has been cheated out of a prize it had been chasing for four years in a contest where it believes it was the front-runner until some high-level Eskom officials intervened on Areva’s behalf.
More broadly, the contract might have bigger implications than its $370 million price tag. The winner may have an inside track on benefiting from South Africa’s nuclear ambitions — the country says it wants to build at least six new nuclear reactors by 2030. Each new reactor would likely run a few billion dollars.
All this began in 2010 when Eskom put out a call for bids to replace six aging generators on the continent’s only nuclear power plant near Cape Town — the Koeberg nuclear power station.
The generators at Koeberg need to be swapped out by 2018, Eskom has said, but the utility repeatedly delayed a decision on who would get the work. Its technical committee recommended Westinghouse at least twice, according to the company and reports in South African newspapers — once in 2011 and again in 2013.
But last year, Eskom’s management brought in an outside consultant, Swiss-based AF-Consult Switzerland Ltd, to help with the evaluation process.
In July 2013, AF-Consult wrote that the steam generator replacement project “is expected to be the largest major nuclear spend before a new nuclear build project is launched in South Africa. Therefore, consideration of other issues such as gaining experience with foreign suppliers who are likely to be involved in new nuclear build in South Africa may be of value.”
According to court documents provided to the Post-Gazette by the M&G Centre for Investigative Journalism (amaBhungane), the consulting company wanted Eskom to evaluate the bidders not just for their price and technical expertise but for “strategic issues,” such as the tight timeline and a historical claim to the plant. The latter issue has been a point of debate. Westinghouse designed the reactors at Koeberg but a predecessor of Areva actually built them.
In the end, the recommendation to go with Areva seems to have pivoted on Eskom’s fear that Westinghouse would allow delays and miss the 2018 scheduled nuclear outage, necessitating another 18-month wait.
Westinghouse says it was blindsided by this logic. “Everything changed without any explanation,” wrote Frederik Petrus Wolvaardt, managing director of Westinghouse South Africa, who authored the initial court document in late August.
In its court filings, Westinghouse said four anonymous sources that are senior in Eskom’s command chain told Westinghouse it was the front-runner and was set to get the contract until the last moment.
“You guys have been pickpocketed,” one of the sources told a Westinghouse consultant after word of Areva’s success got out, according to Westinghouse’s application before the court.
Westinghouse alleged that a high-ranking Eskom official was prejudiced against the company and set events in motion to deny it the contract.
Eskom told the court the allegations amount to rumor mongering.
“I accept that naturally [Westinghouse] would be disappointed with the announcement that its bid was not successful,” wrote Matshela Moses Koko, Eskom’s acting group executive for technology and commercial, in an affidavit in the case.
“What I do not accept though is the unethical attempts by the [company] to pour scorn on the evaluation process … by a wholesale reliance on unfounded information from undisclosed sources, whose existence and credibility cannot be tested.”
By the beginning of November, Eskom said it dumped more than 600 documents on Westinghouse’s lap, but the nuclear company wanted more. The key pieces Westinghouse sought finally came through “at the very last moment,” the nuclear company wrote, and on Nov. 12 Westinghouse withdrew its urgent request to jail the two Eskom employees for not complying with the records release.
But while the situation is no longer urgent, Westinghouse said it will still pursue legal action against the utility. The matter is scheduled to be heard by the South African court in late January.
The court documents provide a rare glance at the stakes in a bidding war.
The four-year process cost Westinghouse about $5 million, and losing the bid places in danger the jobs of 17 Westinghouse employees at its office in Cape Town, among others, the company said.
Westinghouse also engaged engineering and other firms, such as Bechtel of San Francisco and Doosan of South Korea, and now, “in order to retain or rebuild good relationships with these subcontractors and suppliers, Westinghouse will have to compensate them for their losses by providing other contracts,” the company wrote. “At the very least, this will mean that Westinghouse will have a considerably weaker negotiating position with these suppliers in the near future.”
While the subtext for some of this debate is South Africa’s nuclear future opportunities, the country may never achieve its nuclear hopes, some analysts say.
“South Africa talks big about a nuclear program but can deliver little,” said Chris Gadomski, lead nuclear analyst with Bloomberg New Energy Finance. “The reason is that Eskom cannot raise electricity prices high enough [because too many people cannot afford to pay for the real cost of electricity], so programs get routinely canceled and delayed.”
Westinghouse sees a nuclear future in South Africa. Last year, it signed a memorandum of understanding with a South African nuclear company to investigate making fuel assemblies in the country.
“Westinghouse firmly believes in the huge potential growth of South Africa’s energy business towards a more balanced portfolio of clean sources of renewable and nuclear energy,” the company said in a statement.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.