When Alpha Natural Resource’s coal, dug from Appalachian mines, arrived at a South Carolina power plant this year, it saw a cheaper cousin from abroad eating its lunch.
More than 335,000 tons of coal from Alpha’s mines in Kentucky and West Virginia bumped along about 400 miles of railroad tracks to reach the South Carolina Generating Co.’s Williams plant along the bank of the Cooper River.
Approaching from the south were 242,000 tons of Colombian coal. Though the South American fuel traveled four times the distance, it came at a better price and grabbed 24 percent of the solid fuel share at Williams during the first eight months of this year. Alpha supplied 33 percent, according to data provided by South Carolina Generating Co. to the Energy Information Administration.
The dynamic has grated on Alpha’s finances, according to the Virginia company’s CEO Kevin Crutchfield, who noted increasing imports into the U.S. as an industry stressor during the company’s most recent earnings call.
To be sure, coal imports in the U.S. are but a tiny sliver of coal consumption and of the problems facing the industry. More pressing concerns range from falling commodity prices, powerplant shutdowns, transportation constraints, and environmental regulations to competition from cheap natural gas.
Still, there is something incongruous about the world’s richest coal nation seeing a spike in coal imports during a domestic and global glut.
U.S. Census data shows coal imports in the U.S. increasing by 43 percent during the first six months of 2014, compared with the same period last year. Reports submitted by power plants to the Energy Information Administration follow the same trend and show it escalating. In July and August, two months not yet available in the Census data, power plants were already halfway to the total imports for the first six months of the year.
Colombia is the most popular foreign origin this year, followed by Indonesia, Venezuela and Russia, power plants reported.
The Census data, which is supplied by customs districts and includes not just shipments to power plants but also to industrial customers, as well as metallurgical coal and coke volumes, includes half a dozen other countries such as Ukraine, Canada and China.
Metallurgical coal imports, although just a small portion of overall imports, rose rapidly this year as well. At the half year mark, such shipments were already at 90 percent of last year’s imports.
The backdrop for this influx of coal is a domestic and global glut of both thermal and metallurgical coal, said Mike Mellish, industry economist with the Energy Information Administration. Australian coal mines have added capacity, as have Colombian mines.
At the same time, imports to China and Europe have slowed.
“Colombia typically shipped to the European market,” Mr. Mellish said, which has also been the traditional destination for Appalachian coal.
The recent drop in imported coal prices goes against a decade-long trend of rising prices. Power plants reported paying just above $40 per ton for imports in 2002 and more than $90 in 2012. In 2013, the price slumped into the mid-$80s.
For years, domestic coal won over imports because it was cheaper to produce and transport, Mr. Mellish said. “But this year, it’s kind of shifting back the other way.”
South American coal is at a particular advantage, partly because several coal giants have invested a significant amount into boosting coal production capacity in Colombia.
“The mines in Colombia are pretty close to the ports. The all-in delivery costs are pretty competitive,” said Andrew Cosgrove, an equity analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence. As a coincidence, oversupply in the vessel market has also brought down freight rates, making barging coal between countries even more economical, he said.
“For your southern utilities, it makes geographic sense,” he said.
Meanwhile, the U.S. coal market is adjusting to a new normal in the railroad system that once held coal as king but has recently shifted to a new master: oil. Rail transportation constraints have some utilities rethinking their coal contracts. It’s possible, some have turned to imports to fill those gaps, Mr. Cosgrove said.
“Mainly, you’re probably displacing Central Appalachian coal the most,” he said.
Rail constraints played a part in endearing Colombian coal to South Carolina Generating Co.’s Williams plant this year, said its spokesman Eric Boomhower.
“Some coal that was bound for this plant by rail was diverted and used to shore up coal inventories at other facilities,” he said. As the company shifted the volumes to some of its other plants, it filled the gap at Williams with imports.
Between a third and a half of the cost of coal received at the Williams plant comes from transportation expenses and while Colombia is 1,200 miles farther than Appalachia, water transportation is cheaper than rail.
“Due to global supply/demand dynamics, Colombian coal recently has generally been priced competitively with domestic coal,” Mr. Boomhower said.
Alpha’s concern about imports — the company mentioned them as a strain during each of the last two earnings calls following losses — appear to be unique among the nation’s largest public coal companies. None of the other major players discussed the topic. In fact, Arch Coal predicted in its annual report in February that U.S. coal imports, which had been falling since a peak in 2007 would continue to decline this year.
The uptick isn’t keeping analysts awake either.
“That would be way down on the list of issues that the industry is facing,” said Evan Mann, an analyst with New York-based Gimme Credit.
U.S. imports represent a small part of the global glut, which is driving down prices across the board, he said.
“There’s so much coal around. It seems like we’re in the early stages of bottoming,” he said.
In October, China announced it would reinstate tariffs that ended in 2007 on coal imports in order to boost its domestic coal industry.
The move, if enacted, would dampen the most promising export market for U.S. coal, leaving more supply in the country or competing, at lower prices, at other export destinations.
Alpha’s predictions, whether about imports or other coal industry stressors, are notoriously bleaker than its peers’ but “so far they’ve been right,” Mr. Evan said.
“Things have been more pessimistic,” he said. “I think it’s just a crappy business right now, unfortunately.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.