It’s not easy to convince an oil and gas operator to experiment with a $30 million well pad, to put a different kind of sand into a well that has been responding just fine to the status quo or to try fracking it with liquefied natural gas instead of the cheap, available and proven water mixture used today.

It takes some finesse and the promise of much greater yields in the future, even if that future is more than a decade away.

That’s the uneasy task of Jared Ciferno, the Pittsburgh-based director of the strategic center for natural gas and oil at the National Energy Technology Laboratory that serves as the fossil fuel research arm of the Department of Energy.

“We’ll pay you to do it,” he tells companies.

Advertise with us

But government funding isn't really the draw.

It’s this: Even with all the millions of dollars spent tapping a single shale well, the hundreds of trucks and webs of pipelines and millions of tons of water and sand, only between 5 percent and 30 percent of the fuel trapped in the ground comes out through the well.

For NETL, the mission is the other side of the same coin. Getting more oil and gas out of each well means fewer wells will be needed, lessening the environmental impact of the industry.

“What can we do tomorrow so that we can double or triple recovery rates?” Mr. Ciferno asks.

In the coming months, NETL will launch a working shale oil and gas laboratory, which will be used to test technologies that aim to answer that question.

Advertise with us

There will be one well site in West Virginia, another in Ohio, and another probably in the western part of the country, Mr. Ciferno said.

The government lab will follow these commercial, company-operated sites from greenfield through development. It will measure things such as environmental impacts, and test futuristic technologies aimed at boosting recovery rates and/or decreasing the footprint of extraction.

One such innovation in the queue for testing is a conductive proppant — the stuff used to wedge fractures open so that that oil and gas can flow through to the wellbore — that could tell companies exactly where their sand ends up in fractures created to unleash oil and gas.

The concept was developed by Kumul Sharma, a professor at the University of Texas at Austin. Earlier this year, Mr. Sharma received an NETL grant to test this proposed method.

First, he’ll design the tool that would be lowered into the well to sense the electromagnetic signals coming from the special proppant. Then, he’ll identify a cost-effective conductive proppant — petroleum coke, the stuff left over on the floor of refineries, could work, Mr. Sharma said, as would specially coated sands and ceramic proppants — and test it in a pilot well.

Advertise with us

“What will we find?” he wondered. “I think our goal is to try to see if we can identify where the proppant actually goes. Do the fractures reorient themselves as a result of interference with other fractures? Does the proppant settle to the bottom or does it fill the entire fracture?”

Right now, companies map the geometry of a well using microseismic sensors. This tells them where there are splinters that spider off the main fracture, but it doesn't say much about the actual channel through which the oil and gas flow, Mr. Ciferno said.

Another project under development involves using acoustic emitters mixed in with proppant, which would send sound waves to alert a sensor where in the well they ended up.

“It’s high risk,” Mr. Ciferno said. “Industry would say, ‘no way, I’m going to put my sand down there, and I’m off to the next pad.’”

For a government lab, on the other hand, these kind of experiments are its bread and butter.

Advertise with us

Perhaps the holy grail for shale development, often mentioned at industry conferences, is waterless fracking — using some other substance as a conduit for sand and chemicals to crack the rock and release its bounty. Companies have successfully fracked with carbon dioxide, nitrogen and propane. But those are expensive and often impractical.

NETL is readying to launch a project that would look at fracking with liquefied natural gas, sending the same fuel downhole that would later be recovered from the well.

“Water is the main work horse for hydraulic fracturing. It’s cheap. It’s abundant, and it’s used a lot,” Mr. Ciferno said.

Liquefied natural gas, on the other hand, isn't as cheap as water. It’s takes quite a bit of energy to refrigerate it, so it stays in liquid form. NETL is looking at whether it can identify or engineer a cost-effective technology to turn gas coming out of a well or a pipeline into LNG using mobile equipment that would be placed on a well pad.

“The idea here is if you’re going to do multiple wells on a site, you can actually take the field gas from one and use it [to frack] the next one,” he said.

Advertise with us

When drilling companies cite waterless fracking as the way of the future, and say it’s likely 10 or 20 years away from becoming a reality, “that’s probably not a bad projection,” Mr. Ciferno said, although he’d like to see that pan out out sooner.

“We’re looking long term, saying we’d like to use much less water, maybe no water at all,” he said.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.