In a move reflective of a “philosophical shift,” Consol Energy Inc. is phasing out pensions and health care benefits for retirees and shifting to a 401(k) model.
“[Pension] plans like these, they're very dangerous to companies because they're volatile,” said Kurt Salvatori, vice president of human resources for the Cecil energy company. “That’s one of the reasons why companies would prefer a 401(k), because it's very predictable.”
Consol’s pension expenses have ranged between $23 million and $81 million annually over the past decade. During the same period, its workforce has gotten significantly younger, as the company shifted more of its emphasis away from coal operations toward a growing oil and gas business. Last year, Consol sold five West Virginia coal mines to Ohio-based Murray Energy, shedding thousands of workers and retirees.
Today, the company has about 4,200 employees, 4,400 non-union retirees and 5,000 union retirees.
As of Wednesday, Consol froze pensions for the majority, or 2,853, of its current employees, who have had both a defined benefit plan and a 401(k) plan as part of their retirement package.
To make up for the loss, the company’s dollar-for-dollar match to an employee’s contribution to a 401(k) increased from 6 percent of an employee's salary to 9 percent.
The remaining employees — those over the age of 40 with more than 10 years of experience — will continue to accumulate a pension until they retire, Consol said.
“In many ways, we look at a 401(k) as a win-win,” Mr. Salvatori said. “[Such plans] give people what they want, give them control, and they’re portable.”
Defined benefit plans, which guarantee a fixed payout upon retirement, have been on the decline in recent years, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Employees coming into the workforce are conditioned to expect and want 401(k) retirement plans, Mr. Salvatori said, and with a younger crowd now defining Consol’s future, the transition shouldn't be drastic, he added.
In 2008, more than half of Consol’s coal employees, who made up the majority of the company, were over 50 years of age. Today, fewer than a third are over 50.
The average age of a gas employee at Consol is 38.
The company started reaching out to its workers this week to notify them of the pension freeze and upcoming changes to retiree health care plans.
Once that process is done, Consol will start sending letters to retirees informing them about planned changes to their company-funded health care benefits.
Non-union retirees will retain their current health care benefits until January 2020, at which point about 90 percent should be 65 years or older and therefore eligible for Medicare, Mr. Salvatori said.
Union retirees will continue to receive company-funded health care until a contract stipulating the obligation expires in 2016. It’s unclear what will happen after that as Consol has no active unions.
For current employees, the health care benefit will never be available upon retirement. However, all workers will receive a lump sum payment from the company this month, corresponding to their years of service, that they can use to plan for their future, Mr. Salavotri said.
In total, Consol will hand out $50 million in payments ranging between $2,500 and $100,000. It’s an investment the company plans to recover in five or six years by not having to pay retiree health care costs.
“We are making these changes in a responsible way to both protect and invest in our greatest asset — our people,” said Brian Aiello, a spokesman at Consol.
Other local companies, such as Alcoa and ATI, have cut retiree health care benefits in an effort to decrease expenditures. Both companies were sued for those efforts.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.