More than 1,100 Consol Energy retirees will be losing their medical, prescription drug and life insurance benefits by the end of the year.
Murray Energy, the Ohio-based coal company that bought five Consol mines last year for $3.5 billion and, in the process, took over benefits for retirees of those mines, informed them it would terminate their benefit plans Dec. 5.
This applies to retirees who were salaried employees at Consol, not union members, and is estimated to impact 1,192 households, including 161 in Pennsylvania.
A few weeks ago, some of those retirees received new health insurance cards when Consol officially transferred them to Murray. Then, late last week, certified letters arrived from Murray with the bad news.
The news hit Nancy Linville like an anvil.
Her husband, Melvin Linville, 78, of Mannington, W.Va., worked at Consol’s Robinson Run Mine for 28 years, most of it as a long-wall foreman. When he retired in 1992, the Linvilles assumed they’d be able to rely on Consol’s insurance to fill the gaps in Medicare.
“We'll have to cut things out, but you can't go without insurance,” Mrs. Linville said. “But, you know, just one trip to the hospital — that would be devastating.”
After she learned the news, Mrs. Linville called the AARP to get an estimate for supplemental medical insurance and was quoted a monthly premium of $401.
“My retirement is only $398 a month,” she said. “I just can't go out and get another job.”
In October, Cecil-based Consol posted on its website a list of questions and answers about the deal’s impact on current and retired employees, where it disclosed that Murray would have the right to “offer, amend or terminate such benefits at any time.”
In the final agreement, Consol arranged for Murray to continue to provide health insurance and benefits for at least a year after the deal closed Dec. 5, 2013.
“Consol Energy's hope and expectation was that Murray Energy would honor these obligations beyond the one-year period that was negotiated as part of our agreement,” Consol spokeswoman Kate O’Donovan said Tuesday. “While we respect the fact that Murray Energy is a different company with different priorities, this is an unfortunate and disappointing decision."
Ray Oldaker, 69, of Peora, W.Va., said during his career as a mine supervisor at Consol, he was always led to believe he'd be taken care of for life.
“It was always implied that we’d never have to worry about medical insurance,” Mr. Oldaker said.
While Mrs. Linville has called state legislators and anyone else she could think to reach out to, Mr. Oldaker is less optimistic.
“What we ought to have done is gotten all the retirees together and we ought to have marched right on [Consol's] main offices in Pittsburgh,” Mr. Oldaker said. “Maybe we’ll do something [still].”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.