More than 1,100 Con­sol Energy re­tirees will be los­ing their med­i­cal, pre­scrip­tion drug and life in­sur­ance ben­e­fits by the end of the year.

Mur­ray Energy, the Ohio-based coal com­pany that bought five Con­sol mines last year for $3.5 bil­lion and, in the pro­cess, took over ben­e­fits for re­tirees of those mines, in­formed them it would ter­mi­nate their ben­e­fit plans Dec. 5.

This ap­plies to re­tirees who were sal­a­ried em­ploy­ees at Con­sol, not union mem­bers, and is es­ti­mated to im­pact 1,192 house­holds, in­clud­ing 161 in Penn­syl­va­nia.

A few weeks ago, some of those re­tirees re­ceived new health in­sur­ance cards when Con­sol of­fi­cially trans­ferred them to Mur­ray. Then, late last week, cer­ti­fied let­ters ar­rived from Mur­ray with the bad news.

Advertise with us

The news hit Nancy Lin­ville like an an­vil.

Her hus­band, Melvin Lin­ville, 78, of Man­ning­ton, W.Va., worked at Con­sol’s Robin­son Run Mine for 28 years, most of it as a long-wall fore­man. When he re­tired in 1992, the Lin­villes as­sumed they’d be able to rely on Con­sol’s in­sur­ance to fill the gaps in Med­i­care.

“We'll have to cut things out, but you can't go with­out in­sur­ance,” Mrs. Lin­ville said. “But, you know, just one trip to the hos­pi­tal — that would be dev­as­tat­ing.”

After she learned the news, Mrs. Lin­ville called the AARP to get an es­ti­mate for sup­ple­men­tal med­i­cal in­sur­ance and was quoted a monthly pre­mium of $401.

“My re­tire­ment is only $398 a month,” she said. “I just can't go out and get an­other job.”

Advertise with us

In Oc­to­ber, Ce­cil-based Con­sol posted on its web­site a list of ques­tions and an­swers about the deal’s im­pact on cur­rent and re­tired em­ploy­ees, where it dis­closed that Mur­ray would have the right to “of­fer, amend or ter­mi­nate such ben­e­fits at any time.”

In the fi­nal agree­ment, Con­sol ar­ranged for Mur­ray to con­tinue to pro­vide health in­sur­ance and ben­e­fits for at least a year af­ter the deal closed Dec. 5, 2013.

“Con­sol Energy's hope and ex­pec­ta­tion was that Mur­ray Energy would honor these ob­li­ga­tions be­yond the one-year pe­riod that was ne­go­ti­ated as part of our agree­ment,” Con­sol spokes­woman Kate O’Dono­van said Tues­day. “While we re­spect the fact that Mur­ray Energy is a dif­fer­ent com­pany with dif­fer­ent pri­or­i­ties, this is an un­for­tu­nate and dis­ap­point­ing de­ci­sion."

Ray Ol­da­ker, 69, of Peora, W.Va., said dur­ing his ca­reer as a mine su­per­vi­sor at Con­sol, he was al­ways led to be­lieve he'd be taken care of for life.

“It was al­ways im­plied that we’d never have to worry about med­i­cal in­sur­ance,” Mr. Ol­da­ker said.

Advertise with us

While Mrs. Lin­ville has called state leg­is­la­tors and any­one else she could think to reach out to, Mr. Ol­da­ker is less op­ti­mis­tic.

“What we ought to have done is got­ten all the re­tirees to­gether and we ought to have marched right on [Con­sol's] main of­fices in Pitts­burgh,” Mr. Ol­da­ker said. “Maybe we’ll do some­thing [still].”