Proved reserves of natural gas — or what drillers can economically extract from the ground — rose in Pennsylvania and West Virginia in 2012, driven by continued development of the Marcellus Shale play.

Meanwhile, the Marcellus itself surpassed the Barnett Shale play of Texas to become the largest shale gas play in the country in 2012 at 43 trillion cubic feet (Tcf) of proved reserves, according to data released April 10 by the U.S. Energy Information Administration.

Among the top five U.S. gas reserve states, Pennsylvania was the exception. Proved reserves in 2012 fell for Texas, Wyoming, Louisana and Oklahoma as natural gas prices plummeted 34 percent over 2011.

Proved reserves are the volumes of oil and natural gas that drillers can be reasonably certain that they can extract from known reservoirs under existing economic and operating conditions, according to EIA.

Advertise with us

Basically, if natural gas prices allow them to turn a profit and drilling technology stays consistent, a driller can expect to pull a given amount of natural gas from the ground. If the gas market shifts significantly, the amount of natural gas drillers can expect to extract will change.

“‘Proved reserves’ is a very restricted definition,” said Pete Stark, vice president of industry relations for consulting firm IHS. “It has to be substantiated by drilling, tests and well performance. A company can’t just assume that since they drilled five wells on five square miles, that the results apply to 20 square miles, for example.”

Houston-based IHS doesn’t measure shale plays in terms of proved reserves. However, a measurement it does track is called “technically recoverable reserves.” That means it looks at how much of the natural gas could be removed from the ground using current technology, regardless of what the natural gas price is on the surface.

Based on 2012 data, IHS estimates that Marcellus’ technically recoverable reserves clocked in at 247 Tcf.

“The Marcellus is becoming the King Kong of North American shale gas plays,” Mr. Stark said. “Its size and the progress that the industry has made in advancing technology and maximizing performance of wells has been remarkable.”

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania and West Virginia reported the largest net increases of natural gas proved reserves in 2012 at 9.8 Tcf and 4.3 Tcf, respectively, according to EIA data.

But tumbling prices slashed the estimate of natural gas that drillers could expect to extract under existing economic conditions overall in 2012. That year, the average natural gas price was about $2.77 per million cubic feet (Mcf), 34 percent below its 2011 level, which meant more challenging economic conditions for estimating proved reserves.

In the first half of 2012, increasing production and oversupply pushed the natural gas spot price below $2 at Henry Hub in Erath, La., a key benchmark for pricing in the U.S. The price averaged $1.95 per Mcf in April 2012. The last time prices fell below $2 was in November 1999.

However, natural gas prices rose by the end of 2012 to finish above $3. EIA expects that to bolster proved reserves estimates in 2013.

“With natural gas prices higher in 2013 and technology continuing to advance, EIA expects U.S. natural gas proved reserves to increase in 2013,” said EIA administrator Adam Sieminski.

Advertise with us

“In general, the Marcellus provides some of the best economics,” said Diana Oswald, energy analyst for Bentek Energy in Denver.

Ms. Oswald noted that the so-called dry gas region of the Marcellus, which produces methane, is “economic even at $4 per Mcf and competes with richer plays.”

Rich, or wet gas plays, contain not just methane, but also ethane, propane and butane. Those can be processed and sold at an additional profit.

Overall, proved reserves of U.S. wet natural gas fell about 7.5 percent to 323 Tcf in 2012.

Despite the overall drop in natural gas proved reserves in 2012, U.S. natural gas production rose about 6 percent from 2011 to 2012, according to the EIA.

Stephanie Ritenbaugh: sritenbaugh@post-gazette.com or 412-263-4910.