West Penn Power may finally have to pay for missing an energy reduction target three years ago.

The southwestern Pennsylvania utility, now part of Akron, Ohio-based FirstEnergy Corp., was the only electric utility in the state to fall short of a 1 percent reduction goal set by Pennsylvania's Act 129. The penalty for not complying, according to the law, is between $1 million and $20 million.

Act 129 of 2008 required all large electric utilities in Pennsylvania to come up with energy efficiency and conservation plans to reduce overall energy consumption and demand during peak times.

The state Public Utility Commission, which administers the act, said Thursday it would send West Penn's case to its investigations and enforcement bureau to decide if and how the utility will be penalized. West Penn has 20 days to contest the move.

Advertise with us

At the same time, the PUC released the results of the entire first phase of Act 129, which spanned four years ending last May. Phase One had three targets: Utilities were required to reduce their energy consumption by 1 percent by May 2011 and 3 percent by May 2013, as well as show a 4.5 percent drop in demand during one year's peak 100 hours.

Downtown-based Duquesne Light exceeded all of its goals. In fact, its overflow of savings — which the utility is able to apply toward Phase Two — constitutes nearly half of the new target. There is only one cumulative reduction target for the second phase, which began in June 2013 and ends May 2016.

West Penn Power, after it was acquired by FirstEnergy in February 2011, also pulled into compliance and ended up saving more than its 2013 target. It entered Phase Two 18 percent closer to its new goal.

Statewide, utilities' energy efficiency programs saved 5.4 million megawatt hours per year, roughly the equivalent of taking 540,000 homes off the grid.

Duquesne Light's budget for its Phase One program was $78.2 million, but it ended up spending $67 million. West Penn Power had a $94.2 million budget and spent $85.7 million.

Advertise with us

The costs to implement these programs were passed on to consumers. But if West Penn is fined for noncompliance, the utility won't be allowed to recover the penalty from its customer base.

FirstEnergy spokesman Todd Meyers said the company hasn't yet decided if it will contest PUC's noncompliance finding, which has been known for years and even confirmed by the company itself.

The utility, when it was part of Allegheny Energy, had a different approach to Act 129, Mr. Meyers said. It opted to run its energy efficiency and conservation programs in-house, whereas other utilities hired consultants that focused on customer outreach.

It also had the lowest electric rates in the state.

"Lower rates generally provide less incentive for customers to conserve energy and participate in programs," he said.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455