The New York Times recently ran a collection of mea culpas by eight of its most prominent columnists. The “sorry, my bads” were informative, entertaining and revealed a willingness by many of this profession’s most astute writers to make themselves vulnerable in the name of journalistic transparency.
I hope The New York Times makes it an annual ritual, and that other columnists and opinion writers at other publications follow its example. Knowing that at least one column a year would ‘fess up and set the record straight might generate a surprising amount of humility.
As a thought experiment, I imagined editorial page editor Jeff Gerritt, saying “C’mon, guys, it will be fun,” as he nonchalantly wiped off the fingerprints on the frame of his 2020 Pulitzer for Editorial Writing.
Because of the way I’m wired, I would blurt out a few things that I got right first. I would loudly announce I have no regrets about constantly denouncing the Trump administration as one of the most dangerous in American history.
I don’t regret a single negative column I’ve written about the excesses of the Trump regime or the goons and sycophants who tried to dynamite the infrastructure of the administrative state so they could loot this country’s wealth in perpetuity without fear.
The Jan. 6 commission testimony of White House aides and witnesses about Mr. Trump’s conduct, as his followers were rioting to overthrow our democracy at the Capitol, confirms his unworthiness to have ever been this nation’s Commander-in-Chief.
That said, I do regret a couple of areas where I believe this column fell short.
When I became a general interest columnist in 1996, after a stint as the paper’s pop music/pop culture critic, I jumped into column writing without working out a coherent theory about how to approach writing about a city as complex and contradictory as Pittsburgh. I wrote about things that happened in the city as if I were covering a big, flashy concert at the Civic Arena.
I often veered from issue-to-issue like a drunken sailor, reacting or overreacting to events, without a thought of connecting the dots to the region’s systemic and structural realities.
For instance, I remember mocking those who applauded the “Don’t Snitch!” ethic that gripped parts of Pittsburgh’s Black community in the mid-to-late ‘90s because it was counterproductive and allowed criminals to thrive in those communities.
I wasn’t particularly sympathetic to those who insisted that there were valid reasons they didn’t want to be viewed as cooperating with cops or “snitchin.’” I was not a critic of the way police did things until much later. In those days, I wrote about police abuse as isolated events and rarely tied it to anything structural — a monumental blind-spot.
I never wrote about how the Clinton crime bill devastated the Black community. I didn’t write about the slur “super predators” or the worldview that made it possible for Washington politicians to think nothing of incarcerating Black youth by the millions for decades for crack possession, while white kids who snorted powder cocaine received lenient sentences.
I didn’t weigh the legitimate suspicions that Black folks in over-policed neighborhoods had about the quality of policing, or the disrespect they received as residents. While my initial dealings with cops were also quite testy, I noticed, early on, they always backed off, or became deferential, once my reporter’s pad came out. Not everyone Black had that level of privilege.
I also missed the boat by writing one too many columns about culture war issues specific to the Black community like ebonics. For some reason, I was offended that millions of Blacks — and whites, for that matter — didn’t speak standard English.
Why? Because I was an elitist idiot who swallowed the white supremacist propaganda about having one acceptable way to communicate in America. Even though I code-switched all the time between “Black English” and standard English, I hypocritically criticized those who preferred to speak in ways that were completely understandable, but deemed unintelligible by the academy of white standards and practices.
Another area where I blew it big time was in writing about public education completely from the seat of my pants, instead of investing the serious time it requires to do it intelligently.
I’m pro-teacher. I believe they should be paid a minimum of $100,000 a year to attract and retain the best teachers possible. I believe all teachers, including those who end up in better funded school districts, should have a mandated apprenticeship at less well-funded urban and rural schools. I believe the education of American youth is a community responsibility.
In the past, I wrote about chronically underfunded schools as if bad performance scores were merely a reflection of the lack of discipline and commitment to learning at home. I never connected the dots to the depressed tax base, redlining or systemic discrimination exacerbated by white flight.
I always made the point that individual effort counts when it comes to pursuing an education, even in suboptimal circumstances, I know I left readers with the impression that if a slave like Frederick Douglass could get an education, despite the odds, so can Black kids in Pittsburgh.
It really wasn’t that simple. I’m embarrassed by many of those columns now. They lacked, not only nuance, but also compassion. In those days, I rarely acknowledged that Pittsburgh was an aggressively segregated city that doled out precious resources according to race and class. I was a second-rate Stanley Crouch.
So, if I ever did write a column with the headline “Sorry, my bad,” it would cover these points. It would unburden my soul while giving the trolls in the comment section something to chew on for years. It would be a win-win for everyone.
Tony Norman can be reached at tnorman@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.