Jim Rogers, a 54-year-old unhoused man, was killed in October for failing to comply with a police officer’s order to put his hands behind his back.
People who witnessed the event on Harriet Street in Bloomfield agreed with the cops that Mr. Rogers was non-compliant, but they insist that he wasn’t belligerent, hostile or violent.
The only one on the scene who checked all of those boxes was wearing a Pittsburgh police officer’s uniform. The still-unidentified officer repeatedly shouted at Mr. Rogers to comply and put his hands behind his back. Because he knew he hadn’t done anything wrong, Jim Rogers had the audacity to ask, “Why?”
Mr. Rogers had no way of knowing it, but someone saw him remove a bike from a front lawn and take it for a spin. That person called the cops and characterized what Mr. Rogers did as theft.
After a few minutes, Mr. Rogers returned the bike. Because the bike’s owner had no luck in selling it, he had made it free to anyone willing to pedal it away. Mr. Rogers apparently decided it wasn’t a good fit for him and returned it to the owner’s lawn.
Unfortunately, the first officer on the scene wasn’t interested in nuance. He was looking for a bike thief. Despite not having the bike in his possession, Mr. Rogers looked shady enough to deserve to be ordered to put his hands behind his back.
Read More
The “why’s” the officer got in return infuriated him. He demanded total and unconditional compliance. He aimed his Taser and after the give-and-take of justifiable civilian outrage on Mr. Rogers’ part, the officer lit him up.
Other officers arrived on the scene to aid their comrade. It is estimated that the officer tased Mr. Rogers at least eight times. He had not committed a crime, much less one deserving potential death by electrocution. Mr. Rogers died the next day because cardiac arrest prevented oxygen from getting to his brain, according to a coroner’s report that classified it as “accidental.”
Despite a number of horrified neighbors who demanded that the officer stop electrocuting Mr. Rogers, there was no civilian footage of the killing. Only the body-cams of the nearly dozen cops on the scene bore witness to such an absurd and unnecessary death. To date, the footage has not been made public, but it is probably very, very bad and incriminating for at least one of them.
This week, the city fired five Pittsburgh police officers involved in responding to the incident. Another three officers who were subject to an internal investigation get to keep their jobs, but they have to be “re-trained” — whatever that means.
We have no idea if the officer who first tased Mr. Rogers is among the five who were fired, or the three who will be retrained to not kill unarmed civilians who have done nothing wrong except ask why they’re being arrested for a crime that didn’t happen.
All eight officers who faced discipline and an investigation remain unnamed. No one has been indicted for the death of Jim Rogers and it isn’t clear whether what happened can even be formally described as a crime given the latitude police officers have to commit violence, including lethal violence, against civilians.
This is the point where those who believe that cops always have the right to kill noncompliant citizens — especially Blacks — begin chirping their usual racist ragtime: “If you comply, you live. If you defy an officer for any reason, you should expect to be killed because you’re a threat to both the officer and public order. Order demands instant compliance with police authority. You don’t have any civil rights when an officer tells you to do something.”
Of course, this is the usual doggerel of trolls in the comment section. It doesn’t matter that these same trolls cheer on the Jan. 6 insurrectionists or babble about “freedom” when they’re protesting mask mandates at state capitols. Whenever they defy police, they’re being “patriots.” They never expect to get shot, no matter how destabilizing their presence is or how threatening they are to the functioning of democracy.
But an unarmed Black man accused of stealing a bike? It’s open season on that chump. He was homeless, and, thus, unimportant. Thank God his family and the community activists, many from the neighborhood where he was killed, felt otherwise.
Pittsburgh has a divided soul when it comes to police violence. When a Nazi living in his mother’s Stanton Heights basement killed three police officers answering a domestic complaint, he was taken alive despite the rage the officers felt over the death of their comrades. How was that possible?
We saw the same professionalism during the police response to the antisemitic siege in Squirrel Hill in 2018. It was the bloodiest day for Jews in American history, but the police took the white supremacist alive.
So given the level of professionalism-under-fire Pittsburgh cops are capable of exercising in the most extreme circumstances, how is it possible for death to be the outcome of an encounter over a bike that wasn’t even stolen?
Why was Jim Rogers killed just because he refused to put his hands behind his back? In what universe is it OK to kill civilians for questioning unjust police behavior? Why would anyone want to live in a country like that? That’s literally a police state.
All of the fired officers have a right of appeal through arbitration, so this case will probably drag on for years. Meanwhile, the public still hasn’t seen the body-cam footage that compelled the city to cut five officers loose. We’re closer to justice for Jim Rogers than we were in October, but it is still a very long way off.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631 or Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.