Neil Young’s ultimatum to Spotify was not a “Sophie’s Choice” moment for the streaming giant. The two-time Rock & Roll Hall of Fame inductee insisted that Spotify choose between his six-decade catalogue of generation-defining music and Joe Rogan, the top-performing podcaster on the platform and, possibly, the world.
“They can have Rogan or Young, not both,” the rocker said in a letter posted on his website. “I am doing this because Spotify is spreading fake information about vaccines — potentially causing death to those who believe the disinformation being spread by them.”
“Please act on this immediately today and keep me informed of the time schedule,” Mr. Young wrote.
It was a gutsy move. Spotify accounts for 60% of his catalogue’s streaming revenue.
But it shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone that given the choice between the author of “Heart of Gold” and “The Joe Rogan Experience,” Spotify went for the gold. It didn’t have to look any farther than its balance sheets: Joe Rogan has an estimated 200 million monthly listeners, more than justifying the $100 million deal he signed in 2020 to stream exclusively with the company.
Neil Young has an estimated 6 million listeners per month on the site. It’s very basic math as far as Spotify is concerned. The company knows that most of Mr. Young’s hardcore fans don’t subscribe to streaming services; they prefer catching him live or listening to his music on vinyl or CD, so streaming numbers are far from an accurate count of his immense fanbase.
Read More
On Thursday, Spotify began deleting Neil Young’s music from its platform but left the door open for the rocker to return. That’s going to be a long wait.
Kicking Shakey to the curb instead of acknowledging that its top podcaster is often the source of vaccine misinformation detrimental to the public is a move that will eventually hurt Spotify as much as the criticism it regularly receives for reimbursing artists pennies on the dollar for the privilege of exploiting their work on its platform.
Spotify has removed 40 episodes of “The Joe Rogan Experience” for reasons Neil Young has complained about, but it has made no secret that it values Joe Rogan’s audience share far more than any artist’s stature in the culture.
These days, rock ‘n’ roll is just another commodity that comes packaged with a set of values many corporations may consider as ephemeral and hard to define as cryptocurrency.
Looking at Neil Young’s fight with Spotify, future historians will declare that this generation is living in a cracked-mirror version of the of the 1960s and ‘70s. Legalized marijuana in Middle America is the first big clue that times have changed.
A member of the Kennedy family who sounds like an unhinged conspiracy theorist when he compares vaccinations to Holocaust experiments is another long, strange trip.
Unlike the ‘60s, when they were counterculture heroes, rock icons like Eric Clapton and Van Morrison now sound like reactionary cranks standing on soap boxes when it comes to their pronouncements on vaccinations. What happened? Mr. Clapton claims that his critics are suffering from “mass formation hypnosis” possibly caused by “subliminal messages” on YouTube.
The epic guitar god battles of the ‘70s have been replaced by debates about the efficacy of ivermectin versus Moderna shots. Bluesman Robert Cray backed out of the opening slot of Mr. Clapton’s tour rather than be associated with the man.
That’s why the talk about Meat Loaf’s vaccination status shortly after his death last week was so fascinating. Meat Loaf was a militant anti-vaxxer. He told Post-Gazette pop music critic Scott Mervis that he valued his autonomy over his fear of death. “If I die, I die,” seemed to be his response to COVID.
Well, according to reports, the fatalistic rocker did die of COVID, adding to the 850,000 death toll in the U.S. alone. The virus also took such musical greats as John Prine, Wallace Roney, Ellis Marsalis and John “Bucky” Pizzarelli early in the pandemic.
COVID and its various iterations have sickened countless other pop stars: Madonna, Wiz Khalifa, Kanye West, Billie Eilish, Gene Simmons, Drake, Ed Sheeran and Elton John, among others. Billboard keeps a running list of those who have been stricken by it.
Guitar shredder and loudmouth Ted Nugent caught the virus and suffered enough to admit he thought he was going to die, but declared he still wouldn’t take the vaccine. Anti-vaxxer Kid Rock’s entire band caught it recently, but he’s been spared so far.
Steel Woods, a country rock band, tried to enlist a dead icon to bolster its refusal to play in venues that require proof of vaccination. Last year, the band posted a defiant picture of Johnny Cash with the following message on social media:
“We are an American Band with American values. We aim to create music that is healing and play shows for all who want to attend. We believe in an individual’s right to choose what they want to put into their body and that no one should be forced to do anything for their own good in order to go about their lives. The recent news that AEG and Live Nation venues — and specifically our show in St. Louis on 11/5 — will require vaccination or proof of negative test effective beginning of October is not something that we fully support or are willing to comply with.”
But singer/songwriter Roseanne Cash was having none of it. She refused to allow her father’s image to be appropriated by Steel Woods for its own purposes.
“THEIR statement, not my dad’s from beyond the grave,” Ms. Cash wrote on Twitter. “This is an irresponsible and thoughtless misuse of the image and supposed beliefs of someone who cannot offer his own opinion. Please remove his picture from your press release. I hope you all #getvaxxed.”
Through all the confusion and distraction of the moment, “Rockin’ in the Free World” continues to echo in the distance. Ironically, it’s the one Neil Young anthem that everyone from Eric Clapton and Kid Rock to the members of Crazy Horse will always claim as their own.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.