It's official. Democrat Ed Gainey has been elected the 57th mayor of Pittsburgh. Politicos can now stop their ritual hedging of the bets that gave Republican Tony Moreno hope he could somehow tap into a previously unseen groundswell of “Gainey-averse” Democrats to swing the election in his direction.
There was no anti-Gainey groundswell. Democrats voted like Democrats and rejected Mr. Moreno, who, after failing to win the Democratic primary, switched party allegiances to mount a doomed race against a popular Democrat who had defeated a well-funded Democratic mayor seeking a third and final term.
The appearance of the qualifier “if” along with the oft-repeated phrase “if Mr. Gainey is elected, he will become the first African American to serve as mayor of Pittsburgh” in news coverage may have annoyed Mr. Gainey at times, but it was a recognition of an uncomfortable reality — Pittsburgh has never shown an interest in electing an African American to the office he will occupy for the next four years.
Even in a solidly blue town where the Democratic registration dwarfs Republicans, it would’ve been folly to write off the possibility that Mr. Moreno wasn’t at least within spitting distance of an upset given the shifting racial dynamics of a city that kept politically ambitious African Americans marginalized for decades.
You could see in the way Mr. Moreno carried himself in the debates that at least he believed his promise to implement a gentler, more engaged law-and-order regimen with the Pittsburgh police was resonating with white working class voters concerned about the recent spike in violent crime.
Ed Gainey speaks at election night party
Whatever his political convictions, he wanted to be the first Republican to hold the mayor’s office in this town since the 1930s. Perhaps one day he will convince enough Democrats sufficiently disenchanted to vote Republican.
Read More
But not today.
Ed Gainey, 51, is now Pittsburgh’s first elected African American mayor. It is a tribute to the maturity of both Mayor-elect Gainey and Mr. Moreno that their often spirited quest for the job never deteriorated into a sewer of racialized grievances.
From the beginning, Mr. Gainey had the support of rank-and-file Democrats disillusioned with Mayor Bill Peduto.
Progressive Democrats in Pittsburgh were particularly drawn to Mr. Gainey’s message of building bridges between communities, especially after the summer of protest generated by the murder of George Floyd.
A message centered around making the city more livable for all and inviting to those who have historically been excluded from the rooms where policies are shaped had a wide appeal.
Despite being deeply skeptical of the city’s cozy relationship with nonprofits, the mayor-elect is not perceived as the Marxist wild man that opposition literature painted him in the closing days of the Democratic primary. Mr. Gainey ran on a message that was fundamentally hopeful about the city’s people and institutions, while not backing away from a promise of reforming those areas where needed.
But cynicism runs deep, even on the occasion of a victory like this for Mr. Gainey. And who can blame folks for being a little trepidatious? Pittsburgh does not have a long history of acceptance of Black leadership or even participation in the highest levels of city government outside of Pittsburgh City Council.
Some of the city’s most impressive African American leaders have served on City Council. Any one of them, especially Sala Udin and Jake Milliones to name two from an earlier era, would’ve been considered outstanding candidates for mayor in other cities, run for office — and won.
When you think about the wave of African American candidates voted into mayors’ offices of cities like Gary, Indiana, in 1967, followed by Wilson Goode in Philadelphia and Harold Washington in Chicago in the 1980s, the fact that Pittsburgh is several decades past those benchmarks is sobering.
What took so long for someone with a different set of experiences, but an equally deep love of Pittsburgh and political experience to be elected mayor?
Back when I had hair, I went to Hamm’s Barbershop in the Hill District one afternoon to get a read on the politics of the city’s Black community. It was sometime in 1989 and the Democratic primary was ground zero for Pittsburgh political intrigue.
Sitting in the main barber’s chair, I casually brought up civil rights lawyer Byrd Brown’s name — hoping it would start a constructive discussion about his chances in the primary while giving me some idea of the level of support he could expect from the folks like those in that room.
Let me just say that the notion of a Black candidate ever being elected to the Pittsburgh mayor’s office wasn’t something the barbers or customers would allow themselves to take seriously. Their laughter and expletives turned what had been a fairly subdued afternoon into an an opportunity for mockery at my expense.
One of the barbers said he’d given some money to Byrd Brown’s campaign, but he didn’t believe the man had a chance. Byrd Brown had too many things going against him, according to those barbershop oracles.
He was born into relative privilege in the Sugar Top section of the Hill District; he was exceptionally handsome and athletic; he was a star quarterback in high school; he was a graduate of Yale University; he was a respected civil rights lawyer who did pro bono work for members of the city’s Black community; and he was married to a white woman.
The consensus at the barbershop was that Byrd Brown would come in dead last in the primary. They were almost right. Out of five candidates, Brown came in fourth.
Of course, Byrd Brown’s failure to connect with the Black community on the populist level doomed him more than anything else. He should’ve been at Hamm’s Barber Shop or at Archie’s on Fifth Avenue making his case.
Ed Gainey understands this lesson to the depths of his bones. That’s why he’s everywhere. You can’t go to a barbecue, a wedding, a business opening, a funeral, a protest, a Little League game or a boring political gathering where he’s not present or at least has been invited.
Ed Gainey is a load-bearing pillar within Pittsburgh’s Black community and everyone knows it. To hundreds of people he shakes hands with every week, he’s not “Mr. Gainey.” He’s Ed.
How is he going to keep up this level of engagement as mayor? He can’t, despite the fact he’s actually promised to expand his understanding of his constituents by visiting every neighborhood and getting to know as many people as he possibly can.
He’ll work something out. He’s an extrovert, but a very smart one. He knows when to engage and when to pull back to get work done.
Ed Gainey already understands from experience how Pittsburgh’s often arcane bureaucracy works and he knows enough about being an effective leader to staff his administration with the best people he can find who are willing to implement his vision of what Pittsburgh needs to truly be “the most liveable city” for those already here.
He knows that there is “Black flight” from Pittsburgh and that Black infant mortality is still unacceptably high despite the presence of some of the country’s most successful medical centers. He’s read all of the white papers on the disparities in community outcomes broken down by race.
He’s promised to tackle the scourge of gang violence. He’s been to enough funerals to know what that pain feels like up close. He’s also a very adept political insider who happens to be a Black man well acquainted with the challenges of municipal leadership. Most of all, he’s a member of a community that couldn’t even bring itself to hope for an aggressive advocate on Grant Street until recently.
Even under Ed Gainey, Pittsburgh won’t become Shangri-la for Black people, but it has the potential to be so much more. Elections have consequences, we hear. Pittsburgh is about to find out if there’s anything to that.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.