“The only thing necessary for the persistence of evil is for good men to do nothing.”

— Edmund Burke

Last week during a discussion on Clubhouse over which he had been appointed moderator, the acclaimed actor Lakeith Stanfield failed the Edmund Burke test, big time.

There was evil talk in the online chat room over which he presided, but he failed to shut it down or confront those who were comparing Jews to termites. Those who were making distinctions between ordinary Jews and satanic Jews were allowed to hold the floor on the iPhone-based social media platform.

Advertise with us

The antisemitism on display received no significant pushback from the actor, who starred in “Sorry to Bother You” and “Get Out,” according to those who attended. For reasons that are known only to him, Mr. Stanfield, who has a Clubhouse following of 79,000, allowed himself to be appointed the sole moderator of a discussion that had already been shut down once under another moderator.

In an era when reputations and careers can be destroyed with a wayward tweet, why did one of the stars of “Atlanta” and an Oscar nominee for his role as an FBI informant in “Judas and the Black Messiah” take on a role fraught with such moral responsibility on a social media app still getting its bearings?

The name of the chat room discussion should’ve given the 29-year-old actor a clue of what to expect: “Someone Ended the Room About Farrakhan.”

What could possibly go wrong? The previous discussion about the Nation of Islam leader and his hoary rhetoric regarding Jews should’ve presented something of a cautionary tale to Mr. Stanfield who comes across as exceptionally well-informed and humane in interviews.

Swatting down a few moronic beer hall ranters running their mouths about Jewish conspiracies shouldn’t have been that difficult, especially for a celebrity who was made the moderator because of his charisma and reputed intelligence.

Advertise with us

Unless the bigots in the room were specifically setting the popular actor up for failure, they probably would’ve deferred to any rising indignation in his voice, especially if it were accompanied by a clever rebuke or two in response to the slurs. The time to stand up to racist bullies is always in the moment they are prattling on, not after the crowd has dispersed.

The next day, Mr. Stanfield showed up in another Clubhouse chat room and tried to explain his failure to exercise his prerogative as moderator the day before to mute the voices of those in the room determined to demonize Jews for a litany of world-spanning atrocities stretching back eons.

“It’s been a crazy couple 48 hours,” he reportedly said. Part of the appeal of Clubhouse for many is that conversations are not recorded, but that conceit is probably a bit too unrealistic now that the latest social media platform has become a place of controversy.

“I’ve been in a couple of rooms where a lot of [expletive] has been discussed and talked about, very heightened emotional states. It’s been very enlightening and interesting to me. I never really knew that this debate existed in this way about identity, the origins of Judaism in Jewishness, and how many different interpretations there are of different things, whether or not it’s a religion and ethno-religion or what it is a faith race,” he said garbling the message a bit at the end of his opening statement.

Mr. Stanfield told the Jewish teachers in the room who had witnessed the earlier encounter and had gathered to discuss it that “someone” had derailed the discussion and that “someone would say something that was without a doubt antisemitic...and then instead of acknowledging why it was antisemitic, it would just go back to that original person, and then it would kind of repeat what they were saying, they clearly weren’t listening to us.”

Advertise with us

By blaming a nameless “someone,” the actor was playing a bit of a blame game himself, but his desire to distance himself from the hate expressed in the chat room he failed to moderate earlier was appreciated. Though no one accused him of personally using antisemitic language, his attempt at neutrality in a room where racist hate was expressed was swiftly denounced on Twitter, where he had also become a trending subject for past homophobic statements. Black millennials weighed in and expressed their disgust along with Jewish and queer activists about past comments. Sensing that social media was turning against him, Mr. Stanfield posted a more unequivocal apology on his Instagram account, where he has a million followers:

“Yesterday I entered an online chat room on Clubhouse about the teachings of Louis Farrakhan. When the room’s participants noticed me, I was quickly made a moderator of this room. At some point during the dialogue the discussion took a very negative turn when several users made abhorrent antisemitic statements and at that point, I should have either shut down the discussion or removed myself from it entirely. I condemn hate speech and discriminatory views of every kind. I unconditionally apologize for what went on in that chat room and for allowing my presence there to give a platform to hate speech. I am not an anti-Semite, nor do I condone any of the beliefs discussed in that chat room.”

Mr. Stanfield has a lot to lose if the controversy over the Clubhouse debacle becomes an opportunistic talking point for culture vultures on conservative media eager to “cancel” an outspoken actor best known for his progressive politics. He’s currently in Europe with the cast of “Atlanta” filming upcoming episodes of the groundbreaking show that made him a star. He’s also making the rounds promoting his lead voice role in the Netflix animated series “Yasuke,” based on the life of a legendary 16th-century Black samurai. Now is not the time to lose the goodwill of a multiracial audience that has rewarded your various projects with acclaim and hit status.

But it’s not likely that folks who have taken to minimizing the Jan. 6 attack have enough residual moral integrity to go after Lakeith Stanfield for failing to stand up to antisemitic rants in real time. When an entire political caucus lacks the guts to stand up to Donald Trump’s Big Lie and the “Camp Auschwitz” crew that assaulted police officers, hunted members of Congress and paraded a Confederate flag through the halls of the Capitol, they have forfeited any right to be taken seriously on questions of racial intolerance ever again.

I was invited to join Clubhouse a few months ago, but I have yet to participate in a discussion or start a group of my own, so I don’t know how difficult it would be to mute one that was getting out of control. If it is difficult, that’s yet another sign that a social media platform that tolerates poisonous rants at the beginning is going to bear much bitter fruit in the future. Still, I’m happy to hear that Clubhouse has removed a lot of racist troublemakers from the site in recent weeks, but hate remains a problem on every social media platform.

Advertise with us

Haters prefer that good men and women do nothing while they rant and plot in the shadows. They deserve the courtesy of loud and public rebukes the moment that ignorance begins falling from their lips. Saying nothing allows the evil Burke warned us about to persist.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.