Please ex­cuse the self-in­dul­gence. This is the first col­umn in an oc­ca­sional se­ries in which I re­spond to the most fre­quent com­plaints of rac­ist trolls. Warn­ing: If you want to main­tain your faith in hu­man­ity, steer clear of the com­ments sec­tion of my col­umn:

Q: Why do you, a Black man, write about so many Black things all the time? It’s al­ways black­ity-black­ity-black-black with you! You’re ob­vi­ously rac­ist be­cause white peo­ple don’t think about Black peo­ple as much as Black peo­ple think about rac­ism, im­plicit bias and all the things that make Amer­ica a liv­ing hell. Give it a rest and write about some­thing that doesn’t in­volve sys­temic rac­ism for once.

A: I write about Black “things,” as you put it, be­cause I find the Black ex­pe­ri­ence enor­mously in­ter­est­ing. As a Black man for­tu­nate enough to have a col­umn in a town where such plat­forms are rare — es­pe­cially for Black women — I have a re­spon­si­bil­ity to ad­dress is­sues of par­tic­u­lar in­ter­est to folks like me. I don’t care if it makes you un­com­fort­able.

Q: Don’t you re­al­ize how bor­ing your col­umn is to white peo­ple like me? I feel un­der siege from the open­ing sen­tence to the last para­graph ev­ery time I read one of your col­umns.

Advertise with us

A: Yet you con­tinue to read and com­ment on a “bor­ing col­umn,” an irony that eludes your big­oted liz­ard brain. Frankly, I don’t mind that you find it bor­ing. I find your in­ces­sant whin­ing about the prev­a­lence of Black is­sues in this col­umn bor­ing. You’re wel­come to skip it, along with most of the other things in the pa­per you don’t read. But the fact that you’re still read­ing it means you’re in­ter­ested in what I have to say. You may be rac­ist, but at least you’re a dis­crim­i­nat­ing one (pun in­tended). You’re so en­gaged by what I write that you hide be­hind ri­dic­u­lous pseu­do­nyms to spew ig­no­rance at the bot­tom of ev­ery col­umn as if you hate it when you don’t. You feel guilty and con­victed, or else you’d shut up and learn.

Q: You never write about Black-on-Black crime or prob­lems in the Black com­mu­nity. White peo­ple like me care more about the lat­est shoot­ings in Wilkins­burg than you do. That’s why we al­ways bring it up. You should learn a thing or two from Can­dace Owens or Di­a­mond & Silk about Black self-sab­o­tage and re­ori­ent your pri­or­i­ties. If all Blacks were like them — clown­ish and ser­vile — Amer­ica would be bet­ter off.

A: When this col­umn de­buted in 1996, I wrote about crime and neigh­bor­hood shoot­ings ad nau­seam. In fact, peo­ple like you com­plained about that, too. “We’re tired of all this na­vel-gaz­ing about kill­ings on the East End, snitch­ing, Crips v. Bloods, po­lice bru­tal­ity, in­sti­tu­tional rac­ism in ed­u­ca­tion, blah-blah-blah” — folks like you used to bleat be­tween ra­cial ep­i­thets left on my an­swer­ing ma­chine. “You’re just try­ing to make the white man feel guilty for lock­ing you an­i­mals in your cages.”

When my think­ing be­came a lit­tle more nu­anced and I be­came less in­ter­ested in be­com­ing the next Stan­ley Crouch, you hated that too. Now you’re nos­tal­gic for Tony Nor­man ’96-’98 be­cause he wasn’t writ­ing about the enor­mous im­pact of white su­prem­acy in ev­ery area of Amer­i­can life. He was writ­ing like a typ­i­cal Black neo-lib­eral, blam­ing Black peo­ple for not ac­com­mo­dat­ing them­selves to white stan­dards, which are al­ways hyp­o­crit­i­cal and il­lu­sory.

Q: Why do you hate white peo­ple?

Advertise with us

A: Only a mo­ron would ask a ques­tion like that.

Q: Why don’t you give both sides of a con­tro­versy equal time? For in­stance, you’re al­ways crit­i­cal of Don­ald Trump and Re­pub­li­cans, but you’ve never said any­thing bad about Pres­i­dent Barack Obama and the Dem­o­crats. That’s not ob­jec­tive jour­nal­ism.

A: We had eight years of the Obama ad­min­is­tra­tion. Do you re­ally think your charge that I never wrote any­thing crit­i­cal about Mr. Obama would hold up to even the most ca­sual Google search? Also, you don’t seem to un­der­stand the dif­fer­ence be­tween what col­um­nists do and what re­port­ers do. If you’re read­ing my col­umn, you’re go­ing to get my rad­i­cally sub­jec­tive opin­ion. If my bias of­fends you, stop read­ing it. If enough peo­ple stop read­ing the col­umn, it will go away. Capisce?

Q: Sev­eral of your Post-Ga­zette col­leagues mix it up with those of us who reg­u­larly post in the web­site’s com­ment sec­tion. Sure, they all hap­pen to be white, and they’re usu­ally not writ­ing about is­sues that trig­ger us — like race — so they’re not sub­ject to as much rac­ist in­vec­tive. Still, they do prove that civil dis­course is pos­si­ble. Mean­while, you seem to have noth­ing but dis­dain for your on­line com­mu­nity of crit­ics.

A: You got that right.

Advertise with us

Q: You’ve been part of Pitts­burgh me­dia since 1988. What do you want most to see hap­pen if you could snap your fin­gers and make it so?

A: Be­sides get­ting a pay raise af­ter 14 years? This is a re­gion in des­per­ate need of di­verse voices in man­age­ment and on the streets where sto­ries are filed and pic­tures are taken. Not just news­pa­pers. This in­cludes ra­dio, TV news and web­sites. Pitts­burgh has never had a golden pe­riod of pro­por­tional rep­re­sen­ta­tion in lo­cal me­dia, but there were far more re­port­ers and man­ag­ers of color hav­ing an im­pact on cov­er­age de­cades ago than there are now.

Be­lieve it or not, I was not the first Black col­um­nist in Pitts­burgh. My friend Mike Seate, who was proudly right-of-cen­ter when he wrote for the Pitts­burgh Tri­bune-Review, was there be­fore me. He was hated by right-wing trolls no mat­ter what he wrote. He was abused by rac­ist trolls for years be­fore I got on the scene. We used to joke that if we ever gath­ered our hate mail to­gether un­der one cover, it would make a hel­luva phone book. We both got the N-word screamed at us more times on our of­fice an­swer­ing ma­chines than Mar­tin Luther King ever did.

Our friend Lou Ran­som split the dif­fer­ence be­tween me and Mike by writ­ing scru­pu­lously fair and bal­anced col­umns ev­ery week for the New Pitts­burgh Cou­rier, where he was also an ed­i­tor. Still, there was more ra­cial and ide­o­log­i­cal di­ver­sity in the lo­cal me­dia in those days — though sadly, no Black fe­male col­um­nists. At least we have the in­dis­pens­able Tereneh Idia at Pitts­burgh City Paper to­day to fill that enor­mous space.

But we re­ally need doz­ens of Terenehs. We also need more re­port­ers with the poise of my col­league Alexis John­son and the in­teg­rity of my col­league Mi­chael San­tiago. We need to ex­pand the spaces where Black voices truly mat­ter in Pitts­burgh me­dia.

Tony Nor­man: tnor­man@post-ga­zette.com or 412-263-1631. Twit­ter @Tony_Nor­manPG.