Please excuse the self-indulgence. This is the first column in an occasional series in which I respond to the most frequent complaints of racist trolls. Warning: If you want to maintain your faith in humanity, steer clear of the comments section of my column:
Q: Why do you, a Black man, write about so many Black things all the time? It’s always blackity-blackity-black-black with you! You’re obviously racist because white people don’t think about Black people as much as Black people think about racism, implicit bias and all the things that make America a living hell. Give it a rest and write about something that doesn’t involve systemic racism for once.
A: I write about Black “things,” as you put it, because I find the Black experience enormously interesting. As a Black man fortunate enough to have a column in a town where such platforms are rare — especially for Black women — I have a responsibility to address issues of particular interest to folks like me. I don’t care if it makes you uncomfortable.
Q: Don’t you realize how boring your column is to white people like me? I feel under siege from the opening sentence to the last paragraph every time I read one of your columns.
A: Yet you continue to read and comment on a “boring column,” an irony that eludes your bigoted lizard brain. Frankly, I don’t mind that you find it boring. I find your incessant whining about the prevalence of Black issues in this column boring. You’re welcome to skip it, along with most of the other things in the paper you don’t read. But the fact that you’re still reading it means you’re interested in what I have to say. You may be racist, but at least you’re a discriminating one (pun intended). You’re so engaged by what I write that you hide behind ridiculous pseudonyms to spew ignorance at the bottom of every column as if you hate it when you don’t. You feel guilty and convicted, or else you’d shut up and learn.
Q: You never write about Black-on-Black crime or problems in the Black community. White people like me care more about the latest shootings in Wilkinsburg than you do. That’s why we always bring it up. You should learn a thing or two from Candace Owens or Diamond & Silk about Black self-sabotage and reorient your priorities. If all Blacks were like them — clownish and servile — America would be better off.
Read More
A: When this column debuted in 1996, I wrote about crime and neighborhood shootings ad nauseam. In fact, people like you complained about that, too. “We’re tired of all this navel-gazing about killings on the East End, snitching, Crips v. Bloods, police brutality, institutional racism in education, blah-blah-blah” — folks like you used to bleat between racial epithets left on my answering machine. “You’re just trying to make the white man feel guilty for locking you animals in your cages.”
When my thinking became a little more nuanced and I became less interested in becoming the next Stanley Crouch, you hated that too. Now you’re nostalgic for Tony Norman ’96-’98 because he wasn’t writing about the enormous impact of white supremacy in every area of American life. He was writing like a typical Black neo-liberal, blaming Black people for not accommodating themselves to white standards, which are always hypocritical and illusory.
Q: Why do you hate white people?
A: Only a moron would ask a question like that.
Q: Why don’t you give both sides of a controversy equal time? For instance, you’re always critical of Donald Trump and Republicans, but you’ve never said anything bad about President Barack Obama and the Democrats. That’s not objective journalism.
A: We had eight years of the Obama administration. Do you really think your charge that I never wrote anything critical about Mr. Obama would hold up to even the most casual Google search? Also, you don’t seem to understand the difference between what columnists do and what reporters do. If you’re reading my column, you’re going to get my radically subjective opinion. If my bias offends you, stop reading it. If enough people stop reading the column, it will go away. Capisce?
Q: Several of your Post-Gazette colleagues mix it up with those of us who regularly post in the website’s comment section. Sure, they all happen to be white, and they’re usually not writing about issues that trigger us — like race — so they’re not subject to as much racist invective. Still, they do prove that civil discourse is possible. Meanwhile, you seem to have nothing but disdain for your online community of critics.
A: You got that right.
Q: You’ve been part of Pittsburgh media since 1988. What do you want most to see happen if you could snap your fingers and make it so?
A: Besides getting a pay raise after 14 years? This is a region in desperate need of diverse voices in management and on the streets where stories are filed and pictures are taken. Not just newspapers. This includes radio, TV news and websites. Pittsburgh has never had a golden period of proportional representation in local media, but there were far more reporters and managers of color having an impact on coverage decades ago than there are now.
Believe it or not, I was not the first Black columnist in Pittsburgh. My friend Mike Seate, who was proudly right-of-center when he wrote for the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, was there before me. He was hated by right-wing trolls no matter what he wrote. He was abused by racist trolls for years before I got on the scene. We used to joke that if we ever gathered our hate mail together under one cover, it would make a helluva phone book. We both got the N-word screamed at us more times on our office answering machines than Martin Luther King ever did.
Our friend Lou Ransom split the difference between me and Mike by writing scrupulously fair and balanced columns every week for the New Pittsburgh Courier, where he was also an editor. Still, there was more racial and ideological diversity in the local media in those days — though sadly, no Black female columnists. At least we have the indispensable Tereneh Idia at Pittsburgh City Paper today to fill that enormous space.
But we really need dozens of Terenehs. We also need more reporters with the poise of my colleague Alexis Johnson and the integrity of my colleague Michael Santiago. We need to expand the spaces where Black voices truly matter in Pittsburgh media.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.