Jack Erdie was once well-known as a troubadour around town. Usually playing solo on an acoustic guitar, his idiosyncratic, folk-influenced songs helped audiences view familiar situations and relationships in intriguing new ways.

During those years, he recorded several CDs and developed a reputation as one of the region’s finest songwriters. For a short time, he led a band called the Insubordinates. He opened for Anne Feeney three times during a national tour, and she recorded one of his songs.

“I was a bad choice to open for a ‘Protest Queen’ since I had only two protest songs, both against the Bush machine,” he quipped later.

It wasn’t a bad start for a career that would wind through different creative outlets and different cities and eventually leave him sheltering in place and working on a podcast he plans to launch soon.

Advertise with us

The route here from those early concert stages has been both long and winding.

Even as Mr. Erdie was honing his musical craft, he was also strengthening his acting chops. After coming to Pittsburgh in 1993 from West Virginia, he left for Los Angeles in ’98 to find his fortune in Hollywood, only to return after three years, humbled but matured by the experience. He quit acting because of the paucity of roles, except for some work in independent films and on voiceovers.

He even wrote a novel, although he didn’t do anything with it. “It just felt good to create a thing of my own again without waiting for the phone to ring and say, ‘OK, we think you’ll do,’ [or] waiting for permission or direction or compromise,” he said.

From 2003 to 2008, he didn’t act at all.

Then the work came, of course. Mr. Erdie found opportunities in movies filmed in the Pittsburgh region, including “The Road,” “One for the Money,” “Abduction” and “Out of the Furnace.” He also appeared in the series “Outsiders” and “Banshee.”

Advertise with us
Jack Erdie in the independent movie "Tics" poster.

After getting the acting bug again, he returned to LA for a second sojourn, this one lasting five years. He was cast as Richard Speck, the real-life killer of nurses on Netflix’s “Mindhunter,” a series filmed in the Pittsburgh area.

Because of acclaim the role generated, Mr. Erdie assumed it would translate into more opportunities in LA. But those simply never materialized. He continued living an actor’s life in one of America’s most expensive cities. He taught acting, did voiceover work, caught small roles, worked on screenplays, learned how to put a podcast together — and drove for ride-hailing service Lyft.

So last June, Mr. Erdie returned to Pittsburgh for the much lower cost of living and the movie and TV opportunities here.

He was once again seen in local stage productions. His role on “Mindhunter” had raised his profile here, and people wanted to see him.

Most recently, he’s been working on a crowdfunded movie project with local filmmaker Ted Haynes about mental illness called “Tics.” Thanks to his previous run as a singer-songwriter, Mr. Erdie also has the option of picking up his guitar and booking a show. And he’s been teaching a very physical form of acting, as well as an online course about the business of acting.

Advertise with us

That might seem to be enough, but he’s still full of ideas. Lately, he’s been mulling thoughts triggered during thousands of conversations he had with clients as a Lyft driver.

“I met medical ethicists, health care think-tank people,” Mr. Erdie said, stopping short of doing a full litany of his customers. The long, deep conversations with people outside his usual orbit reinforced a suspicion he has always harbored.

“No matter what they tell you in the industry about people’s attention spans, there’s a hunger across the board for a return to long-form discussion that actually gets to some real [meaning] rather than sound bites,” he said.

When, without warning, the COVID-19 pandemic hit and disrupted everyone’s best-laid plans, he got more serious about that idea. Mr. Erdie, like most other Americans, is sheltering in place until the pandemic eases.

“I’m working from home,” the 54-year-old Brookline resident said. “The other plans I had just had the door slammed on them because of this — things that required a face-to-face sit-down with people, so I just started thinking how to match what’s going on [out there] with a personal mission: a podcast idea I have.

Advertise with us

“The old normal is temporarily halted,” he said. “While people are stuck at home, or if they’re still going to work, they’re now facing tremendous anxiety, frustration and some anger around it.

“I want to give them [time] to talk about: ‘What was your old normal? What’s your new normal? What’s it like now? When it’s over, what do you want the world to look like? What do you want normal to be like when this is over? Who’s to say it has to be the same?

“Why go back to the things we feel were wrong with the old normal?” he said. “Maybe it’s time to come up with ways to make normal better, make human interaction better, make the way we treat our planet better.”

Mr. Erdie has named his podcast “Plague Talk” and hopes to have the first episode up soon.

“It’s important to me to reach a wide base and be reflective of the whole cross-section of Pittsburgh,” he said. “I want people who are faith-based as well as people who don’t believe we have anything but each other. People from the right side of the aisle, people from the left.

Advertise with us

“We’ll get all perspectives, but it’s always going to be part of my brand to hold people to facts and bring them back from propaganda and anecdote on either side.”

“Plague Talk” will be part of a podcast family network that Mr. Erdie envisions called Smeartipod — smart with heart. He hopes the podcast and the site will be valuable sources of information and morale-boosting during a time of social isolation.

Another show he plans will be called “Talk of Ages.” Mr. Erdie describes that concept as in-depth, raw and honest conversations with people transitioning into less independent living spaces. “[Talk of Ages] will be ongoing, but I hope ‘Plague Talk’ will be over soon,” he said.

He’s still working on a tagline for his first podcast. He’s leaning toward: “Stay at home, but let the world hear your voice.” It’s better than “Bring out your dead,” he jokes — referring to the chant heard in the streets of Europe (and later parodied by Monty Python) during the Black Death, when gravediggers roamed the land collecting the dead.

Jack Erdie is much more optimistic about the future than that.

Advertise with us

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. 

‘

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.