The headline on the front page of the Philadelphia Inquirer earlier this week showcased the biggest difference between Pittsburgh and our sister metropolis to the east: “North Philly man cleared of murder after 27 years in prison, the 10th exoneration under DA Larry Krasner.”
Such a headline in this paper or any other local media is unimaginable under Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. Try to imagine a headline touting the current DA’s efforts to clear, say, a North Side man — or anyone else unfairly convicted of a crime — who has had to languish in prison for decades because of a coerced confession, prosecutorial misconduct or outright police corruption. If you can imagine it, you should be writing scripts in Hollywood.
As has been documented in news reports recently, Mr. Zappala’s office can barely generate the interest or energy to investigate alibis of those merely accused of crimes, much less convicted.
The headlines Pittsburghers are likely to see showcase teens spending months in jail because, according to Mr. Zappala, the investigators, the cops and maybe even some of his own people didn’t do their jobs.
It’s never Mr. Zappala’s fault.
Even when he tepidly “takes responsibility” for some outrageous miscarriage of justice, one senses that Mr. Zappala doesn’t believe it’s a reflection on his management style or the priorities he has set for his office. Benign neglect has worked for him for decades and that’s not likely to change because Philly’s DA is some kind of wild-eyed liberal reformer.
Read More
On rare occasions, Mr. Zappala will humor his constituents by falling on a tiny rubber sword before quickly picking himself up and going about his business ignoring their cries for justice, because, well, he’s the Democratic incumbent don’t cha know!
This week, Mr. Zappala’s campaign told the Greater Pittsburgh Chapter of the League of Women Voters that he would be skipping yet another candidate’s forum scheduled for Monday: “We get a number of requests to be places and do our best, but we can’t be everywhere as much as we would like to be. If anything changes, we will let you know.”
With less than a month left until the voters go to the polls, Mr. Zappala refuses to share any stage with Independent challenger Lisa Middleman, a reform-minded candidate in the mold of Philly’s Mr. Krasner and other conscientious DAs who have sprung up across the nation in recent years.
Mr. Zappala’s intention appears to be to deprive Ms. Middleman’s campaign of as much media exposure as possible and run out the clock before voters fully catch on to the fact that there’s an alternative to the lazy — and mostly unaccountable — status quo.
I don’t believe Mr. Zappala is “afraid” of debating Ms. Middleman. I believe he’s mostly being contemptuous of democracy because that’s the easiest tactic in a two-person race. If he believed that the people of Allegheny County deserved to hear a counterargument to his “do nothing” vision for the district attorney’s office, he would’ve agreed to the League of Women Voters’ request to pick an alternate date for the forum.
Instead, Mr. Zappala pretended to still be nursing a case of existential angst over comments Ms. Middleman made 27 years ago about jury selection: “I don’t like fat women on my jury because I don’t want them to be jealous that I’m not fat. That’s a stupid reason, it is nonetheless a reason I think of.”
After expressing disappointment that the League would even consider inviting Ms. Middleman to a candidate’s forum based on something she said three decades ago, his campaign spokesman Stevey Zappala — yes, the nepotism is that strong in Pittsburgh — wrote without a hint of self-awareness: “That type of rhetoric is unconscionable and has no place in our criminal justice system or our community. We have no desire to share a stage with anyone who espouses those kinds of beliefs.”
Of course, Ms. Middleman has apologized for using indelicate terms like “big, fat, fat piggy people” nearly three decades ago, but Mr. Zappala continues to be so scandalized by the memory of her pre-PC-era fat-shaming that he can’t be bothered to fulfill the democratic expectation and courtesy of debating her for the enlightenment of the voters.
Mr. Zappala’s lame evasions reveal the contempt he has for the intelligence of Allegheny County voters who are supposed to somehow believe that the same district attorney who let four innocent teenagers linger in jail for months is so tenderhearted that 27 years later he still harbors a grudge against someone who used a slur against fat people.
This is the definition of DPP — Democratic Party privilege — in Allegheny County, a region that operates on the principle of hereditary succession, arrogant incumbency and blind party loyalty.
When I think about what other district attorneys are doing in other cities to pursue justice and compare that to what’s happening here in Pittsburgh, I get sick to my stomach. While Mr. Zappala plays games by pretending to be so incensed by Ms. Middleman’s decades-old insult that he can’t debate her, there are major miscarriages of justice that aren’t being aggressively addressed or investigated.
Personally, I’ll take the Independent candidate who once threw shade at fat people over the incumbent DA who can’t get a conviction against cops who kill unarmed black civilians. I’ll take the idealistic reformer over the cynical pol who undercharges cowards who brutalize black women at gas stations while overcharging black and brown people for minor or equivalent crimes.
Give me the would-be disruptor of the status quo over the entrenched incumbent who can’t bring himself to acknowledge the manifest unfairness of the region’s criminal justice system.
“Innocent people shouldn’t be sitting in jail cells,” Philly’s ridiculously conscientious district attorney said after his 10th exoneration of an unjustly convicted person in less than two years. Shortly after his election, Mr. Krasner created something called the Conviction Integrity Unit that identifies possible wrongful prosecutions and convictions and investigates the circumstances, an unimaginable proposition under Mr. Zappala, the kind of law-and-order Democrat this region considers progressive.
“It’s not that hard. The system should be just. It should be fair,” Mr. Krasner said as if it was the most self-evident thing in the world. If you can imagine the next Allegheny County district attorney talking this way, then there’s still hope — but you’ll have to vote accordingly on Nov. 5.
The choice of Allegheny County’s DA is as important as who sits in the mayor and county executive’s offices. In a one-party town like Pittsburgh, the DA may be the most important choice a voter can make.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.