It doesn’t take much to reenact a scene from a Charles Dickens novel in Pennsylvania. As the national economy continues humming along with the efficiency of the Industrial Revolution, half of the kids in this state qualify for free school lunch.

“It was the best of times, it was the worst of times,” you’re tempted to say, echoing the opening line from  “A Tale of Two Cities,” a novel that acknowledged the social ills visited upon the poor even as the rich got richer in London and Paris.

But this is Pennsylvania. Our literary and social realities bend more toward the “Oliver Twist” end of Dickens’ magnificent oeuvre. Recently, the Wyoming Valley West School District in northeastern Pennsylvania sent letters to the parents of students worthy of villainy straight out of Dickens’ novel:

“Your child has been sent to school every day without money and without a breakfast and/or lunch. This is a failure to provide your child with proper nutrition, and you can be sent to Dependency Court for neglecting your child’s right to food,” wrote Joseph Muth, school district director of federal programs, with the finesse of a Victorian-era villain rubbing his hands in delight.

Advertise with us

“If you are taken to Dependency Court, the result may be your child being removed from your home and placed in foster care. Please remit payment as soon as possible to avoid being reported to the proper authorities.”

Because the Wyoming Valley West School District is in Luzerne County, the threat was not taken lightly. Those who remember the infamous “Kids for Cash” scandal that sent former Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas judges Mark Ciavarella and Michael Conahan to prison for filling for-profit juvenile detention centers with kids in exchange for kickbacks know that our state has more than its fair share of heartless officials and bureaucrats itching to do the unthinkable.

Within hours of sending out the notices, the school district was the focus of national outrage — and deservedly so. Various good Samaritans stepped forward to pay the $22,467 debt so that parents of children targeted by the letters wouldn’t have to live in fear of a child being scooped up by social services at school someday.

Until a few days ago, the school district adamantly refused to accept payment from a third party. “It’s a fundamental obligation of parents to house, feed, and clothe their children,” a school board member told The Philadelphia Inquirer. “It’s not our obligation. This nanny-state mentality is troubling to me.”

There’s a scene from “Oliver Twist” that comes to mind when encountering a quote like this: “Please, Sir. I want some more.” That’s the point in the novel where the hungry orphan, with upturned bowl and expectant eyes, asks for more gruel. But the cook and all the officials at the workhouse considered withholding food an indispensable part of character development for the orphan wretches.

Advertise with us

Todd Carmichael, the CEO and co-founder of La Colombe coffee, a Philly-based company, had been rebuffed several times after offering to erase the lunch debt in its entirety. Mr. Carmichael is a well-known liberal activist in Philly, so there may have been a reluctance on the part of the school district to take his money because of the optics.

Mr. Carmichael, who received free lunches himself as a child, complained to the media about not being allowed to pay the outstanding bill. The onslaught of national and local bad press, including a fiery editorial denunciation by The Philadelphia Inquirer, caused the Wyoming Valley West School District to abruptly reverse itself in a letter to district residents:

“The Wyoming Valley West School District Board of Directors sincerely apologizes for the tone of the letter that was sent regarding lunch debt. It wasn’t the intention of the district to harm or inconvenience any of the families of our school district. We want to thank everyone for their concern and generous donation offers to help pay for the unpaid lunch bills.

“We would like to acknowledge Mr. Todd Carmichael’s generous offer. We have been in touch with … the Wyoming Valley West Educational Foundation (previously established to benefit the students of our district). After discussions with [it] and all members of the Wyoming Valley West School Board, we have decided to accept Mr. Carmichael’s generous donation. It will be directed to the Wyoming Valley West Educational Foundation to eliminate the debt owed by the parents.”

Not content to leave it there, the school district slipped in one more self-justifying attempt to mitigate its initial cruelty:

Advertise with us

“Wyoming Valley West School District followed all USDA and PDE regulations. All meals served to students were chosen by the students from our regular menu. No shaming occurred and no alternate meals were provided. Again, please accept our sincere apology for any harm or inconvenience the letter caused.”

Congratulating itself for not serving literal gruel to the kids whose parents weren’t current with their lunch bill is consistent with the cluelessness the school board has exhibited since sending out its original letter.

Because no one has quit or been fired (yet), the appalling lapse in empathy towards the estimated 64% of students in the district who live below the poverty line could happen again. We live in a peculiar age where cruelty is now sanctioned at the very top of the political food chain. It only backs down when it can be sufficiently shamed. But what do we do about those who are both cruel and beyond shame?

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.