There’s a reason most people dread jury duty. It’s one of the few opportunities that ordinary citizens have besides voting and paying taxes to connect their values to the exercise of a civic duty. It requires a willingness to weigh competing interests with a moral and intellectual seriousness often missing from day-to-day life, especially when the stakes are high.
Sorting through conflicting evidence during jury deliberation, meant to obscure the truth as much as illuminate it, isn’t easy. In a trial where the stakes are low, there’s no guarantee that even an attentive and conscientious jury will find its way to a just outcome given the variables thrown its way.
Raise the stakes and judicial uncertainty rises exponentially, especially when the defendant is a representative of the criminal justice system. Even a former police officer on trial for a shooting resulting in the death of an unarmed citizen will still manage to carry just enough residual authority to compel a jury’s benefit of the doubt.
Here in Allegheny County, it is difficult, if not impossible, to think of a single case in which a police officer was convicted by either a local jury or one bused in from the hinterlands for killing an unarmed civilian. It’s a crime that’s nearly impossible to prove, given the leeway police officers have to use lethal force in accordance with state law and departmental training.
The absence of an actual threat during a shooting doesn’t matter if an officer feels threatened by the intangibles of circumstance. As soon as the adrenalin spikes, a perceived threat can be dealt with at the officer’s discretion, even if it means shooting an unarmed civilian.
Yes, there are times when police officers have to justify deadly gun fire, excessive use of Tasers and illegal choke holds to a jury, but history and the law are on their side once jury deliberations begin, which is why it is so difficult to get a conviction.
Read More
It’s a structural legal advantage that even highly motivated prosecutors usually cannot overcome, especially in Western Pennsylvania where juries usually defer to police testimony and experts-for-hire who specialize in finding the “reasonable” in the indefensible for $15,000 — tops.
Last week, former East Pittsburgh police officer Michael Rosfeld told a multiracial jury from Dauphin County that he believed Antwon Rose II presented a deadly threat to him despite the fact that Antwon was running away and had no weapon.
The ex-officer told the jury that he shot the Rankin teen in the back as he ran to “protect” both himself and the community. It was such an outrageous statement that many assumed that the logic circuits of the jurors would kick on in protest. After all, Mr. Rosfeld was echoing the Vietnam War-era rationale of having to destroy a village to save it.
The Rosfeld jury deliberated for four hours before returning a “not guilty” verdict. Four hours is an inordinately short amount of time to elect a foreman, review the evidence, eat a meal and deliberate a verdict of such monumental consequences.
Chances are that the jury was on the bus back to Dauphin County before the verdict sunk in. Even the Borg, the hive-minded aliens on “Star Trek,” couldn’t have gotten to a consensus as quickly as that jury despite having their minds cybernetically linked. This makes last week’s proceedings on heavily-fortified Grant Street less a murder trial than an exercise in bias confirmation.
There are many who feel that, now that a jury has weighed the evidence and found Mr. Rosfeld not guilty, further protests are unseemly and endanger the social order because they rile up the passions of the community and disrupt too many things.
But this is exactly why protests like the one staged by students on Monday are valuable — and necessary. Unjust laws that shield cops from the consequences of their bad decisions and actions are being called out by outraged citizens who are finally waking up to the real cost of being politically disengaged. These citizen protesters are the flipside of the jurors. They now know that it matters who writes the laws and what those laws say regarding the use of lethal force by the police. It matters who sits in the district attorney’s office and how cases like the killing of Antwon Rose II are prosecuted.
Michael Rosfeld said he pulled the trigger to “save” himself and the community. Meanwhile, outraged citizens of that community, including high school students, are marching across town, interrupting traffic and demonstrating in restaurants to “save” themselves.
One of these acts — the shooting of an unarmed teenage suspect — was violent and beyond a jury’s ability to judge or punish. The peaceful protests, though disruptive, call attention to the necessity of overhauling antiquated laws governing police shootings. Young people who are Antwon’s age are at the forefront of this protest.
While the Rosfeld jury made a decision that was contrary to even the most minimal expectations of justice, its verdict was consistent with longstanding laws and practices. That’s the problem. That’s why young Pittsburghers of all persuasions have finally felt compelled to march in the streets in recent days. They’re tired of letting juries have the last word. The laws have to change. Taking responsibility for improving laws requires speaking out and marching.
Protesting is just as important as jury duty in a democracy, especially if it leads to more voting. After all, jurors are selected from voter rolls. The young people in the streets today will become the jurors of tomorrow.
Tony Norman is a columnist for the Post-Gazette (tnorman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1631.)






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.