When people ask what I thought of “Green Book,” this year’s Oscar-winning best picture, it feels like one of those Rorschach-test moments that are such a common part of the American experience.

On the one hand, you don’t want to dash the enthusiasm of well-meaning white people for a film they believe showcases feel-good bonhomie between the races that is much needed in this Trumpian age.

On the other hand, there’s a temptation to interrogate white people who liked the movie (and only white folks who liked “Green Book” even bother to ask black folks what they thought of it) what it is about a sly update of “Driving Miss Daisy” that they find so compelling.

Since I nodded off only a few times during “Green Book,” I consider it pleasant enough by Hollywood standards. The performances by Viggo Mortensen as the bigoted but lovable chauffeur Frank “Tony Lip” Vallenlonga and Mahershala Ali as the dignified pianist Dr. Don Shirley, are solid. Mr. Ali won a best supporting actor Oscar for doing his best with a role that the Shirley family denounced as historically inaccurate.

Advertise with us

“Green Book” was more entertaining than it was enlightening about the Jim Crow era, a period white folks have yet to fully reckon with as a time when the massive inequities and racial advantages established during slavery were codified by law. There’s nothing that takes place in this film that isn’t still happening somewhere in this country, though on a more informal basis.

Prior to last year, when the movie debuted, most white Americans had never heard of “The Negro Travelers’ Green Book” that had once been so essential to navigating huge swaths of the country during Jim Crow.

For black folks of a certain age, the “Green Book” was that heavily underlined and scribbled booklet with tattered pages that sat on coffee tables under piles of Jet and Ebony all year until it was needed.

Though it was descended in spirit from the intelligence gathering that made the Underground Railroad possible, it was considered unremarkable in the middle decades of the 20th century because it was so ubiquitous and utilitarian.

If someone had proposed making a movie called “Green Book” in the ‘50s or early ‘60s, it would’ve been akin to pitching a film called “The Yellow Pages” based on the annual phone directories, though I suspect something called “The White Pages” could have gotten studio financing even then.

Advertise with us

“If Beale Street Could Talk,” a far superior film directed by Barry Jenkins and based on a James Baldwin novel that takes place in roughly the same era, didn’t garner the discussion or the audience “Green Book” did when it was released last year. This is because it lacks the requisite “white savior” or “magic Negro” character capable of absolving America of its original sin. (Cue the #WhiteSaviorSoWhite hashtag).

On the other hand, the sin that doomed “Beale Street” to relative obscurity despite a powerful cast led by Regina King, who took home an Oscar for her role as the film’s empathetic matriarch, was its fidelity to the full spectrum of black life and its indifference to accommodating the white gaze.

The audience’s entertainment comes at a price while watching a movie like “Beale Street” — everyone will go home enlightened about people and situations never experienced on the big screen before.

There’s a scene in “Beale Street” in which Brian Tyree Henry, playing a recently released convict, talks about prison life and how it changed him. It wasn’t the words Mr. Henry used as much as the pauses, the way he exhaled cigarette smoke and sipped his beer over dinner, that impress a viewer. For weeks, I couldn’t stop thinking about Mr. Henry’s mumbling and subtle gestures as he recalled the unutterable things that he experienced behind bars. There was nothing remotely as powerful or memorable in “Green Book.”

But “Green Book” wasn’t designed to be anything more than escapist entertainment, and on that level it succeeds. It is grossly sentimental and bullish about tackling systemic racism with the power of redemptive anecdote: A former bigot is redeemed from his racism by mere proximity to a cultured black man.

Advertise with us

The black man, a musical genius, is, in turn, redeemed by the working class Italian-American “authenticity” of the white man, who promptly introduces him to fried chicken and Little Richard. What’s wrong with this picture, America?

Screenwriter Nick Vallenlonga, the real-life son of the late chauffeur portrayed in the movie, insists he had the late Don Shirley’s blessing to tell the story the way he did and that he was unaware that the pianist had any living family members or he would’ve consulted them.

While that sounds sketchy, there’s no doubt that Mr. Vallenlonga feels he’s written a screenplay in the best tradition of Hollywood liberalism: Everyone gets along by the end of the movie after finally seeing each other as human. It doesn’t have to get any more complex than that. Racism is seen as the expression of maladjusted individuals, not systems.

Director Spike Lee laughed backstage when “Green Book” was announced as 2018’s best film over his own “BlacKkKlansman.” It was a graceless moment on his part, but reflective of a general consensus: “Green Book” is far from the best picture of the year, but it is arguably the most heartwarming for many white Academy of Motion Picture voters.

Meanwhile, we’re all dreading “Green Book’s” inevitable sequel — “Redlining: A Love Story in Black and White.”

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 42-263-1631.